Baptist World Aid Australia’s Ethical Fashion Report assessed 98 companies representing 420 fashion brands on how they treat workers and the environment. Only four scored A+ across every category. Here’s what you actually need to know.
Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through them, Britwealth may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We only include products and services that are relevant to the topic.
This article is general information only and does not constitute professional advice. For your specific situation, consult a qualified professional.
The report, which covered 420 fashion brands, introduced new questions around modern slavery under the Australian Modern Slavery Act and increased the weighting on environmental factors. Companies were graded on the evidence they could produce — less evidence meant lower grades, regardless of what they claimed internally. That distinction matters because, as the report showed, having a policy on paper and actually enforcing it are two very different things.
This is where the shift toward conscious consumerism collides with reality. Shoppers increasingly want to buy from brands that align with their values, but figuring out which ones actually walk the talk takes some work.
The Gap Between Policy and Practice
Baptist World Aid’s director of advocacy Peter Keegan put it plainly: the largest areas of improvement were in policy and governance, where plenty of As and A+s were awarded. But grades dropped dramatically when it came to enforcing commitments — things like regularly auditing suppliers’ labour conditions. “Companies have taken first steps but not fully integrated through every aspect of operations,” Keegan said.
The numbers back that up. Only 15% of companies could demonstrate they were paying living wages to any workers in the final stages of production. That’s a stubbornly low figure for an industry that’s been under pressure to clean up its supply chains for years.
Dr Rebecca Van Amber, a fashion sustainability expert at RMIT University, noted that reports like this never paint a full picture of what’s happening on the factory floor. Unless someone is physically auditing a facility or has a trusted auditor on the ground, there’s no way to be certain goods aren’t being made at a cheaper facility down the road. Keegan added that if a big global operation claims there’s no slavery in its supply chain, it probably hasn’t looked closely enough or isn’t taking the issue seriously enough.
This gap between what brands say and what they actually do is the central problem for anyone trying to shop ethically. The brands that are winning — the ones scoring A+ ratings — are the ones that can show their work, not just state their intentions.
What Ethical Fashion Actually Means
Georgina Neill Ryan, founder of Slowe Store, breaks it down this way: sustainable fashion focuses on the environmental side — long-term design, manufacturing, and consumption practices. Ethical fashion centres on how humans and animals are treated — living wages, working conditions, animal welfare. Fair trade fashion ensures the people making the product are at the centre of the brand’s mission. These terms get used interchangeably, but they’re not identical. A brand can be sustainable in its materials while being unethical in its labour practices, or vice versa.
The Good On You rating system, which evaluates brands across the three pillars of people, planet, and animals, assesses over 100 key issues including child labour, forced labour, worker safety, carbon emissions, chemical safety, and animal product use. Brands that score well across all three are rare — which is why the four that earned A+ from Baptist World Aid stand out.
How to Identify an Ethical Brand
The most practical tool for Australian shoppers is the Good On You directory, which rates brands on their policies and actions across people, planet, and animals. The platform assesses over 100 key issues and gives each brand an overall rating of Good or Great. It’s not perfect — Dr Van Amber points out that no single report captures everything happening on a factory floor — but it’s a solid starting point.
Beyond checking ratings, there are specific things to look for.
Certifications that mean something. Fairtrade certified cotton, GOTS certification, BSCI membership, and WRAP certification all indicate a brand has submitted to third-party oversight. Sorella Organics, for example, uses Fairtrade certified cotton, which ensures strict social standards. NICO’s factories are signatories to the Bangladesh Fire and Building Safety Accord and are BSCI and WRAP compliant.
Supply chain transparency. Brands that name their factories, disclose material origins, and publish audit results are more likely to be genuine. Arnsdorf, an Australian label, reveals the costs associated with each garment and the origin of its fabrics and materials — a level of transparency that’s still unusual in fashion.
Material choices. Organic cotton, hemp, Tencel, recycled materials, and natural plant-dyed textiles are all lower-impact options. Vege Threads uses 100% GOTS certified organic cotton and hemp. Bassike’s signature jersey cotton is certified carbon neutral by Climate Active, and its t-shirts produce 43% less carbon emissions than conventional cotton equivalents.
Local production. Brands that manufacture in Australia, like Dharma Bums (Ethical Clothing Australia certified) and Citizen Wolf (made-to-measure in Sydney), have shorter supply chains and are easier to audit. Nelson Made produces footwear locally using a small-batch model.
For plus-size shoppers, the options are more limited but growing. Alexcea Apostolakis, a studio assistant for a slow fashion brand in Melbourne, recommends Variety Hour, Sully’s, and Ruby. Annika Nielsen, a model and content creator, favours Less Common, Sanct, and Patience Made. The key, as Nielsen puts it, is to think about cost per wear — a $100 slower-produced top that lasts years versus a $10 fast fashion top that falls apart after a few washes.
Where Brands and Consumers Go Wrong
The Baptist World Aid report revealed some stark failures among well-known Australian retailers. Myer received a D overall, scoring F for both worker empowerment and environmental sustainability — failing to demonstrate any evidence that its final-stage manufacturing facilities paid living wages. Bardot and Boardriders (the company behind Billabong, Quiksilver, and Roxy) both received F ratings across the board. SHEIKE received F in every category. RM Williams scored D, unable to show evidence of living wage payment at any final-stage facility.
→ Scroll right to see all columns
| Brand | Overall Grade | Worker Empowerment | Environmental Sustainability |
|---|---|---|---|
| Myer | D | F | F |
| David Jones | B | C | B |
| Bardot | F | F | F |
| Boardriders (Billabong, Quiksilver, Roxy) | F | F | F |
| RM Williams | D | — | F |
| Lorna Jane | D | — | F |
| SHEIKE | F | F | F |
Some of these brands chose not to participate in the survey, meaning only publicly available information was assessed — which naturally yields lower grades. RM Williams’ chief managing officer Chris Willingham called the report “highly inaccurate,” noting the company had undergone significant changes and had returned to Australian ownership. SHEIKE’s general manager Sandra Kennedy said the brand wasn’t “striving to be known as a sustainable brand” but was trying to minimise its impact. These responses highlight a broader issue: the brands that are most transparent about their challenges often score better than those that stay silent.
On the consumer side, there’s a different kind of problem. Annika Nielsen, who previously estimated her wardrobe was 80% pre-loved, realised she was “fast fashion-ing at op shops” — buying secondhand items because they were cheap or a good brand, only to re-donate them later. The most sustainable garment, she notes, is the one you already own. Shop your closet first, take care of what you have, and think carefully before adding anything new.
There’s also the sizing gap. Many responsibly-produced labels don’t cater to plus sizes, effectively sizing out ethical consumers. As Sam van Zweden wrote for Fashion Journal, if a size exists in a brick-and-mortar store, it’s often on a hidden rack. Online shopping means confusing size guides, postage costs, and returns — what she calls part of the “fat tax.” The scarcity of plus-size clothing extends even to op shops, making thrifting more laborious for larger bodies.
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the difference between ethical and sustainable fashion? ▾
How reliable are ethical fashion ratings? ▾
Which Australian brands are the most ethical? ▾
Is ethical fashion more expensive? ▾
Can I trust brands that say they’re ethical? ▾
Conscious Consumerism Is Still Building
The four brands that scored A+ across the board — Etiko, Joyya, Mighty Good Basics, and Outland Denim — prove it’s possible to treat workers fairly, minimise environmental harm, and run a viable fashion business. But they’re outliers. The majority of the 98 companies assessed still can’t demonstrate basic living wage payment, and the gap between policy and enforcement remains wide.
What’s changing is the pressure. The Australian Modern Slavery Act is forcing companies to ask harder questions about their supply chains. Consumers have better tools than ever — Good On You’s directory, the Baptist World Aid report, and a growing number of transparent brands that make their practices public. The brands that are winning are the ones that treat transparency as a feature, not a risk.
If this was useful, you might also want to read The Importance of Company Culture: Creating a Positive and Productive Workplace.
Remember: this article is general information only. For advice on your specific situation, speak to a qualified professional.
Sources and Further Reading
The Power of Mentorship: Unleashing Potential in the Australian Business Landscape — How mentorship drives growth in Australian business, relevant for founders building ethical brands.
Baptist World Aid Australia (2021). Ethical Fashion Report. 🔗
Good On You (2026). Most Ethical and Sustainable Clothing Brands from Australia and New Zealand. 🔗
Marie Claire Australia. Ethical Fashion Brands. 🔗
Fashion Journal (2025). Ethical Plus Size Fashion Australia. 🔗