Victoria’s opposition has pledged $1.27 billion to send public hospital patients into private hospitals for surgery, aiming to clear a waiting list that’s grown to nearly 69,000 people. The plan would add 25,000 operations a year across more than 100 private hospitals and day surgeries, with no out-of-pocket fees for patients. Here’s what you actually need to know.
Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through them, Britwealth may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We only include products and services that are relevant to the topic.
This article is general information only and does not constitute professional advice. For your specific situation, consult a qualified professional.
That policy proposal is just one sign of how blurred the line between public and private has become. Taxpayers already subsidise private health insurance premiums to the tune of $6.3 billion a year, and Medicare chipped in another $3.81 billion for medical services delivered to private patients in 2023–24. Meanwhile, the private hospital sector is running at a loss while insurers post profits. The question of whether choosing private care is worth the cost isn’t straightforward — and the answer depends on what you’re actually paying for.
Real Stakes in the Public-Private Split
The most immediate stake is waiting time. Victoria’s elective surgery waitlist grew from roughly 58,000 to nearly 69,000 over the past year alone. That’s the kind of number that drives people toward private insurance. But the private system has its own problems. According to Grattan Institute analysis, private hospitals are using only 64 per cent of their beds. Some are reporting financial difficulties from softer patient demand, rising out-of-pocket specialist fees, and cost-of-living pressures.
The benefits ratio — the share of premium revenue insurers pay out in claims — sat at 90 per cent before the pandemic, dropped to 83 per cent in 2022–23, and was still only 85 per cent as of March 2026. The APHA has renewed its call for a legislated minimum 90 per cent payout ratio, arguing it would cost the government and patients nothing while closing the gap between hospital revenue and costs. That dispute sits at the heart of whether private cover delivers value.
Then there’s the question of access. Around 300 psychiatrists in Australia are currently prevented from practising in private hospitals due to bureaucratic restrictions, while acute private mental health hospitals report 40–60 per cent vacancy rates. The APHA has described a situation where stranded patients have died by suicide while unable to secure a psychiatrist consult. That’s a stake that goes beyond waiting lists and out-of-pocket costs.
What the Choice Really Comes Down To
The core trade-off is this: private cover buys you faster scheduling and more choice of doctor, but you’re paying into a system where the financial incentives are increasingly misaligned. Insurers want to keep premiums competitive and profits healthy; hospitals need higher reimbursement rates to cover rising costs; and taxpayers are already on the hook either way.
How the Costs Actually Work
When you’re treated as a private patient in a private hospital, you’re dealing with three separate bills: the hospital accommodation, the doctor’s fees, and any gap between what the insurer pays and what the provider charges. Medicare covers 75 per cent of the MBS fee for private patients, and your insurer typically picks up some or all of the remaining 25 per cent — but only if they have an agreement with that hospital and that doctor.
If your health fund doesn’t have a deal with the hospital, you could face significant uncovered costs. That’s why the recent contract disputes matter. Healthscope, which runs 38 for-profit private hospitals, has threatened to end agreements with insurers. St Vincent’s and UnitingCare Queensland both announced they’d walk away from contracts before reaching last-minute deals. These aren’t abstract negotiations — they determine whether your cover actually covers you at the hospital you want to use.
→ Scroll right to see all columns
| Cost component | Public patient (public hospital) | Private patient (private hospital) |
|---|---|---|
| Hospital accommodation | Covered by Medicare | Covered by insurer minus excess/co-pay |
| Doctor/specialist fees | Covered by Medicare | Medicare pays 75% of MBS fee; insurer may cover gap |
| Out-of-pocket exposure | Minimal (optional extras like TV, parking) | Average $511 per visit (gap + excess + co-pay) |
| Choice of doctor | Limited to hospital staff | You choose, but may affect gap costs |
| Waiting time for elective surgery | Can be months; waitlist at ~69,000 in Victoria | Typically weeks, but depends on hospital capacity |
The Medicare Levy Surcharge adds another financial layer. For the 2026/27 tax year, singles earning over $105,000 a year and families earning over $210,000 (plus $1,500 per dependent child after the first) generally need to hold appropriate private hospital cover to avoid the surcharge. If you have hospital cover with an excess of $750 or less as a single, or $1,500 or less as a family, you can avoid paying the MLS entirely. That’s a direct financial incentive that makes private cover more attractive for higher earners, regardless of whether they actually use it.
Where People Get Tripped Up
Assuming private insurance covers everything
The average out-of-pocket cost of $511 per private hospital visit tells you this isn’t a free ride. Policies contain exclusions, waiting periods, and limits. Even with top-tier cover, you can face gap fees if your chosen doctor charges above the insurer’s agreed rate. Before booking any private treatment, ask your specialist for an estimate of their fees and check whether other doctors (anaesthetist, assistant surgeon) will charge separately. Contact your insurer to confirm which doctors and hospitals they have agreements with.
Ignoring the benefits ratio when choosing a policy
The benefits ratio has dropped from 90 per cent before the pandemic to around 85 per cent in early 2026. That means a larger share of your premium is going toward insurer costs and profits rather than your care. When comparing policies, it’s worth looking beyond the headline premium to what proportion actually flows back to providers. The APHA has called for a mandatory minimum 90 per cent payout ratio, but until that’s legislated, the gap varies by insurer.
Not checking whether your hospital has an agreement with your insurer
The contract disputes between major private hospital operators and health insurers aren’t just industry news — they directly affect your coverage. If your insurer doesn’t have an agreement with the hospital where your procedure is scheduled, you could face significant uncovered costs. Before any planned admission, ask the hospital directly whether they have a current agreement with your health fund, and read your Private Health Information Statement (PHIS) to understand what’s covered.
Overlooking the public option entirely
Some people assume private is always faster, but with private hospitals running at only 64 per cent capacity, that’s not a given. And the Victorian opposition’s policy to divert public patients into private hospitals — if implemented — would further blur the lines. Meanwhile, public hospitals provide high-quality care at minimal cost, and for emergency treatment they remain the primary option regardless of insurance status. The choice isn’t always binary; many Australians use both systems at different times.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is private health insurance worth it just to avoid waiting lists? ▾
What’s the average out-of-pocket cost for private hospital treatment? ▾
Can I be treated at a private hospital as a public patient? ▾
Does Medicare cover private hospital treatment? ▾
What happens if my private hospital doesn’t have a deal with my insurer? ▾
Are private hospitals in financial trouble? ▾
Bottom Line on Choice and Cost
The public and private systems in Australia are more entangled than most people realise. Taxpayers are already deep into funding private care through premium rebates and Medicare subsidies. Private hospitals are running at a loss while insurers post profits. And the benefits ratio — what actually flows back to patient care — has been sliding for years.
Choosing private care can mean faster access and more choice, but the financial protection it offers is thinner than many assume. The average $511 out-of-pocket cost per visit, the contract disputes between hospitals and insurers, and the declining benefits ratio all point to a system where value for money needs to be assessed case by case, not assumed.
The strongest argument for holding private cover right now might be the Medicare Levy Surcharge — a direct tax saving for higher earners — rather than the certainty of better or faster care. And with policies like Victoria’s proposed public-to-private patient diversion, the distinction between the two systems will only get murkier.
Remember: this article is general information only. For advice on your specific situation, speak to a qualified professional.
If this was useful, you might also want to read Health Insurance Rebates: Maximising Your Savings in Australia.
Sources and Further Reading
Beyond the Basics: Exploring Niche Private Health Cover for Aussies — A look at specialised health insurance options beyond standard hospital cover.
Mental Health Private Insurance: What Aussies Need to Know — Covers the gaps in mental health coverage and what to look for in a policy.
Australian Private Hospitals Association (2026). Private health reforms positive if right. 🔗
The Conversation (2024). Are private hospitals really in trouble — and is more public funding the answer? 🔗
The Age (2026). Public patients in private hospitals: the no-fee plan to slash surgery waiting lists. 🔗
Canstar (2026). What is the cost of staying in hospital in Australia? 🔗
Australian Institute of Health and Welfare (2021–22). Health expenditure Australia. 🔗
Department of Health and Aged Care (2023–24). Medicare annual statistics. 🔗
