The Truth About Car Insurance Excess: How Much Should You Really Pay?

Picture this: you drive a Subaru Outback in Chatswood, NSW. You find a comprehensive policy with a $600 excess for $2,014 a year. Then you spot the same policy with a $2,000 excess — $1,452 a year. That’s a $562 difference each year, or about $47 a month. But here’s the catch: if you crash and write off the car, you’ll need to hand over $2,000 before the insurer pays a cent. The excess is the price of admission for a claim, and picking the right number means balancing guaranteed savings against a potential lump sum you might not have.

Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through them, Britwealth may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We only include products and services that are relevant to the topic.

This article is general information only and does not constitute professional advice. For your specific situation, consult a qualified professional.

$2,014
Annual premium with a $600 excess (Subaru Outback example)
insureconnect.com.au

$1,452
Annual premium with a $2,000 excess (same policy)
insureconnect.com.au

$562
Potential annual savings by choosing the higher excess
insureconnect.com.au

$11.6B
Total car insurance claims paid by insurers (2023-2024)
APRA (via money.com.au)

Understanding the trade-off between your excess and your premium is the single most practical thing you can do when buying car insurance. The right choice depends entirely on your savings, your driving habits, and your stomach for risk. Here’s what you actually need to know to get it right.

What You’ll Learn About Car Insurance Excess

The Direct Trade-Off
A higher excess almost always means a lower premium. The insurer shares less risk, so they charge less for the policy. The key is figuring out whether the annual savings outweigh the risk of a larger claim-time payment.

Excesses Stack Up
Your basic excess isn’t the only one. Age excess, inexperienced driver excess, and unlisted driver excess can all pile on top of each for a single claim, turning a manageable figure into a shock.

The Not-At-Fault Rule
You generally don’t pay an excess if the accident wasn’t your fault and you can identify the other driver. But hit-and-runs, theft, and weather damage still leave you with the bill.

Savings Buffer Matters
Your total excess should be an amount you could pay tomorrow from your emergency savings without stress. If you can’t, a lower excess is the safer financial bet.

Insurance Excess
The fixed amount you agree to pay toward the cost of a claim before your insurer covers the rest. It’s not part of your premium — it only applies when you claim. If repairs cost $6,500 and your excess is $1,000, you pay the first $1,000 and the insurer covers the remaining $5,500.

Premium Savings vs. Claim-Time Cost: The Real Numbers

Let’s look at a concrete example. Based on a comparative quote for a Toyota Corolla with a 30-year-old main driver, the difference between the lowest and highest excess options is striking.

→ Scroll right to see all columns

Source: National Cover analysis
Excess Level Annual Premium Annual Savings vs $400 Excess Out-of-Pocket at Claim Time
$400 $1,120 $0 $400
$1,000 $896 $224 $1,000
$2,000 $696 $424 $2,000

Choosing the $2,000 excess saves $424 a year compared to the $400 excess. Over five claim-free years, that’s $2,120 in your pocket. But if you have one at-fault claim costing $2,000, you’re still $120 ahead over that period. The risk is real, but so is the reward. The Subaru Outback example from earlier tells the same story: raising the excess from $600 to $2,000 saves $562 a year, or nearly 30 per cent off the premium. What I tend to notice is that people focus on the monthly premium and miss the total annual picture — that small monthly saving adds up to something meaningful over a few years.

The $2,000 Threshold
Choosing a $2,000 excess cuts your premium by up to 38% compared to a $400 excess. But it only makes sense if you have a solid emergency fund. Financial counsellors often recommend keeping your total excess within an amount you can comfortably cover using savings. If that $2,000 would break your budget, a lower excess is worth the higher premium.

This trade-off looks different for every driver. Someone with a clean record, off-street parking, and low annual kilometres may feel comfortable with a higher excess because they genuinely claim less often. On the other hand, a driver in a high-risk area with a history of claims might find a lower excess cheaper in the long run when you factor in the frequency of claims.

Common Mistakes People Make With Car Insurance Excess

Picking the Highest Excess Without Checking Your Savings

The mistake is straightforward. You see the lowest premium and jump at it. But if you have only $1,000 in savings and you pick a $2,000 excess, a single at-fault accident leaves you unable to afford the claim. The car sits unrepaired, or you have to borrow money at a bad rate. Insurers generally won’t let the claim proceed until the excess is paid, either directly to the repairer or deducted from a total-loss settlement. What I’d do: check your emergency fund first. If it’s under $2,000, work backwards from there and choose an excess that fits comfortably within it.

Ignoring the Stacking Effect of Additional Excesses

Your basic excess is just the starting point. Most Australian policies add an age excess for drivers under 25, an inexperienced driver excess if the driver hasn’t held a full licence for two years, and an unlisted driver excess if the person at the wheel isn’t named on the policy. These amounts stack on top of your basic excess for a single claim. Let’s say your basic excess is $600, the age excess is $400, and the unlisted driver excess is $300. If your 19-year-old friend borrows your car and has an accident, your total out-of-pocket cost becomes $1,300 — more than double what you expected. The policy schedule always lists these, but most people don’t read it closely enough.

Assuming You’ll Never Claim

The “I’m a safe driver” mindset leads many to choose the highest excess. Statistically, you might go five or ten years without a claim. Over that time, the premium savings are substantial. But the moment a claim happens — whether it’s your fault or not — the excess still applies unless the other driver is identified and accepts fault. If you’re saving $424 a year and have one $2,000 claim in ten years, you’re still ahead by $2,240 in that decade. The psychological sting of a large lump sum payment often outweighs the mathematical benefit. It’s worth weighing your own tolerance for that feeling against the guaranteed savings.

Not Understanding When the Excess Is Waived

Many drivers believe they’ll never pay an excess because they’re careful. But excess applies in more situations than just at-fault accidents. Theft, vandalism, storm damage, hail, flood, bushfire, and animal collisions all typically require you to pay the excess. The only common scenario where you don’t pay is when you can provide the full name, address, and vehicle registration of the at-fault driver so the insurer can recover the costs. If you can’t identify them — a hit-and-run in a car park, for example — the excess stays with you. Reading the Product Disclosure Statement (PDS) before you buy the policy is the only way to know exactly where you stand.

How to Choose the Right Excess for Your Situation

Run the Numbers Across Multiple Scenarios

When you get quotes, ask for the premium at $400, $600, $1,000, $1,500, and $2,000 excess levels. Write down the annual savings between each step. Then multiply those savings by three years — the average gap between claims for many drivers. That gives you the real financial buffer you’re building against a future claim. If the savings over three years are larger than the difference in excess, you’re winning financially even if you claim once in that period.

Audit Your Emergency Fund Honestly

Your excess should be an amount you could pay tomorrow. Not “maybe in a month” or “after I sell something” — tomorrow. Financial counsellors stress this point repeatedly. If your savings balance is $1,200, choosing a $2,000 excess is a gamble you’ll probably lose at the worst possible moment. A lower excess costs more per year, but it guarantees you can always access your insurance benefit when you need it. If you’re unsure about your legal position after a complex claim dispute, getting a second opinion through a finance advice service might help clarify your options before you commit.

Factor in Your Driving Profile

Your personal risk profile matters. High annual mileage, street parking in a busy suburb, a history of claims, or young drivers in your household all increase the probability of a claim. If your claim likelihood is high, a lower excess may save you more in the long run because you’ll actually use it more often. Conversely, if you work from home, park in a garage, and have a clean 10-year record, a higher excess makes strong financial sense. RACQ suggests weighing the difference between a higher premium with a lower excess versus the opposite, based on your personal financial situation.

Compare High vs. Low Excess for Your Specific Policy

→ Scroll right to see all columns

Source: MoneySmart car insurance guide
Factor High Excess Low Excess
Annual premium Lower (saving up to 38% vs low excess) Higher (paying for lower risk at claim time)
Cost when you claim Higher out-of-pocket (e.g., $2,000) Lower out-of-pocket (e.g., $400)
Best for Strong savings buffer, low claim risk, low annual mileage Limited savings, higher claim risk, frequent drivers
Psychological impact Smaller ongoing cost, but painful lump sum at claim Higher ongoing cost, but easier claim-time experience

Understanding the minimum insurance requirements in your state also matters. Third-party property policies often have a fixed, non-adjustable excess, while comprehensive policies give you more control. Knowing the difference helps you choose the right type of cover first, then fine-tune the excess within it.

Look Ahead to Emerging Changes

Insurance products evolve. Some insurers now offer telematics-based policies where your driving behaviour directly affects your premium, sometimes with lower excess options for good drivers. Others are adjusting excess structures for electric and high-performance vehicles. Keeping an eye on how your insurer handles these categories can reveal opportunities to lower your excess or premium without compromising your coverage. If your policy fine print feels overwhelming, consulting a business law service for a plain-English breakdown of your obligations might be worth the investment.

Frequently Asked Questions About Car Insurance Excess

Do I pay an excess if the accident wasn’t my fault? ▾
Usually not. If you can identify the other driver and provide their full name, address, and vehicle registration, your insurer will pursue them for recovery and you generally won’t pay an excess. If you can’t identify them — a hit-and-run — the excess applies.
How is the excess collected when I make a claim? ▾
For repairable claims, you typically pay the excess directly to the repairer when the work is completed. For total-loss claims, the excess is deducted from the settlement payment you receive. All applicable excesses are added together and collected as one amount.
What happens if I can’t afford my excess at claim time? ▾
The claim will not proceed until the excess is paid. Some insurers offer payment plans or hardship options, but this varies. The best approach is to lower your voluntary excess at your next renewal so it matches your available savings.
Can I remove the basic excess from my policy? ▾
No. The basic (standard) excess is set by the insurer and is non-negotiable. However, you can adjust your voluntary excess, which sits on top of the basic excess. Lowering your voluntary excess increases your premium, and vice versa.
Does a higher excess always mean a lower premium? ▾
Yes, mathematically. When you agree to pay more at claim time, the insurer carries less risk and prices the policy accordingly. The exact savings vary by insurer and your personal profile, so comparing quotes at different excess levels is essential.

Your Excess, Your Control

The car insurance excess is one of the few levers you actually control in an insurance policy. You can’t change your age, your postcode, or your driving history overnight. But you can choose exactly how much financial risk you carry at claim time. The right number balances guaranteed premium savings against a claim-time cost you can comfortably cover. Let your savings buffer and your real driving habits — not a guess or a fear — make that decision for you.

Remember: this article is general information only. For advice on your specific situation, speak to a qualified professional.

If this was useful, you might also want to read Navigating Car Insurance After an Accident: A Step-by-Step Guide.

Sources and Further Reading

The Ultimate Guide to Understanding Car Insurance Excess in Australia — A deeper look at the technical differences between compulsory, voluntary, and additional excesses across Australian policies.

Understanding State Mandated Insurance Levels in Australia — Know the legal minimum coverage requirements in your state before choosing your excess level.

ASIC MoneySmart (2024). Choosing car insurance. 🔗

RACQ (2024). What is car insurance excess. 🔗

National Cover (2024). Car insurance excess explained. 🔗

Allianz Australia (2024). What is car insurance excess. 🔗

Share this

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Email

Sam Willy

I’m Sam Willy, one of the bright minds behind BritWealth.com, where I share insights, stories, and fun ideas about a wide range of topics—finance included, but not limited to it! My journey into the world of writing began with a simple hobby: sharing the things that fascinated me. From quirky facts to deeper dives into personal development, I’ve always been curious about the world around me and love passing that knowledge on.
Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted

Disclaimer

The content published on BritWealth.com is provided for general informational and educational purposes only and should not be considered financial, legal, insurance, tax, investment, or professional advice. You should always carry out your own research or seek independent professional guidance before making financial or business decisions.

Some content on this website may contain affiliate links. This means BritWealth.com may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase, at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, BritWealth earns from qualifying purchases.

While we make reasonable efforts to keep information accurate and up to date, BritWealth.com makes no representations or warranties, express or implied, regarding the completeness, accuracy, reliability, suitability, or availability of any content on this website.

Any reliance you place on information found on this site is strictly at your own risk. BritWealth.com will not be liable for any loss, damage, or consequences arising from the use of this website or reliance on its content.

By using this website, you acknowledge and agree to this disclaimer and our terms of use.

Table of Contents

Share This

On Trend

Readers'
Top Picks

Telematics: Is Data-Driven Car Insurance Right for You?
Car Insurance

Telematics: Is Data-Driven Car Insurance Right for You?

Here’s an article based on the provided search results, following all your guidelines. Telematics is definitely shaking things up in the car insurance world. Basically, it’s a way for insurance companies to get a much clearer picture of how you actually drive. Instead of just guessing your risk based on general factors, they can use technology to see your driving habits in real-time. This has the potential to make car insurance cheaper for a lot of people, especially those who are careful drivers. It’s kind of like getting rewarded for good behavior, but with your driving. It’s a pretty

Read More »

Should You REALLY Claim on Your Car Insurance? A Balancing Act for Australian Drivers

Around 1 in 7 Australians with car insurance makes a claim in any given year, yet the average claim sits just over $5,200. That figure alone doesn’t tell you whether you should actually pick up the phone and file one. The real question is whether the damage in your driveway is worth the ripple effects on your premium, your excess, and your future options. Here’s what you actually need to know. Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through them, Britwealth may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We

Read More »

Australia Self-Insured Car Policy Guide

Navigating car insurance in Australia can feel like a maze, especially when considering self-insurance. This guide breaks down the essentials, explores the concept of self-insurance, compares it with traditional car insurance, and equips you with the knowledge to make informed decisions. Understanding Car Insurance Basics in Australia Before diving into self-insurance, let’s solidify the foundation: the different types of car insurance available in Australia. Primarily, you’ll encounter three main categories: Compulsory Third Party (CTP), Third Party Property, and Comprehensive car insurance. Compulsory Third Party (CTP) Insurance CTP, also known as greenslip insurance in some states, is mandatory in every

Read More »

Is Loyalty Rewarded? Uncovering Car Insurance Benefits You Might Be Missing in Australia

Many Australian car insurance companies promise loyalty rewards, but are you really getting a sweet deal? Beyond the feel-good marketing, uncovering the true benefits often requires digging into the fine print and understanding how your policy stacks up against the competition. This article explores the car insurance landscape in Australia, highlighting potential loyalty perks, exposing common pitfalls, and providing actionable tips to ensure you’re genuinely rewarded for sticking around. Loyalty Programs: More Than Just a Discount? The term “loyalty program” can be deceptively simple. What it actually entails varies significantly between insurers. While some offer genuine discounts, others might

Read More »

Car Insurance Loyalty: Is it Costing You Money in the Long Run, Australia?

Sticking with the same car insurance company year after year might feel comfortable, but in Australia, loyalty doesn’t always pay off. In many cases, it can actually be costing you money. Insurance companies often lure in new customers with attractive introductory offers, then gradually increase premiums over time, hoping loyal customers won’t notice or won’t bother switching. The Loyalty Trap: How Car Insurance Premiums Creep Up The car insurance industry in Australia is fiercely competitive. Insurers constantly try to attract new business with enticing discounts and promotional rates. This creates a dynamic where new customers often receive the best

Read More »

Does Location Matter? The Truth About Car Insurance by Australian Suburb.

Yes, location profoundly impacts your car insurance premium in Australia. From bustling city centres teeming with traffic to quiet rural towns, where you park your car overnight plays a significant role in determining how much you’ll pay for coverage. This article dives deep into the location factor, exploring how your suburb affects your car insurance costs and providing actionable tips to potentially lower your premiums. The Geography of Risk: Why Suburb Matters Car insurance companies are in the business of assessing risk. One of their most crucial risk factors is location. Your suburb isn’t just a place on a

Read More »
AUSTRALIA
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x