Most drivers think they understand car insurance. Then a claim gets denied, or the renewal quote jumps for no obvious reason, and it turns out a lot of what people assume about their policy is just wrong. A survey by Ratehub found the average Canadian got only five out of ten common insurance myths right. Here’s what you actually need to know.
This article is general information only and does not constitute professional advice. For your specific situation, consult a qualified professional.
Some of these myths are harmless. Others cost you money or leave you without cover when you need it most. Let’s run through the ones that actually matter.
What your policy actually covers
The gap between what people think their insurance does and what it actually covers is where the expensive surprises live.
Third-party insurance does not cover theft of your car
This is the one that catches people off guard. Third-party insurance is mandatory in many places — India, for example, requires it for all motor vehicles — but it only covers liability for injury, death, or damage you cause to another person or their property. It does not pay out if your own car is stolen. Theft of the insured vehicle falls under own-damage protection, which you only get with a comprehensive policy or a standalone own-damage policy. If you’re driving around on basic third-party cover thinking you’re protected against theft, you’re not.
If your car is stolen and the thief causes damage, you’re usually not liable
Ray Blackburn, product manager at Toyota Insurance, notes that assuming the car was genuinely stolen — not taken by a family member without permission, and not left with keys in plain view — there is generally no liability on the owner when the thief causes an accident. Each case has its own facts, and an attorney can help sort out the edge cases, but the broad rule is: a thief’s damage doesn’t become your bill.
Ridesharing and delivery need a separate conversation with your insurer
Using your car for commercial purposes — Uber, DoorDash, any activity where you earn income — changes the risk profile. The Ratehub survey found 72% of Canadians know they need to tell their insurer about this, which means 28% don’t. If you haven’t notified your insurer and you have an accident while delivering food or carrying passengers, your claim can be denied outright. Only a handful of insurers offer policies that cover ridesharing and delivery, so shop around if that’s part of your plan.
What actually drives your premium
A lot of the conventional wisdom about what makes insurance expensive is wrong. Here’s what the data actually says.
Car colour doesn’t matter
Red cars, yellow cars, matte black wraps — none of it affects your premium. Blackburn states plainly that colour does not influence insurance premiums. The myth probably persists because people assume flashy colours attract more tickets, and tickets affect premiums. But the colour itself is not a rating factor.
Number of doors isn’t a direct factor either
Two doors versus four doesn’t directly change your rate. What matters is the insurer’s loss experience with that specific vehicle type. If a two-door version of a model generates more claims cost than the four-door version, the insurer may charge more for the two-door. But it’s the claims data driving the difference, not the door count.
Your credit score matters — in most places
In most US states, insurers use credit-based insurance scores alongside driving record and claims history when setting premiums. Studies show drivers with higher credit scores tend to file fewer claims, and insurers treat a strong score as a sign of lower risk. This isn’t universal — some states prohibit or restrict the practice — but where it’s allowed, your credit history directly affects what you pay.
Where you live and how much you drive
Postal code matters more than most people realise. The Ratehub survey found 66% of Canadians now know it affects their rate, up from 39% in 2019. Dense urban areas with more congestion, confusing intersections, and higher theft rates mean higher premiums. The same logic applies to annual kilometres — more time on the road means more exposure to accidents. 24% of Canadians still think mileage doesn’t affect their rate, but it does.
The age curve isn’t what you think
Young drivers pay the most — NRMA comprehensive quotes for an 18-year-old driver in Sydney are the highest, dropping sharply by age 25. But older drivers don’t keep getting cheaper forever. CHOICE data shows drivers aged 60–69 pay the lowest average comprehensive premium in Australia at $1,312 per year. Drivers 70 and over pay slightly more at $1,358. Drive.com.au quotes for a 2026 Toyota RAV4 show premiums climbing sharply after age 69, with an 85-year-old paying $735 more per year than a 75-year-old. The sweet spot is around 69, not 80.
New cars aren’t always expensive to insure
Newer vehicles cost more to repair or replace, which tends to push premiums up. But safety features — automatic braking, anti-theft systems, collision avoidance technology — can pull them back down. Insurers factor in the risk of injury, theft, and damage, so a car with strong safety ratings and good theft-deterrent features may cost less to insure than an older model without them.
How claims actually work
The claims process is another area where myths cause real problems. A few things worth getting straight.
Not-at-fault accidents can still raise your rates
This one surprises a lot of people. Blackburn notes that insurers increasingly find that customers involved in any accident — even ones where they weren’t at fault — have a higher likelihood of having a future accident that is their fault. The reasons aren’t fully clear, but the result is that some insurers factor not-at-fault accidents into new customer quotes. It’s not legal everywhere, but it happens in many markets.
Police don’t determine fault — insurers do
35% of Canadians in the Ratehub survey believed police decide who’s at fault in an accident. They don’t. The insurance company makes that determination based on policy terms and the facts of the incident. In a no-fault system, you deal with your own insurer regardless of fault, but you can still be found anywhere from 0% to 100% at fault. Parking lot collisions often end up split 50/50.
Your insurer will find out about past tickets and accidents
73% of Canadians know this, but 13% think the insurer will never find out, and 14% aren’t sure. Once a ticket is paid or a conviction recorded, it goes on your driving abstract. Insurers check this record, typically at renewal. You don’t need to volunteer the information — they’ll see it.
Your premium can go up even if you never make a claim
Only 46% of Canadians know this. If thefts spike in your area, or there’s a wave of hail damage claims across the region, or the insurer’s own financial position changes, your premium can rise even with a clean record. This is why letting your policy auto-renew without checking the market rate every year is a bad habit.
FAQ
Does a red car really cost more to insure? ▾
Will a speeding ticket under 15 km/h affect my insurance? ▾
Do red-light camera tickets raise my insurance rates? ▾
If someone steals my car and crashes it, am I liable for the damage? ▾
Does car insurance follow the driver or the car? ▾
Can my insurance go up if I never make a claim? ▾
Don’t let what you don’t know cost you
The myths that stick around are the ones that sound plausible. Red cars cost more — sure, that almost makes sense. Third-party insurance covers everything — well, it’s called insurance, isn’t it? But the gap between what people assume and what their policy actually says is where the real money gets wasted. A few minutes checking your policy type, asking about discounts, and comparing rates at renewal can save hundreds a year. And if you’re relying on third-party cover thinking it protects your own car, that’s the one myth worth fixing today.
Remember: this article is general information only. For advice on your specific situation, speak to a qualified professional.
If this was useful, you might also want to read Shocking Car Insurance Facts Every Aussie Driver Needs to Know.
Sources and Further Reading
How Your Driving History Impacts Car Insurance Premiums in Australia — A closer look at how claims, tickets, and demerit points affect what you pay.
Ratehub (2025). 10 Insurance Myths Worth Knowing. 🔗
CHOICE. Car insurance policies to avoid. 🔗
AutoGuide (2025). Busting Popular Insurance Myths. 🔗
Money (2025). Myths About Car Insurance Costs. 🔗
Finchannel (2026). Myth-Busted: Does Third-Party Insurance Cover Theft? 🔗
Drive.com.au (2025). How your age prices you out of car insurance. 🔗