Is That Cheap Car Insurance REALLY Worth It? The Hidden Costs Exposed

You spot a car insurance deal online for $60 a month. That’s nearly half the national average of $101.70. Feels like a win. But what you don’t see yet is the fine print that could cost you thousands if you actually need to claim. The gap between a cheap premium and a policy that pays out when you need it is often wider than people realise.

Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through them, Britwealth may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We only include products and services that are relevant to the topic.

This article is general information only and does not constitute professional advice. For your specific situation, consult a qualified professional.

$1,220
Average annual comprehensive premium (Australia)
Compare the Market

$142.70
Average monthly premium for drivers aged 18–24
Canstar

$72.70
Average monthly premium for drivers aged 65+
Compare the Market

15%
First-year online discount (Budget Direct)
Finder

That $60 monthly deal might come from an insurer that caps liability limits below what other providers offer, or excludes cover for personal items like your phone or laptop. The real cost of cheap car insurance isn’t always the premium — it’s what you lose when you claim. Here’s what you actually need to know.

What Cheap Car Insurance Actually Covers (and What It Doesn’t)

Lower liability limits
Some budget policies cap the amount the insurer pays if you damage someone else’s property. If costs exceed that limit, you’re personally on the hook for the difference.

No cover for personal items
Policies from ROLLiN’ and Budget Direct don’t cover personal belongings like phones or laptops if they’re damaged or stolen from your car. That’s a gap many don’t spot until it’s too late.

Age excess charges
Bingle charges an extra $600 excess if the driver is under 25. ROLLiN’ doesn’t, which can save younger drivers hundreds on a claim.

Roadside assistance limits
Youi includes roadside assistance automatically, but only covers the first two call-outs per year. After that, you pay.

When you’re comparing policies, the first thing to check isn’t the monthly figure — it’s the product disclosure statement (PDS). That’s where the real differences live. One term you’ll see a lot is excess — the amount you pay out of pocket when you make a claim.

Excess
The fixed amount you pay toward a claim before your insurer covers the rest. A higher excess usually lowers your premium, but means more cash upfront if you need to claim.

What I tend to notice is that people focus on the premium and skip the excess structure. That’s where the hidden costs live. A policy with a $60 monthly premium and a $2,000 excess might cost you less per month but more overall if you claim every few years. Worth weighing against a policy with a slightly higher premium and a $400 excess.

How Age, Location, and Gender Shift Your Premium

Your premium isn’t random. Insurers price risk based on who you are, where you live, and how old you are. The differences are bigger than most people expect.

The age gap costs young drivers $840 a year
Drivers aged 18–24 pay an average of $142.70 per month. Drivers aged 65+ pay $72.70. That’s a difference of $70 per month — or $840 per year — for the same level of cover.

Location matters almost as much. In New South Wales, the average monthly premium is $120. In Western Australia, it’s $88.60. That’s a $376 annual difference just for living in a different state. Gender also plays a role, though the gap is smaller: men pay $103.80 on average, women $99.80.

→ Scroll right to see all columns

Source: Compare the Market data
Age group Monthly premium Annual premium
18–24 $142.70 $1,712.40
25–34 $114.20 $1,370.40
35–44 $105.20 $1,262.40
45–54 $106.20 $1,274.40
55–64 $91.20 $1,094.40
65+ $72.70 $872.40

If you’re under 25, the cheapest option isn’t necessarily the one with the lowest monthly payment. ROLLiN’ doesn’t charge an additional age excess for under-25s, while Bingle adds $600. That means a cheaper monthly premium from Bingle could cost you more if you actually claim. The same logic applies to location — if you live in NSW, your baseline is higher, so comparing policies from different states doesn’t help. Compare within your own postcode.

Three Mistakes That Cost You More Than the Premium Saves

Choosing the lowest excess without checking the fine print

A low excess sounds good until you realise it’s tied to a policy that excludes cover for things you’d expect to be included. Budget Direct, for example, offers a 15% first-year discount but has a lower liability limit than many competitors. If you cause significant damage to someone else’s property and the cost exceeds that limit, you pay the rest. That gap can run into tens of thousands. The fix? Read the PDS before you buy. If you’re unsure about the legal language, services like JustAnswer Finance can help clarify what you’re signing up for.

Paying monthly instead of annually

Most insurers charge more if you pay monthly. The difference isn’t always obvious because it’s baked into the monthly figure. Paying annually can save you the equivalent of one to two months’ premium per year. If you can afford the lump sum, it’s one of the simplest ways to cut costs without changing your cover level. Set a calendar reminder a month before renewal so you have time to move the money.

Not shopping around at renewal

Loyalty doesn’t pay in car insurance. Many providers offer the best deals to new customers, then quietly increase premiums at renewal. The 15% first-year discount from Budget Direct is a good example — it’s only available when you buy online, and it doesn’t apply in year two. Set a reminder to compare quotes at least two weeks before your policy ends. Use a comparison site, but also check the insurer’s own website directly — some deals only appear there.

How to Pick the Right Policy for Your Situation

Match your excess to your savings

Your excess should be an amount you could pay tomorrow without borrowing. If you have $2,000 in savings, a $2,000 excess is risky — one claim wipes out your buffer. A $500 excess is safer, even if the premium is slightly higher. The trade-off is real: a higher excess lowers your monthly cost but increases your financial risk. Run the numbers for your own situation before deciding.

Check what’s excluded, not just what’s included

Every policy has exclusions. ROLLiN’ doesn’t cover personal items like phones or laptops. Youi’s roadside assistance covers only two call-outs per year. Budget Direct’s liability limit is lower than competitors. Make a list of what matters to you — do you carry expensive gear in your car? Do you drive long distances where breakdown cover is important? — and check each policy against that list. A policy that excludes something you rely on isn’t cheap; it’s incomplete.

Consider the insurer’s claims reputation

A cheap policy is worthless if the insurer fights every claim. Youi has a customer satisfaction rating of 4.38 out of 5, with 93% of customers saying they’d recommend it. That’s a strong signal. Budget Direct scores 9.9 on Finder’s rating system, which weighs both price and features. Check independent review sites and customer satisfaction awards before you buy. A $10 monthly saving isn’t worth it if you spend hours on the phone fighting for a payout.

What’s changing in the market

Insurers are increasingly using credit-based insurance scores to set premiums in some regions. That means your financial history could affect your car insurance cost, even if you’ve never made a claim. If you’re planning a major credit application — a home loan, for example — check your credit report before shopping for insurance. A clean report could save you more than any discount code. Also watch for climate-related changes: some insurers are adjusting premiums based on extreme weather risk in your area, which could shift costs significantly in the next few years.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does cheap car insurance cover rental cars? ▾
Not always. Bingle includes a hire car for any covered incident. Budget Direct and ROLLiN’ may not. Check the PDS for “hire car” or “courtesy car” wording.
Can I lower my premium by adding a second driver? ▾
It depends. Adding an older, experienced driver with a clean record can lower the risk profile. Adding a young driver usually raises it. Run a quote both ways.
What happens if I miss a monthly payment? ▾
Most insurers will cancel your policy after a grace period. You’ll lose any no-claim bonus and may struggle to get affordable cover elsewhere. Set up automatic payments.
Is third-party fire and theft cheaper than comprehensive? ▾
Usually yes, but it only covers damage to other people’s property, plus fire and theft of your own car. It won’t cover your car in an at-fault accident. For older cars worth under $5,000, it can make sense.
Does a dashcam lower my premium? ▾
Some insurers offer a small discount for having a dashcam, but it’s not universal. It can help with claims disputes, which may protect your no-claim bonus. Check with your insurer before buying one.
Can I switch insurers mid-policy? ▾
Yes, but you may lose the premium you’ve already paid. ROLLiN’ has no exit fee if you cancel. Other insurers may charge an administration fee. Compare the cost of switching versus waiting until renewal.

The Real Cost of Cheap Insurance Isn’t the Monthly Bill

The cheapest policy on the market can still leave you exposed if it doesn’t match your circumstances. A $60 monthly premium that excludes personal items, caps liability, and charges an age excess could end up costing you more than a $90 policy that covers what you actually need. The research shows that age, location, and gender create huge price differences — but the biggest gap is between what you think you’re covered for and what the policy actually pays out. Read the PDS, compare exclusions, and check the insurer’s claims reputation before you buy.

Remember: this article is general information only. For advice on your specific situation, speak to a qualified professional.

If this was useful, you might also want to read Does Your Location Impact Your Car Insurance Premiums in Australia? We Investigate.

Sources and Further Reading

Uninsured Drivers in Australia: How to Protect Yourself — What happens if you’re hit by an uninsured driver and how to cover that risk.

Understanding Third-Party Fire and Theft Insurance in Australia — A breakdown of when this cheaper option makes sense and when it doesn’t.

Finder (2026). Cheap Car Insurance. 🔗

Canstar (2026). Best Car Insurance Australia. 🔗

Forbes Advisor (2026). Cheap Car Insurance. 🔗

Compare the Market (2021). Average Cost of Car Insurance. 🔗

Share this

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Email

Sam Willy

I’m Sam Willy, one of the bright minds behind BritWealth.com, where I share insights, stories, and fun ideas about a wide range of topics—finance included, but not limited to it! My journey into the world of writing began with a simple hobby: sharing the things that fascinated me. From quirky facts to deeper dives into personal development, I’ve always been curious about the world around me and love passing that knowledge on.

Comments are closed.

Disclaimer

The content published on BritWealth.com is provided for general informational and educational purposes only and should not be considered financial, legal, insurance, tax, investment, or professional advice. You should always carry out your own research or seek independent professional guidance before making financial or business decisions.

Some content on this website may contain affiliate links. This means BritWealth.com may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase, at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, BritWealth earns from qualifying purchases.

While we make reasonable efforts to keep information accurate and up to date, BritWealth.com makes no representations or warranties, express or implied, regarding the completeness, accuracy, reliability, suitability, or availability of any content on this website.

Any reliance you place on information found on this site is strictly at your own risk. BritWealth.com will not be liable for any loss, damage, or consequences arising from the use of this website or reliance on its content.

By using this website, you acknowledge and agree to this disclaimer and our terms of use.

Table of Contents

Share This

On Trend

Readers'
Top Picks

Car Insurance Loyalty: Is it Costing You Money in the Long Run, Australia?

Sticking with the same car insurance company year after year might feel comfortable, but in Australia, loyalty doesn’t always pay off. In many cases, it can actually be costing you money. Insurance companies often lure in new customers with attractive introductory offers, then gradually increase premiums over time, hoping loyal customers won’t notice or won’t bother switching. The Loyalty Trap: How Car Insurance Premiums Creep Up The car insurance industry in Australia is fiercely competitive. Insurers constantly try to attract new business with enticing discounts and promotional rates. This creates a dynamic where new customers often receive the best

Read More »

Understanding Voluntary Excess Options For Car Insurance

Understanding voluntary excess options can dramatically improve your car insurance experience in Australia. In a nutshell, it’s all about balancing lower premiums with potential out-of-pocket costs when you make a claim. This article breaks down voluntary excess, offering practical advice to help you make smart choices. What is Voluntary Excess, Really? Voluntary excess, which you might also hear called voluntary deductible, is the amount of money you choose to pay towards a car insurance claim, on top of what your insurer already requires (the compulsory excess). Think of it as your “skin in the game.” By agreeing to pay

Read More »

Tips To Lower Your Monthly Premium Car Insurance Costs

Car insurance can be a significant monthly expense for Australian drivers, but there are several ways you can lower your premium. By being proactive and informed, you can save money while still getting the coverage you need. Understand Your Insurance Needs Before you start looking for ways to reduce your premium, it’s essential to understand your insurance needs. Are you driving a new car that requires comprehensive coverage, or is a third-party policy sufficient for an older vehicle? Knowing what type of insurance you need can prevent you from overpaying. Many people opt for comprehensive insurance not realizing that

Read More »

Modifications & Insurance: Are Your Aussie Car Upgrades Covered?

Modifying your car in Australia can significantly enhance its performance, aesthetics, or functionality. However, failing to inform your car insurance provider about these modifications can lead to denied claims and a voided policy. Understanding how modifications affect your insurance and taking the necessary steps to ensure coverage is crucial for peace of mind and financial protection. Navigating the Complex World of Car Modifications and Insurance The relationship between car modifications and insurance coverage is often complex and misunderstood. While some modifications may seem harmless, insurers view them through the lens of increased risk. This risk can stem from a

Read More »
The Future of Car Insurance: Autonomous Vehicles and Aussie Roads
Car Insurance

The Future of Car Insurance: Autonomous Vehicles and Aussie Roads

The rise of self-driving cars promises safer roads, but it’s also shaking up the car insurance world. As these vehicles become more common in Australia, it’s crucial to understand how insurance will change, who will be responsible when accidents happen, and what it all means for you as a driver (or, soon, a passenger). Understanding Autonomous Vehicles First, let’s break down what we mean by “autonomous vehicles.” These aren’t just cars with cruise control. Self-driving cars, also known as driverless vehicles, use advanced technology to navigate roads without direct human input. KIRO7 explains that these cars utilize complex systems

Read More »

Top Tips For Finding Affordable Car Insurance In Australia

Finding affordable car insurance in Australia definitely doesn’t have to be an uphill battle. With so many insurers out there and lots of things to consider, it’s super important to get a good grip on how things work. This article will walk you through easy-to-understand tips and tricks to help you snag the best car insurance deal without skimping on the coverage you really need. Get to Know the Car Insurance Options In Australia, you’ve got three main types of car insurance to choose from: third-party, third-party fire and theft, and comprehensive. Getting your head around each one will

Read More »
AUSTRALIA