If a visitor trips on a loose stair at your rental property and breaks their wrist, the legal and medical costs can easily run into tens of thousands of dollars. In Australia, landlord public liability insurance is usually bundled into a standard landlord policy, but knowing who is responsible for what between you and your tenant can mean the difference between a covered claim and an out-of-pocket disaster.
Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through them, Britwealth may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We only include products and services that are relevant to the topic.
This article is general information only and does not constitute professional advice. For your specific situation, consult a qualified professional.
These numbers show why the split matters. A single slip-and-fall claim can wipe out years of rental income, and if the cause was something you were responsible for fixing, your insurance may not help. Here’s what you actually need to know.
One term you’ll see in every policy document is duty of care.
What I tend to notice is that most disputes between landlords and tenants come down to who knew about a problem first and what they did about it. That’s where the research gets specific.
Who pays for what: the full responsibility breakdown
The table below covers the most common areas where responsibility gets blurred. Each row is based on standard tenancy legislation across Australian states and territories, with the exception of South Australia’s smoke alarm rules, which differ.
→ Scroll right to see all columns
| Area | Landlord responsibility | Tenant responsibility |
|---|---|---|
| Gardens & lawns | Major landscaping, tree lopping, fixing reticulation, cleaning gutters | Mowing, weeding, pruning, watering, reporting issues like leaks or pests |
| Pest control | Termites/white ants always; initial pest-free condition; infestation from structural issues | Infestation caused by poor housekeeping or failure to report |
| Repairs & maintenance | Structural, electrical, plumbing, air conditioning; urgent repairs within legislated timeframes | Damage caused by tenant, children, pets, or guests; replacing light globes; cleaning windows |
| Smoke alarms | Supply, install, replace batteries at start of tenancy, maintain alarms | Clean and test monthly; replace batteries (except SA where landlord usually does it) |
| Security | Ensure state-compliant locks, window locks, exterior lights; maintain them | Need permission for extra security measures; then maintain them |
Notice what’s missing from that table: insurance. Pests and vermin are standard exclusions in landlord insurance, so the cost of managing an infestation or repairing damage sits with whoever caused it. That’s a gap worth weighing against your overall property insurance strategy.
Three mistakes that cost landlords real money
Assuming the tenant handles everything outdoors
Garden maintenance is the tenant’s job, but major tree work and reticulation repairs are yours. If a tree branch falls and damages a neighbour’s fence, and you hadn’t arranged for a qualified arborist to trim it after the tenant reported overhanging limbs, you could be liable. The tenant’s job is to mow and weed. Your job is to keep the structure safe. A basic tree lopping kit won’t cut it for large branches — you need a licensed professional, and that cost sits with you.
Ignoring the smoke alarm battery rule
In most states, the tenant replaces batteries in battery-powered smoke alarms. In South Australia, the landlord is usually responsible unless the tenancy agreement says otherwise. If a tenant removes a flat battery and doesn’t replace it, and a fire causes injury, your public liability insurance may still respond — but only if you can show you maintained the alarm and instructed the tenant properly. The fix is simple: put the battery replacement rule in writing in the lease and check it during inspections.
Thinking public liability insurance covers everything
It covers claims where you’re legally liable. If a tenant’s guest trips over a child’s toy left on the stairs, that’s the tenant’s problem, not yours. But if the same guest trips on a broken stair you knew about and didn’t fix, you’re on the hook. The insurance covers your legal defence costs and any compensation awarded, but only if the hazard was something you should have addressed. The distinction matters because many landlords assume any injury on the property triggers coverage. It doesn’t.
How to handle repairs, claims, and disputes the right way
Urgent repairs: know your state’s timeframes
Each state and territory sets its own definition of an urgent repair and how quickly you must respond. In New South Wales, urgent repairs include burst water pipes, blocked toilets, serious roof leaks, gas leaks, and electrical faults. The landlord must arrange repairs immediately. In Victoria, the same categories apply, and the tenant can organise urgent repairs up to $2,500 without your prior approval if you can’t be reached. The key is having a clear process: the tenant reports the issue in writing, you respond within the legislated window, and you keep records of every communication. If you’re unsure about your state’s rules, a landlord-tenant law service can clarify your obligations before a dispute arises.
Making a public liability claim
If a third party is injured or their property is damaged, the process follows a standard sequence. First, the claimant notifies you in writing. You then notify your insurer immediately — most policies require prompt notification. The insurer will investigate to determine whether you breached your duty of care. If you did, the policy covers legal defence costs and any compensation awarded, up to the sum insured (typically $1 million or more). If you didn’t, the insurer may still cover defence costs while liability is assessed. The critical step is documenting everything: inspection reports, repair receipts, tenant communications, and photographs. Without records, it’s your word against theirs.
What happens when a tenant causes damage
If a tenant’s child throws a ball through a window, the tenant pays for the replacement. If they don’t, you can claim against their bond at the end of the tenancy. But if the damage is structural — say, a wall knocked through during a party — the cost can exceed the bond. In that case, you may need to pursue the tenant through a tribunal. Your landlord insurance may cover the damage, but you’ll typically pay an excess and your premiums may rise. The better approach is to conduct regular inspections and address small issues before they become big ones.
Upcoming changes to rental property standards
Several states are tightening minimum standards for rental properties. Victoria already requires rental properties to meet minimum energy efficiency and safety standards, including ceiling insulation and fixed heating. New South Wales is phasing in similar requirements for smoke alarms, pool fences, and electrical safety. These changes affect what counts as a “reasonable repair” and could shift more responsibility onto landlords for upgrades that were previously optional. If you’re planning a renovation or buying a new investment property, factor these standards into your budget now rather than scrambling later.
Frequently asked questions
Who pays for pest control if the lease doesn’t mention it? ▾
Can a tenant install their own security cameras? ▾
What happens if a tenant doesn’t report a leak and it causes structural damage? ▾
Is landlord public liability insurance tax-deductible? ▾
Who is responsible for mould in a rental property? ▾
Does landlord insurance cover damage from a tenant’s pet? ▾
Your responsibility doesn’t end with the lease
The line between landlord and tenant responsibility isn’t fixed — it shifts with every inspection report, every repair request, and every change in state regulation. What stays constant is your duty of care. If you know about a hazard and don’t act, you’re exposed. If you document everything and respond promptly, your insurance has your back. The landlords who get into trouble aren’t the ones who make big mistakes. They’re the ones who let small things slide.
Remember: this article is general information only. For advice on your specific situation, speak to a qualified professional.
If this was useful, you might also want to read Neighbourly Disputes: Your Property, Who Pays the Insurance Answers?.
Sources and Further Reading
Simple steps to lower your property insurance premiums in Australia — Practical ways to reduce your premium without cutting essential cover.
How to save on investment property insurance costs in Australia — Strategies specifically for investors managing multiple properties.
PropertyUpdate (2024). Landlord vs tenant responsibilities. 🔗
Duo Insurance (2024). Do you need public liability as a landlord and where do you get it? 🔗
YourLifeChoices (2024). Landlord vs tenant: who is responsible? 🔗
RentCover (2024). Landlord vs tenant responsibilities. 🔗
