Beyond Super: Alternative Australian Retirement Investments You Need To Know.

Superannuation is the backbone of most Australian retirement plans, but the numbers tell a story worth paying attention to. Median super balances for men aged 65–69 sit at $230,766, while women the same age have $207,187, according to the AFR. For many people, that’s not enough to live on without the Age Pension, which remains the main income source for 42% of men and 41% of women in retirement. The proposed Division 296 tax changes, which would add 15% tax on earnings from super balances above $3 million, have pushed some high-balance members to consider alternatives — but the rules aren’t final yet, and the affected group is estimated at around half a per cent of account holders.

Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through them, Britwealth may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We only include products and services that are relevant to the topic.

This article is general information only and does not constitute professional advice. For your specific situation, consult a qualified professional.

$230,766 / $207,187
Median super balances (men / women aged 65–69)
afr.com

35% / 23%
Super as main retirement income source (men / women)
afr.com

$3 million
Division 296 threshold for additional 15% tax
kalkine.com.au

$3.5 trillion
Expected wealth transfer to next generation over 20 years
afr.com

Superannuation has powerful tax advantages — contributions are taxed at 15%, and earnings within the fund are taxed at 10–15% rather than your marginal rate. But it locks your money away until preservation age, which is currently 60. That’s why some people are looking at alternatives like investment bonds, trusts, and direct investments. The question is whether the trade-offs are worth it. Here’s what you actually need to know.

Super still wins on tax for most people
The concessional tax rate inside super is hard to beat. Alternatives like trusts and companies come with their own tax treatment, but they rarely match super’s 15% rate on contributions and 10–15% on earnings.

Division 296 affects a tiny fraction
Only about 0.5% of account holders have balances above $3 million. The proposed 15% additional tax on earnings above that threshold is not yet law, and acting before it’s finalised could be premature.

Alternatives have real costs
Family trusts, investment bonds, and companies involve setup fees, ongoing administration, and complex tax rules. The costs can easily eat up any tax advantage if you’re not careful.

Don’t move money out of super too early
Transferring assets from super to an alternative structure can trigger tax liabilities and forfeit the concessional treatment you’ve already benefited from. Compare after-tax outcomes before making any move.

What you need to know about investment bonds, trusts, and other structures

An investment bond is a life insurance policy with investment features. Earnings inside the bond are taxed at a long-term rate of 10–15%, compared with up to 47% for high-income earners who invest directly. You can pass investment bonds to beneficiaries without triggering a tax event. But they come with specific holding-period rules, fees, and limited investment options compared with super. The Generation Life product is one example, but every bond issuer has its own terms.

Investment bond
A life insurance policy that invests your money in shares, property, or fixed interest. Earnings are taxed inside the bond at a concessional rate, and after 10 years you can withdraw the money tax-free. Also called insurance bonds or growth bonds in Australia.

What I tend to notice is that people hear “10–15% tax rate” and assume it’s better than super. But super still offers a lower rate on contributions (15%) and the same or lower rate on earnings. The real advantage of investment bonds is flexibility — you can access the money before preservation age, and they can be useful for estate planning because they don’t go through probate.

The numbers that actually govern this decision

The table below compares the key features of superannuation, investment bonds, family trusts, and direct investments. These are the figures that matter when you’re weighing up which structure suits your situation.

→ Scroll right to see all columns

Source: AFR analysis of super alternatives
Structure Tax rate on earnings Access age Typical costs Estate planning
Superannuation 10–15% 60+ Low (fund fees) Tax-free to beneficiaries
Investment bond 10–15% (long-term) No restriction Moderate (fees + insurance component) Can pass tax-free, no probate
Family trust Beneficiaries’ marginal rate No restriction High (setup + admin + compliance) Complex succession rules
Direct shares / property Marginal rate (up to 47%) No restriction Low to moderate (brokerage, management) Via will, CGT may apply

Here’s what those numbers mean in practice. If you’re a high-income earner on a 47% marginal rate, an investment bond’s 10–15% long-term rate looks attractive. But super still gives you 15% on contributions and 10–15% on earnings, plus you get the benefit of compounding without the drag of ongoing fees. Moving $500,000 out of super into a trust or bond could trigger a tax event on the way out, and you’d lose the concessional treatment on future contributions.

The $3 million threshold that’s not yet law
Division 296 would add 15% tax on earnings attributable to super balances above $3 million, including unrealised gains. The design and timing are still debated, and the threshold isn’t indexed, so it could affect more people over time. But with only 0.5% of accounts currently affected, most Australians won’t be impacted at all.

The AFR reported that future median super balances for retirees with meaningful compulsory contributions are expected to exceed $500,000 in ten years. That’s still below the $3 million threshold by a wide margin. For most people, the best strategy remains maxing out super contributions — up to $30,000 per year under the concessional cap — and only looking at alternatives once that’s in place.

Errors and gaps when considering alternatives to super

Moving assets out of super before understanding the tax cost

This is the most expensive mistake I see. Transferring assets from super to a trust or company can crystallise capital gains and trigger exit taxes. You lose the 15% tax rate on future contributions, and you may end up paying more in ongoing costs than you save in tax. The Kalkine analysis notes that any alternative structure involves costs, compliance obligations, and trade-offs that need to be weighed against the concessional treatment you’re giving up.

Underestimating the ongoing costs of running a trust or company

Family trusts offer flexibility in distributing income, but they come with establishment costs, annual accounting fees, complex tax rules, and the need for a trust deed. Companies have their own tax rate and administrative burden. If your investment portfolio isn’t large enough to justify these costs, you could end up worse off than staying in super or investing directly. The research from Unified Wealth highlights that professional advice is essential to determine whether the structure fits your goals and numbers.

Assuming investment bonds are always tax-effective

Investment bonds have a 10–15% long-term tax rate, but that rate depends on the bond’s underlying investments and the holding period. If you withdraw before 10 years, the tax treatment changes. The Resolution Life article notes that investment bonds carry specific rules, fees, and consequences for accessing funds at different times. They’re not a replacement for super — they’re a complement for specific needs like pre-retirement income or estate planning.

  • Compare after-tax outcomes of remaining in super vs alternative structures, including all costs
  • Factor in setup fees, ongoing admin, and compliance costs for trusts or companies
  • Check the 10-year holding period rules and exit penalties for investment bonds
  • Consider your timeline: do you need access before age 60, or is super’s lock-up acceptable?
  • Don’t act on Division 296 until the rules are finalised and your specific circumstances are clear

How to evaluate retirement investment structures beyond super

Compare after-tax outcomes including all costs

Start with a clear comparison of what you’d actually keep after tax, fees, and compliance costs under each structure. The Kalkine research emphasises that comparing after-tax outcomes is the first step. Use a spreadsheet or work with a financial adviser to model your specific situation. Include the tax you’d pay on contributions, investment earnings, and withdrawals, plus the cost of running the structure each year.

When alternatives actually make sense

Investment bonds can be useful if you want to build wealth outside super for a specific goal — like retiring before 60 or funding a child’s education. Family trusts work well for business owners who want to distribute income across family members. Direct property or shares give you full control and access, but you pay your marginal tax rate on income and gains. The Unified Wealth guide notes that building wealth outside super creates flexibility but requires careful planning around cashflow, tax, and risk.

Step-by-step: how to weigh your options

  • 1
    Calculate your current super balance and projected retirement income
    Use the ATO’s online tools or your super fund’s retirement calculator to estimate your balance at preservation age. Compare this with your expected retirement spending.

  • 2
    Identify the gap or goal that super can’t cover
    Do you need pre-retirement income? Want to leave a tax-free inheritance? Planning to retire before 60? The answer determines which structure suits you.

  • 3
    Model the after-tax return of each alternative structure
    Include setup costs, ongoing fees, tax on earnings, and exit costs. Compare the net result with staying in super. Use the MoneySmart tools for guidance.

  • 4
    Factor in the costs of leaving super
    Moving assets out of super can trigger tax. An SMSF with illiquid assets adds further complexity. The Kalkine analysis warns that crystallising tax and forfeiting concessional treatment may outweigh the benefits.

  • 5
    Get professional advice tailored to your situation
    Tax rules, estate planning, and compliance obligations vary by structure and personal circumstances. A qualified financial adviser can help you navigate the trade-offs. If you need help understanding the legal or tax implications, consider connecting with a specialist through JustAnswer Finance for tax and accounting guidance, or JustAnswer Legal for estate planning questions.

What’s changing — and what’s still uncertain

The proposed Division 296 legislation is not yet law, and its design and timing remain debated. Acting before the rules are finalised could be premature, as the Kalkine research notes. Meanwhile, the Age Pension age is rising, and the AFR reports that $3.5 trillion in personal wealth is expected to transfer from older Australians to the next generation over the next 20 years. Estate planning is becoming a bigger factor in retirement decisions. The average inheritance was $188,249 in the three years to 2022, and the average recipient was around 55 years old — right at the point where they’re thinking about their own retirement strategy.

Frequently asked questions about alternative retirement investments

What is Division 296 and who does it affect? ▾
Division 296 would add 15% tax on earnings from super balances above $3 million, including unrealised gains. It’s estimated to affect around 0.5% of account holders. The rules are not yet law and may change before implementation.
Can investment bonds replace super for retirement? ▾
No. Investment bonds have a higher tax rate on contributions (your marginal rate, not 15%) and don’t offer the same long-term compounding advantages. They’re best used alongside super for specific goals like pre-retirement income or estate planning.
What happens if I move money out of super into a trust? ▾
Moving assets out of super can trigger capital gains tax and exit taxes. You also lose the concessional 15% tax rate on future contributions. The Kalkine research notes that crystallising tax and forfeiting super’s benefits may outweigh any advantages of the trust.
Are family trusts worth the cost for investing? ▾
Family trusts offer flexibility in distributing income, but they come with high setup and ongoing costs. They’re most useful if you have a large portfolio, multiple family members to distribute to, or business succession needs. For most investors, the costs outweigh the benefits.
How does the Age Pension interact with alternative investments? ▾
The Age Pension is means-tested against both income and assets. Investments held outside super — including shares, property, and trusts — count toward the assets test. The work bonus scheme allows you to earn up to $11,800 per year without losing pension, but other investment income is assessable.

Division 296 isn’t law yet — don’t restructure too early

The most important thing to understand is that the proposed Division 296 changes are still being debated. Reacting to a rule that doesn’t exist yet could cost you more than it saves. For the vast majority of Australians, superannuation remains the most tax-effective retirement vehicle available, and the best strategy is to maximise your contributions within the current rules. When you’re ready to explore alternative structures, take the time to compare after-tax outcomes, factor in all costs, and get advice tailored to your specific situation.

Remember: this article is general information only. For advice on your specific situation, speak to a qualified professional.

If this was useful, you might also want to read Retire Rich: The Aussie Dream or a Financial Illusion?

Sources and Further Reading

Legacy Planning: Making a Difference That Lasts Beyond Your Retirement — A deeper look at how to structure your estate and plan for what happens after you’re gone.

Kalkine Education (2024). Beyond Super: Could Trusts, Bonds, and Other Structures Help Under Division 296? 🔗

AFR (2024). Exploring tax-effective alternatives to super. 🔗

Resolution Life (2024). Building Wealth Beyond Your Super. 🔗

Unified Wealth (2024). Building Wealth Beyond Super. 🔗

Share this

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Email

Sam Willy

I’m Sam Willy, one of the bright minds behind BritWealth.com, where I share insights, stories, and fun ideas about a wide range of topics—finance included, but not limited to it! My journey into the world of writing began with a simple hobby: sharing the things that fascinated me. From quirky facts to deeper dives into personal development, I’ve always been curious about the world around me and love passing that knowledge on.
Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted

Disclaimer

The content published on BritWealth.com is provided for general informational and educational purposes only and should not be considered financial, legal, insurance, tax, investment, or professional advice. You should always carry out your own research or seek independent professional guidance before making financial or business decisions.

Some content on this website may contain affiliate links. This means BritWealth.com may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase, at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, BritWealth earns from qualifying purchases.

While we make reasonable efforts to keep information accurate and up to date, BritWealth.com makes no representations or warranties, express or implied, regarding the completeness, accuracy, reliability, suitability, or availability of any content on this website.

Any reliance you place on information found on this site is strictly at your own risk. BritWealth.com will not be liable for any loss, damage, or consequences arising from the use of this website or reliance on its content.

By using this website, you acknowledge and agree to this disclaimer and our terms of use.

Table of Contents

Share This

On Trend

Readers'
Top Picks

Tech & Retirement: Embracing Innovation for a Fulfilling Later Life

Retirement in Australia is undergoing a technological revolution, presenting unprecedented opportunities for a more connected, healthier, and financially secure later life. Embracing these advancements can significantly enhance the retirement experience, but requires understanding and proactive adoption. Staying Connected: Bridging the Digital Divide One of the most significant benefits of technology in retirement is its ability to combat social isolation. Many retirees move away from their established networks, or their families live interstate or overseas. Technology offers a powerful means to stay connected with loved ones through video calls using platforms like Zoom or Skype, instant messaging via WhatsApp or

Read More »

The Unexpected Joys (and Challenges) of Retirement in Australia

Retirement in Australia presents a mixed bag: the joy of newfound freedom and the challenges of navigating a new phase of life, often with complex financial and social considerations. Australians are living longer, which necessitates careful planning to ensure financial security and a fulfilling lifestyle. This article explores the unexpected joys and challenges that many Australians face upon entering retirement, offering insights and practical advice for a smoother transition. The Initial Euphoria and the Inevitable Adjustment The initial days, weeks, and even months of retirement are often filled with a sense of liberation. No more alarm clocks, no commuting,

Read More »

Embracing Minimalism: A Path to a More Relaxed Retirement in Australia.

Retiring in Australia is often envisioned as a time of relaxation and freedom, but the reality can be overshadowed by clutter, financial strain, and a sense of being overwhelmed by possessions. Embracing minimalism offers a powerful alternative, a path to decluttering not just your home but also your life, freeing up time, reducing stress, and ultimately leading to a more fulfilling and enjoyable retirement. The Allure of Minimalism in Retirement: More Than Just Tidying Up Minimalism isn’t about deprivation. It’s a conscious choice to prioritize experiences, relationships, and well-being over the endless accumulation of material possessions. For retirees, this

Read More »
Aussie Dream Home: Retirement Ruined?
Retirement

Aussie Dream Home: Retirement Ruined?

It’s a common story, isn’t it? You’ve worked hard, maybe put in a lot of overtime, and the Australian property market seemed like the best place to put your money. The dream home, the family haven, the solid investment. But what if that very home, the one you’ve poured so much into, is actually putting a bit of a spanner in the works for your retirement plans? It sounds a bit counterintuitive, but there’s a growing conversation around how our attachment to our homes, especially larger ones, can really impact our financial security later on. The Big Picture: Super,

Read More »

The Future of Retirement: How Technology is Reshaping the Aussie Dream.

The traditional Australian dream of retirement – a leisurely existence filled with travel, golf, and grandkids – is undergoing a radical transformation, largely driven by technology. From sophisticated investment platforms to innovative aged care solutions, technology is not merely a supplement to retirement planning; it’s fundamentally reshaping how Australians prepare for, experience, and manage their post-work lives. The Rise of Fintech in Retirement Planning Fintech (financial technology) has democratized access to financial advice and investment tools, previously the domain of high-net-worth individuals. Robo-advisors, like Stockspot or Six Park, provide automated investment management based on individual risk profiles and financial

Read More »

Retirement Boredom is Real: How to Find Purpose & Passion After Work.

Retirement, often envisioned as an endless holiday, can quickly morph into a monotonous cycle for many Australians. The absence of a structured workday, coupled with a lack of clear purpose, can lead to boredom, isolation, and even a decline in mental and physical health. Recognizing this potential pitfall and proactively planning for a fulfilling post-work life is crucial for a happy and healthy retirement in Australia. This article explores the realities of retirement boredom, delves into its causes, and offers practical strategies for finding purpose and passion beyond your career. The Reality of Retirement Boredom in Australia While the

Read More »
AUSTRALIA
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x