Is Your Car Insurance Really Worth It in Australia? The Truth Revealed.

Car insurance in Australia has become a serious financial question. The average annual comprehensive premium hit $2,226 in 2025, up $122 from the year before. For a family on a typical budget, that’s a bill that demands a second look. Here’s what you actually need to know.

Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through them, Britwealth may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We only include products and services that are relevant to the topic.

This article is general information only and does not constitute professional advice. For your specific situation, consult a qualified professional.

$2,226
Average annual comprehensive premium (2025)
Canstar

$692
Average savings by switching to a top-rated policy
Canstar

$312
Extra paid per year by loyal customers (loyalty tax)
ASIC

77%
Australian drivers with comprehensive cover
Youi

Comprehensive cover protects your own vehicle against accidental damage, theft, storms, hail, and floods. It also covers third-party property damage. But the cost has climbed 25% between 2022 and 2024 alone, according to Canstar’s pricing analysis. That’s faster than general inflation over the same period. The question isn’t whether you need insurance — it’s whether the policy you’re paying for is actually worth what it costs.

Here’s what you actually need to know.

What This Article Reveals About Your Car Insurance

Loyalty costs real money
Staying with the same insurer costs you $312 more per year on average than switching to a new customer deal. That’s a loyalty tax, not a reward.

Switching saves hundreds
Drivers who switch to a top-rated 5-star policy save $692 on average. Victorian drivers save $967. Young male drivers can save up to $1,000.

Comprehensive isn’t always the answer
For older, low-value cars, third-party property cover may make more financial sense. Comprehensive cover costs $2,226 on average — that’s a lot if your car is worth $5,000.

Rates are still climbing
Premiums rose 4.4% between January 2025 and January 2026. New car prices jumped up to 39% between 2019 and 2024, pushing repair costs higher.

One term you’ll hear a lot is loyalty tax. It’s the extra amount existing customers pay compared to new customers for the same cover. The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) found that figure sits at $312 per year. That’s not a discount for staying — it’s a penalty.

Loyalty Tax
The extra amount existing insurance customers pay compared to new customers for an equivalent policy. ASIC found this averages $312 per year in Australian car insurance.

What Comprehensive Cover Actually Costs — By State and Driver Profile

The national average of $2,226 hides big differences depending on where you live and who you are. Victorian drivers pay the most at $2,940 — that’s $714 above the national average. Young male drivers under 25 face an average premium of $3,020. Families with a typical profile pay $2,747.

Victorian drivers pay $225 more than last year
The average Victorian premium rose 8.3% in a single year — the steepest state increase. That’s $2,940 for comprehensive cover. Switching to a top-rated policy could save Victorian drivers $967.

Here’s how the numbers break down across different driver profiles and what they mean for your wallet.

→ Scroll right to see all columns

Source: Canstar pricing data
Driver Profile Average Annual Premium Potential Savings by Switching
National average $2,226 $692
Victorian driver $2,940 $967
Young male (under 25) $3,020 Up to $1,000
Family profile $2,747 $1,000

What this means in practice: a young male driver in Victoria paying $3,020 could switch to a top-rated 5-star policy and pay around $2,020 — saving a full $1,000. That’s not a small discount. That’s a month’s rent for many people. The gap between what you’re paying and what you could be paying is wider than most drivers realise.

Comprehensive cover increased 25% between 2022 and 2024. New car prices rose up to 39% over the same period, and used car prices climbed around 32%. When cars cost more to repair or replace, insurers pass that cost on. Total losses — where a car is written off — account for roughly 25% of all claims costs, according to industry data.

Three Mistakes That Cost Australian Drivers Hundreds

Sticking with the same insurer year after year

This is the most expensive habit. The ASIC review found loyal customers pay $312 more per year than new customers. Over five years, that’s $1,560 lost to inertia. What I tend to notice is that people assume their insurer will reward them for staying. The data shows the opposite. The fix is straightforward: get quotes from at least three providers at renewal time. You don’t even need to switch every year — just getting a competing quote often triggers a retention offer from your current insurer. The process takes about 20 minutes online.

Buying comprehensive cover for a car worth less than $5,000

If your car is worth $5,000 and you’re paying $2,226 a year for comprehensive cover, you’re insuring a car that could be replaced for just over two years of premiums. Third-party property cover costs significantly less — often under $500 — and still covers damage you cause to other people’s vehicles. The trade-off is that your own car isn’t covered if you’re at fault. But for an older car, that’s often a risk worth taking. A good rule of thumb: if the annual premium is more than 30% of the car’s market value, comprehensive cover is hard to justify.

Ignoring the excess level when choosing a policy

A lower excess means a higher premium, and vice versa. Many drivers pick the lowest excess without realising they’re paying hundreds extra each year for a benefit they may never use. If you have savings to cover a $1,000 excess, choosing a higher excess can cut your premium by 15–25%. Just make sure you actually have that cash set aside. The unspoken truth about car insurance excess is that most people don’t check their excess until they need to claim — by then it’s too late to change it.

How to Decide What Cover You Actually Need — and How to Get It

Assess your car’s value first

Look up your car’s current market value on a site like RedBook or Carsales. If it’s under $10,000, third-party property cover is worth serious consideration. If it’s under $5,000, comprehensive cover is almost certainly overkill. The premium you save can go toward your next car instead.

Compare at least three policies at renewal

Use a comparison site like Canstar or Mozo. Look at the 5-star rated policies — they average $1,534 per year, which is $692 below the national average. Check what’s included: roadside assist, hire car after a not-at-fault accident, and towing costs are common inclusions on better policies. Don’t just compare the premium — check the excess, the sum insured, and any exclusions for things like driving under 25 or modifications.

Watch for the loyalty tax at renewal

When your renewal letter arrives, don’t just pay it. The premium quoted is almost certainly higher than what a new customer would pay. Call your insurer and ask for a better deal. If they won’t budge, switch. The process is simple: your new insurer handles the cancellation of your old policy. Just make sure there’s no gap in cover — set the start date of the new policy for the day after the old one ends.

What’s coming next: telematics and digital pricing

Insurers are moving toward telematics-based pricing — where a device or app tracks your driving behaviour. Suncorp invested $560 million in a digital upgrade in late 2024. This means safer drivers could see lower premiums, but it also means more data collection. If you’re a low-mileage, careful driver, a telematics policy could save you money. If you’re not, it could cost more. This is still emerging, but it’s worth watching when you next shop around.

For drivers with modified vehicles, the stakes are higher. Modifications can void your cover if not declared. The risks of undeclared car modifications are real — a single undeclared change can leave you with no cover after an accident.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does comprehensive cover include theft if I leave my keys in the car? ▾
Most policies exclude theft if keys were left in the vehicle or in an obvious place. Check your policy wording — this is a common exclusion that catches people out.
Can I switch insurers mid-year? ▾
Yes, but you may lose the remaining premium if you cancel mid-policy. Some insurers refund on a pro-rata basis. Check your policy’s cancellation terms before switching.
Does my no-claim bonus transfer to a new insurer? ▾
Usually yes, but you need to provide proof — typically a letter or certificate from your current insurer. Most insurers accept up to 10 years of no-claim history.
What happens if I have an accident and my policy doesn’t cover the full repair cost? ▾
You’re responsible for the difference. This is why agreed value policies are safer than market value policies — market value can drop below what you owe on finance.
Is third-party fire and theft worth it? ▾
It’s a middle ground — cheaper than comprehensive but covers fire and theft of your own vehicle. Worth considering for cars worth $5,000–$10,000 where comprehensive feels too expensive.
Do I need comprehensive cover if my car is financed? ▾
Most lenders require comprehensive cover as a condition of the loan. Check your finance agreement — if it’s required, third-party cover won’t be enough.

The Real Cost of Not Checking Your Policy

The average driver who switches to a top-rated policy saves $692. The average driver who stays loyal pays $312 more than a new customer. Those two numbers alone suggest that most Australians with comprehensive cover are overpaying. The insurance industry is competitive — 43 providers were analysed in the Canstar study alone — but that competition only benefits you if you actually shop around. The loyalty tax isn’t a fee. It’s a choice to not check.

Remember: this article is general information only. For advice on your specific situation, speak to a qualified professional.

If this was useful, you might also want to read The Great Car Insurance Debate: Are Third Party Policies a Risky Gamble in Australia?

Sources and Further Reading

Tips for Choosing the Right Car Insurance for Luxury Vehicles in Australia — If you drive a higher-value car, the decision between comprehensive and third-party cover changes. This guide covers the specific factors for luxury vehicles.

Electric Cars Insurance: The Shocking Truth for Australian Owners — EV insurance costs and coverage differ from petrol cars. This article explains what electric vehicle owners need to know.

Canstar (2025). Car Insurance Prices Continue to Accelerate. 🔗

Youi (2025). Is Comprehensive Car Insurance Worth It. 🔗

IBISWorld (2025). Car Insurance Industry in Australia. 🔗

Share this

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Email

Sam Willy

I’m Sam Willy, one of the bright minds behind BritWealth.com, where I share insights, stories, and fun ideas about a wide range of topics—finance included, but not limited to it! My journey into the world of writing began with a simple hobby: sharing the things that fascinated me. From quirky facts to deeper dives into personal development, I’ve always been curious about the world around me and love passing that knowledge on.
Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted

Disclaimer

The content published on BritWealth.com is provided for general informational and educational purposes only and should not be considered financial, legal, insurance, tax, investment, or professional advice. You should always carry out your own research or seek independent professional guidance before making financial or business decisions.

Some content on this website may contain affiliate links. This means BritWealth.com may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase, at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, BritWealth earns from qualifying purchases.

While we make reasonable efforts to keep information accurate and up to date, BritWealth.com makes no representations or warranties, express or implied, regarding the completeness, accuracy, reliability, suitability, or availability of any content on this website.

Any reliance you place on information found on this site is strictly at your own risk. BritWealth.com will not be liable for any loss, damage, or consequences arising from the use of this website or reliance on its content.

By using this website, you acknowledge and agree to this disclaimer and our terms of use.

Table of Contents

Share This

On Trend

Readers'
Top Picks

Accident Alert: The First Steps To Take After a Car Accident (And Not Ruin Your Insurance Claim in AU)

A car accident can be a stressful and confusing event. Knowing what to do immediately after a crash, and in the days and weeks that follow, is crucial not only for your safety but also for ensuring a smooth insurance claim process in Australia. Missteps can delay your claim, reduce your payout, or even lead to its rejection. This article outlines the vital steps you should take after a car accident in Australia to protect yourself and your insurance claim. Immediate Actions After a Car Accident Your first priority after a car accident is always safety. Before anything else,

Read More »

Tips For Navigating Total Loss Vehicle Payout In Australia

In Australia, thousands of vehicles are written off each year, and the decision to declare a car a total loss hinges on a surprisingly simple calculation: if the repair cost hits somewhere between 75% and 100% of the car’s pre-accident value, the insurer will call it a write-off. The exact trigger varies by insurer and state, but that percentage band is the single most important number you need to understand before you accept a cent from a total loss settlement. Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through them, Britwealth may earn

Read More »

The Impact of Driverless Cars on Future Car Insurance in Australia.

Driverless cars are poised to revolutionize the Australian automotive landscape, promising safer roads and smoother traffic. However, this technological leap presents profound implications for the car insurance industry, potentially reshaping how risk is assessed, liability is determined, and policies are priced. This article delves into the potential impact of autonomous vehicles (AVs) on the future of car insurance in Australia, exploring the challenges, opportunities, and practical considerations that lie ahead. It also provides tips on car insurance in Australia, covering topics from choosing the right policy to understanding your coverage. The Autonomous Revolution: A Glimpse into the Future Autonomous

Read More »

What You Need To Know About Rental Car Insurance In Australia

Navigating rental car insurance in Australia is crucial for a stress-free trip. It acts as a financial safety net if things go wrong, like an accident, theft, or other damages. Let’s break down everything you need to know about rental car insurance Down Under, covering the different types, how much it might cost, and what to do if you need to make a claim. Understanding the Types of Rental Car Insurance When you’re picking up your rental car, you’ll likely encounter a few different types of insurance. Knowing what they cover is essential. The main ones are Collision Damage

Read More »

Understanding Policy Endorsement Options for Car Insurance

Understanding your car insurance policy is super important to make sure you’re covered and feel secure. In Australia, there are lots of ways to tweak your car insurance with extra options called endorsements. These can make your protection stronger or give you special benefits that aren’t in the basic policy. Let’s dive into these options and give you some simple tips for picking the right car insurance for you. What are Policy Endorsements? Policy endorsements, also known as riders or add-ons, are like bonus features you add to your car insurance. They change the policy to give you more

Read More »

How Voluntary Vehicle Tracking Can Lower Your Insurance Costs

Voluntary vehicle tracking is becoming a really popular way for Australian drivers to save money on car insurance. If you choose to use these systems, which keep an eye on how you drive, you could get some pretty big discounts on your insurance and even become a safer driver overall. Let’s dive into how these systems work, why they’re great, and how you can use them effectively here in Australia. Understanding Voluntary Vehicle Tracking Voluntary vehicle tracking basically means putting a GPS or telematics device in your car. This little gadget collects info about your driving habits – things

Read More »
AUSTRALIA
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x