Your driving history is the single biggest factor determining what you’ll pay for car insurance in Australia, and most drivers don’t realise how much control they actually have over it. A man under 25 pays about 2.2 times what a driver over 50 pays for the same comprehensive cover, according to Canstar’s 2026 Star Ratings. Here’s what you actually need to know.
Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through them, Britwealth may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We only include products and services that are relevant to the topic.
This article is general information only and does not constitute professional advice. For your specific situation, consult a qualified professional.
Those numbers reflect how insurers read your age, experience, and claims history to set your price. The gap between what you’re paying now and what you could be paying — for the same cover — is often bigger than people realise.
What’s at stake when your history isn’t read right
The most obvious cost is straightforward: you pay more than you need to. But there’s a less visible one. If your driving history isn’t accurately represented on your policy — whether through an honest mistake or a deliberate omission — you risk having a claim reduced or refused entirely. That’s not a premium problem; that’s a financial disaster.
Take the common example of an undeclared regular driver. You save maybe $100 a year by not listing your partner who drives the car daily. If that partner has an at-fault crash, the insurer can refuse the claim. The cost of the car lands entirely on you. Undeclared modifications and unlisted regular drivers are among the most common reasons claims get reduced or declined, based on industry claims data.
Then there’s the slow bleed of auto-renewal. Insurers price renewals assuming you won’t check. The average Australian could save about $651 a year just by comparing three quotes. In Victoria, where the average premium is $3,293, a five-star rated policy averages $2,458 — a saving of $835.
The point isn’t that insurers are out to get you. Their pricing models are built around statistical risk, and your driving history is the main input. If you don’t understand how that input is being read, you’re leaving money on the table — or worse, setting yourself up for a refused claim.
How insurers actually read your driving history
Insurers use your driving history to answer one question: how likely are you to make a claim, and how much will that claim cost? Every factor in your history feeds into that calculation.
Age and experience
This is the biggest single factor, and it’s almost entirely driven by claims data. Younger drivers — particularly under 25 — have statistically more accidents. That shows up in the premiums. The Canstar data puts the under-25 male average at $3,158 a year, compared to $1,451 for drivers 50 and over. That’s a gap of about $1,700 a year.
Most people miss this: the 25-to-29 bracket averages $2,367, and the 30-to-49 bracket drops to $1,841. The biggest drop happens between 25 and 30, not at 50. If you’re in your late twenties with a clean record, you’re already being priced much closer to the over-50s than to the under-25s.
Claims history and no-claim bonus
Your no-claim bonus is the single most valuable thing in your driving history. Each year without an at-fault claim pushes your premium down. One at-fault claim can affect your premiums for three to five years, depending on the insurer.
The trap here is small claims. If your total excess is $1,300 and the repair quote is $1,700, you’d only recover $400 from the claim. But that claim can cost you several hundred dollars a year in higher premiums for the next few renewals. Over three years, you’re often worse off than if you’d just paid the repair yourself. Always ask your insurer what your renewal would look like with and without the claim before you lodge it.
Where you live and where you park
Your postcode feeds into the calculation through local theft rates, accident statistics, and weather risk. Victoria has the highest average premium at $3,293, partly due to dense traffic, higher vehicle values, and a run of severe hail and storm claims. Tasmania averages $2,014 — lower congestion, cheaper vehicles, fewer catastrophic events.
Where you park overnight also matters. A locked garage is cheaper to insure than street parking. If you can change where you park, it’s worth doing.
What you drive and how you use it
The make and model of your car affects repair costs and theft appeal. Two cars of identical value can differ by hundreds of dollars a year in premiums. If you’re in the market for a car, get insurance quotes on specific models before you commit.
How you use the vehicle matters too. Standard comprehensive policies exclude carrying passengers or goods for payment. If you drive for Uber, DiDi, or a delivery platform, you need a policy that specifically covers rideshare or delivery use. Driving commercially on a standard policy means your claim will be denied.
Common mistakes that cost you money
Auto-renewing without checking
This is the single most expensive mistake you can make. Insurers price renewals assuming you won’t compare. Getting three fresh quotes every year — including one from your current insurer as a new customer — is worth more than every other tip combined. New-customer prices are frequently lower than renewal prices for identical cover.
Not declaring modifications or regular drivers
Alloy wheels, suspension changes, a partner who drives the car daily but isn’t on the policy — these are the most common reasons claims are reduced or refused. The saving from not declaring them might be $100 a year. The cost of a refused claim is the whole car. Declare everything.
Not transferring your overseas no-claim bonus
If you’ve recently moved to Australia, your overseas driving history may count — but only if you ask. Several Australian insurers recognise overseas no-claim history if you can provide evidence. Almost none volunteer this, and it’s rarely on the quote form. Before you leave your previous country, get a written no-claims letter on company letterhead stating the consecutive years you held the policy and that you had no at-fault claims. Then ring Australian insurers and ask directly whether they recognise overseas driving history. Being rated as a brand-new driver when you have 20 years of clean driving can cost you hundreds of dollars a year.
Choosing the wrong excess
A higher excess usually means a lower premium. Going from $500 to $1,500 can cut your premium noticeably. But only do this if you could actually produce $1,500 tomorrow. Setting an excess you can’t afford defeats the purpose of having insurance.
Not understanding what CTP actually covers
CTP — the green slip in NSW — covers injury to people only. It pays nothing towards damage to any vehicle. If all you’ve paid is your registration, your car and the other driver’s car are both uninsured. Third party property cover at $400 to $900 a year is the cheapest way to remove that risk.
What you can actually do about it
Here’s the practical list, roughly in order of impact.
Shop around every year without exception. This dwarfs everything else. The average saving is $651, and in high-premium states like Victoria and NSW it’s over $800. Use comparison sites, get quotes from individual insurers, and include your current insurer as a new customer.
Ring and say you’re leaving. Retention teams have discounts that never appear on renewal notices. It costs ten minutes.
Pay annually, not monthly. Monthly instalments commonly cost more overall. If your cash flow allows it, paying upfront is a guaranteed return.
Raise your excess deliberately. But only to a level you could actually pay tomorrow.
Restrict or remove young drivers from the policy. Listing an under-25 driver can add a lot to the premium. If they only drive occasionally, check whether the unlisted-driver excess is cheaper than listing them permanently.
Choose market value over agreed value for an ordinary depreciating car with no loan against it. Agreed value costs more and you probably don’t need it unless you have a loan, a classic car, or something unusual.
Take the low-kilometre option if you qualify. Many people drive less than they estimate. Check your last two service receipts for real odometer readings.
Ask about occupation and membership discounts. Some insurers discount for certain professions or motoring club membership.
Bundle home and car only if the bundled total genuinely beats two separately shopped policies. Often it doesn’t.
Frequently asked questions
Does my car colour affect my premium? ▾
Will a not-at-fault claim affect my premium? ▾
Can I insure a car on an overseas licence? ▾
When does comprehensive insurance stop making sense? ▾
Does gender really affect the price? ▾
Your history is your leverage
The way insurers read your driving history isn’t a mystery. Age, experience, claims record, where you live, what you drive, how you use it — these are the inputs. The output is a price, but that price is never final until you’ve compared it against the market.
The single most important thing you can do is never auto-renew. Get three quotes every year. Call your current insurer and tell them you’re considering leaving. The gap between loyalty and shopping around is worth hundreds of dollars a year, and it’s the one thing you can change starting today.
If this was useful, you might also want to read Maximize Your Savings with These Car Insurance Tips in Australia.
Sources and Further Reading
Car Insurance Jargon Explained: Finally Understand Your Policy — A plain-English guide to the terms insurers use, from excess to no-claim bonus.
Top Tips for Getting Temporary Car Insurance in Australia — What to know if you need short-term cover for a borrowed or newly purchased vehicle.
Canstar (2026). Car Insurance Star Ratings 2026. 🔗
Australian Securities and Investments Commission, Moneysmart (2026). Choosing car insurance. 🔗
Allianz Australia (2026). How your car insurance premium is calculated. 🔗
Suncorp Insurance (2026). Why premiums change. 🔗