Customer Loyalty is Dead: Here’s What Replaces It in Australia

Ninety-three per cent of Australians belong to at least one loyalty program, according to the 2026 For Love or Money research from The Point of Loyalty. But only half of them are active in all the programs they’ve joined. That gap between membership and meaningful engagement tells you something important: having a card in someone’s digital wallet doesn’t mean you have their loyalty.

Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through them, Britwealth may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We only include products and services that are relevant to the topic.

73%
of Australian consumers likely to try new shopping behaviours
McKinsey & Company

93%
of Australians belong to at least one loyalty program
The Point of Loyalty

50%
are active in every program they have joined
The Point of Loyalty

40%
say they often or always receive personalised offers
The Point of Loyalty

The same research shows that 63 per cent of members believe programs have enough data to tailor relevant offers, yet fewer than two in five actually experience that personalisation. That gap is where loyalty goes to die. The old model—collect points, wait, redeem—no longer matches what Australian consumers expect. They want immediacy, relevance, and value that works across multiple parts of their lives. Here’s what you actually need to know.

The Four Things That Matter Now in Australian Loyalty

Points Alone Won’t Hold Them
Six in ten Australians say membership in a program has changed how they shop, but that influence depends on relevance, not just rewards. Grocery programs influence around 60 per cent of members—up eight percentage points since 2022—while airline programs now affect roughly 70 per cent, a jump of 24 points over the same period.

Personalisation Is the Baseline
63 per cent of members think brands have the data to personalise offers. Only 40 per cent say it actually happens. The gap between what’s collected and what’s delivered is the single biggest reason programs feel irrelevant.

Subscription Models Outperform
Roughly twice as many Australians are in traditional loyalty programs as in subscription models, but subscription programs score 8 to 15 percentage points higher in member satisfaction. Paid programs like Everyday Extra and Amazon Prime lead the Loyalty Program Experience Index.

Ecosystems Beat Standalone Programs
Australian consumers increasingly prefer programs that work across partners. The willingness to “spend points to redeem partner-company products” rose five percentage points since 2022. Major grocery programs now connect with retail, travel, health insurance, and fuel partners.

What this adds up to is a shift from loyalty as a transaction to loyalty as an experience. The term that captures this shift is the loyalty ecosystem.

Loyalty Ecosystem
A network of integrated partners and personalised, AI-enabled experiences that deliver immediate everyday value to members, replacing the old model of delayed points-based rewards with real-time relevance across multiple sectors of a person’s life.

What I tend to notice is that businesses still treat loyalty as a program they run, rather than an experience they design. That distinction matters more now than it did five years ago. If you want to see how the digital side of this shift is playing out, it’s worth looking at how customer experience strategies are evolving for a digital-first Australia.

What Happens When You Stick With the Old Model

The cost of ignoring this shift shows up in hard numbers. Sixteen per cent of nonparticipants now say “it takes too long to earn rewards” is their reason for opting out—up two percentage points since 2022, according to McKinsey’s December 2025 Asia–Pacific Consumer Sentiment Survey. That’s a small number in isolation, but it points to a deeper impatience.

Grocery program usage at nearly every visit has slipped five percentage points since 2022. Meanwhile, nearly a quarter of customers are unaware that loyalty programs exist for specific brands. That’s not a marketing problem—it’s a relevance problem. If a program doesn’t surface naturally in someone’s shopping experience, they won’t remember to use it.

Subscription Programs Pull Ahead
Paid and fee-based loyalty programs score 8 to 15 percentage points higher in member satisfaction than traditional free-to-join programs. The 2026 Loyalty Program Experience Index average rose to 71.9 from 68.6 in 2023, driven largely by subscription models that offer clear, immediate value.

The gap between top-quartile and bottom-quartile programs has widened since 2022. Members of the best programs are roughly twice as likely to increase purchase frequency and 79 per cent more likely to recommend the brand compared to members of the weakest programs. That divergence means the middle ground is shrinking. Programs that don’t improve will fall further behind, not just stay where they are.

Four Gaps That Are Killing Loyalty Programs Today

The Data-Personalisation Disconnect

Brands are collecting more data than ever, but it’s not translating into better experiences. Sixty-three per cent of members believe programs have the volume of data to tailor offers, yet only 40 per cent say they often or always receive personalised and relevant offers. That 23-point gap erodes trust. Members notice when a brand knows their buying history but sends generic discounts. The fix isn’t more data—it’s better use of what you already have.

Ignoring the Gen Z Shift

Gen Z active participation dropped from 48 per cent in 2025 to 40 per cent in 2026, according to the For Love or Money research. That’s the steepest year-on-year decline among any age group. Gen Z prioritises experiences over monetary rewards and is more likely to support brands with sustainability commitments, as KPMG’s Australian Retail Outlook 2026 notes. If your program still treats every member the same, you’ll lose this cohort before they reach their peak spending years.

Slow Rewards Kill Engagement

Sixteen per cent of nonparticipants say earning rewards takes too long, and that figure is rising. The same impatience affects existing members. Programs that require months of purchases before a meaningful reward becomes available train people to forget about the program between transactions. Immediate, small rewards—a discount on the next shop, a free item after three visits—outperform delayed gratification in almost every category.

Operating in a Silo

Australian consumers increasingly prefer programs that integrate across partners. The willingness to use points across different brands rose five percentage points since 2022. Grocery programs that connect with airline partners, fuel discounts, and health insurance see higher engagement and awareness—over 90 per cent for the largest programs. A standalone program with no partner integration feels like a dead end. If you’re designing a new program, or revamping an old one, getting professional advice on business structure and compliance can help you avoid costly missteps before you launch.

Building the New Loyalty Engine: What Actually Works

The research points to a clear direction: move from a points-based transaction model to an ecosystem that delivers personalised, immediate value across multiple touchpoints. Here’s what that means in practice.

Flip the Value Proposition

Instead of “earn points and redeem later,” design for “get value now.” Subscription programs like Everyday Extra and Amazon Prime lead satisfaction scores because the benefit is immediate—free delivery, exclusive pricing, instant discounts. The data shows subscription programs score 8 to 15 percentage points higher in satisfaction than traditional equivalents. That doesn’t mean every business needs a paid tier, but it does mean the core mechanic should deliver something useful on every visit, not just once a year.

Use AI to Close the Personalisation Gap

Seventy-four per cent of Australians are now aware of at least one way AI can enhance a loyalty program, up from 66 per cent in 2025. But only 23 per cent are comfortable with an AI agent managing their purchase journey. The opportunity lies in using AI for behind-the-scenes personalisation—curating offers, predicting what a member will want next, and surfacing the right partner deals—without making the technology itself the focus. Tools like AI-powered marketing platforms can help automate this level of personalisation without requiring a full in-house data team.

Build Real Partner Ecosystems

The most successful Australian programs connect across sectors. One major grocery loyalty program links with more than 20 partner brands across retail, travel, and financial services. Another has deepened its ecosystem through airline points conversion, health insurance, and fuel partnerships. The table below shows how the old and new approaches compare across key dimensions.

→ Scroll right to see all columns

Source: McKinsey Australian Consumer Loyalty
Dimension Old Loyalty Model New Loyalty Ecosystem
Value delivery Points earned over time, delayed redemption Immediate everyday value, instant rewards
Personalisation Segmented groups, one-size-fits-all offers AI-driven, individual-level relevance
Member engagement Passive, transactional, infrequent Active, experiential, continuous
Partner integration Limited or no cross-brand connections Multi-sector ecosystem with seamless points use
Technology backbone Basic transaction tracking, static rules Predictive analytics, AI, mobile-first experience

Design for Clarity First

The For Love or Money research identifies relevance, ease of understanding, and clarity around rules as top drivers of program satisfaction. Complicated tier structures, blackout dates, and points that expire too quickly all push members away. The programs that score highest on the Loyalty Program Experience Index—Flybuys, Everyday Rewards, McDonald’s My Macca’s Rewards—are all simple to understand and use. If a member can’t explain your program in one sentence, it’s too complicated. For businesses looking to integrate loyalty with their broader ecommerce operations, an ecommerce platform that supports multichannel loyalty features can simplify the technical side considerably.

Prepare for the AI-Enabled Future

McKinsey’s research points to four strategic shifts: move from static segmentation to dynamic AI-enabled insight engines; from static tracking to personalised experiences; from siloed programs to integrated ecosystems; and design for clarity and visible everyday value. Case examples include Delta Air Lines’ AI-powered Concierge assistant in its Fly Delta app and Sephora’s use of AI and machine learning to curate offers. These aren’t futuristic concepts—they’re operating now. The next big ideas in Australian business are already being shaped by this kind of technology integration.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are paid subscription loyalty programs worth it for small businesses? ▾
The data shows subscription programs score 8 to 15 points higher in satisfaction, but they require clear, immediate value. For a small business, a low-cost paid tier with instant benefits—free shipping, exclusive access—can work if the economics are tested first.
How do I know if my current loyalty program is underperforming? ▾
Compare your active participation rate against the national average of 50 per cent. If fewer than half your members have used the program in the past year, and if grocery-style usage at nearly every visit has dropped, the program needs a redesign.
Can small businesses compete with Flybuys and Everyday Rewards? ▾
Not on scale, but you can compete on relevance. Small businesses can offer more personalised, immediate rewards than large programs. Partnering with two or three complementary local brands can also create a mini-ecosystem that feels more connected than a national program.
What’s the minimum data I need to start personalising offers? ▾
Purchase history and basic demographics are enough to start. The research shows 63 per cent of members believe brands already have sufficient data. The problem isn’t collecting more—it’s using what you have to deliver relevant offers at the right time.
How concerned should I be about AI trust issues with customers? ▾
Only 23 per cent of Australians are comfortable with an AI agent managing their purchase journey, and overall concern about AI has increased across all measured use cases. Use AI for behind-the-scenes personalisation, not for visible decision-making, until trust improves.
What’s the ideal number of partners for a loyalty ecosystem? ▾
There’s no fixed number, but the most effective Australian programs connect across retail, travel, financial services, and fuel. Start with two or three partners that overlap naturally with your customers’ existing spending patterns, then expand based on usage data.

Loyalty Without the Program Thinking

The most important finding from this research is that loyalty is no longer a program you run—it’s a byproduct of the experience you deliver every day. The brands pulling ahead are those that treat every interaction as a chance to deliver immediate, personalised value, not as another step toward a future reward. The data is clear: Australian consumers will switch behaviours, try new brands, and pay for subscriptions that actually make their lives easier. The ones that don’t adapt will find their membership numbers looking healthy while their engagement numbers tell a different story.

Remember: this article is general information only. For advice on your specific situation, speak to a qualified professional.

If this was useful, you might also want to read Consumer Behaviour in Australia: Trends You Need to Know.

Sources and Further Reading

Building a Brand That Aussies Trust: Authenticity in the Digital Age — Explores how trust and peer recommendations are reshaping brand relationships in Australia, directly relevant to the loyalty ecosystem shift.

Building a Resilient Business: Lessons from Australia’s Recent Challenges — Covers the operational discipline and adaptability that underpin successful loyalty and customer retention strategies.

McKinsey & Company (2025). Australian consumer loyalty: Rapid change calls for rapid solutions. 🔗

The Point of Loyalty (2026). 2026 For Love or Money Research: The 14th Australian Edition. 🔗

KPMG Australia (2026). Australian Retail Outlook 2026. 🔗

Share this

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Email

Sam Willy

I’m Sam Willy, one of the bright minds behind BritWealth.com, where I share insights, stories, and fun ideas about a wide range of topics—finance included, but not limited to it! My journey into the world of writing began with a simple hobby: sharing the things that fascinated me. From quirky facts to deeper dives into personal development, I’ve always been curious about the world around me and love passing that knowledge on.
Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted

Disclaimer

The content published on BritWealth.com is provided for general informational and educational purposes only and should not be considered financial, legal, insurance, tax, investment, or professional advice. You should always carry out your own research or seek independent professional guidance before making financial or business decisions.

Some content on this website may contain affiliate links. This means BritWealth.com may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase, at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, BritWealth earns from qualifying purchases.

While we make reasonable efforts to keep information accurate and up to date, BritWealth.com makes no representations or warranties, express or implied, regarding the completeness, accuracy, reliability, suitability, or availability of any content on this website.

Any reliance you place on information found on this site is strictly at your own risk. BritWealth.com will not be liable for any loss, damage, or consequences arising from the use of this website or reliance on its content.

By using this website, you acknowledge and agree to this disclaimer and our terms of use.

Table of Contents

Share This

On Trend

Readers'
Top Picks

Beyond the 9-to-5: Creating Passive Income Streams for Australian Wealth Seekers

For Australians looking to bolster their income and achieve financial freedom, diversifying beyond the traditional 9-to-5 job is essential. Creating passive income streams can provide that financial cushion, allowing for greater flexibility, security, and ultimately, wealth creation. This article explores various avenues for generating passive income in Australia, providing actionable tips and real-world examples to help you get started. Understanding Passive Income in the Australian Context Passive income, in its purest form, is income earned with minimal ongoing effort. It’s not about ‘get rich quick’ schemes, but rather about investing time and resources upfront to create systems that generate

Read More »

Investing in Yourself: The Ultimate Guide to Personal and Professional Growth for Aussies

Investing in yourself is undoubtedly the most valuable investment you can make. In Australia’s competitive business landscape, continuous personal and professional development is not just an advantage—it’s a necessity for staying relevant, seizing opportunities, and achieving long-term success. This guide provides a comprehensive roadmap for Aussie professionals and entrepreneurs looking to level up their skills, expand their knowledge, and ultimately, unlock their full potential. Understanding the ROI of Self-Investment in the Australian Context Before diving into the how-to, let’s address the why. In Australia, a highly skilled workforce drives innovation and economic growth. According to the Australian Bureau of

Read More »

Sustainability in Business: A Competitive Advantage for Australian Companies

Sustainability isn’t just a buzzword; it’s rapidly becoming a core competitive advantage for Australian businesses. Companies that integrate sustainable practices into their operations are seeing improved financial performance, enhanced brand reputation, increased customer loyalty, and future-proofing their businesses against environmental and social risks. For Australian businesses, operating sustainably is no longer a choice – it’s a strategic imperative. Understanding Sustainability in the Australian Context Sustainability in business refers to integrating environmental, social, and governance (ESG) factors into a company’s operations and strategy. For Australian companies, this means considering the country’s unique environmental challenges, such as climate change impacts, water

Read More »

The Aussie Advantage: Leveraging Our Unique Strengths on the Global Stage

More than four million Australians are currently or previously embedded in key international markets. That’s a talent pool roughly the size of Sydney, spread across the world’s most dynamic economies. And 95 per cent of them want to come back at some point. Here’s what you actually need to know. Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through them, Britwealth may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We only include products and services that are relevant to the topic. This article is general information only and does not constitute

Read More »

Sustainable Business Practices in Australia: Profit and Planet.

María Mendiluce, CEO of the We Mean Business Coalition, put it plainly earlier this year: “We’re moving to a place where being sustainable can be economically beneficial to the company, because they can reduce their costs, potentially increase their sales, without necessarily increasing the price.” That assessment, drawn from the TIME and Statista ranking of the world’s most sustainable companies, captures a shift that’s been building for years. In Australia, the conversation around sustainable business has moved past the ethical-label stage into something more concrete: operational efficiency, supply chain resilience, and regulatory navigation. Here’s what you actually need to

Read More »
Automation & the Aussie Workforce: Opportunity or Threat? A Balanced Perspective.
Business Insights

Automation & the Aussie Workforce: Opportunity or Threat? A Balanced Perspective.

Automation is rapidly transforming the Australian workforce, sparking debates about whether it presents an opportunity for growth and innovation or a significant threat to job security. This article navigates this complex issue, offering a balanced perspective on the potential benefits and challenges of automation, alongside practical advice for businesses and workers adapting to this evolving landscape. The Rise of Automation in Australia Australia’s economy is embracing automation at an accelerating pace. From advanced robotics in mining and agriculture to AI-powered customer service and data analysis in the finance and healthcare sectors, the integration of automated systems is becoming increasingly

Read More »
AUSTRALIA
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x