You’ve had a crash, you’re standing on the side of the road, and the only thing running through your head is a jumble of who’s at fault, what to say, and whether the insurance will actually pay out. That moment is exactly where most people make the decisions that either smooth out the claims process or turn it into a weeks-long headache. Here’s what you actually need to know.
This article is general information only and does not constitute professional advice. For your specific situation, consult a qualified professional.
What actually breaks when you misunderstand the process
The most common trap is treating the Fair Insurance Code benchmarks as a promise that your claim will be approved and your car repaired inside two weeks. That’s not what they are. The Code says a subscribing insurer will acknowledge your claim within 5 business days and determine whether to accept it within 10 business days after receiving all the information needed to make that decision. If the insurer is still waiting on an assessor’s report, a police file, or third-party details, the clock hasn’t started on that 10-day window.
The second trap is assuming “not at fault” means you pay no excess and everything happens instantly. Under Tower’s comprehensive wording — and this varies by insurer — you pay no excess if you can name the other party and the insurer is satisfied they were more than 50% at fault. But if the other driver drove off and you can’t identify them, your standard excess applies. That’s a cold surprise for someone who assumed they’d be fully covered.
And the third trap is silence. If your claim seems stalled, the worst thing you can do is wait. Under the Code, if an insurer can’t meet the 10-day decision benchmark because the claim is complex or involves a third party, it must explain the delay, give you an expected timeframe, and update you at least every 20 business days. But that only works if you know to ask. Most people don’t, and their claim sits in a queue while they assume someone is working on it.
Mistakes people make and how to fix them
Admitting fault at the roadside
You’re shaken up, the other driver is apologetic, and it feels natural to say “sorry, my fault.” Don’t. Liability depends on evidence, witness accounts, policy wording, and sometimes legal interpretation — not what you blurt out while your heart is still pounding. Exchange details, stay calm, and let the insurer assess the situation. Saying sorry can be used against you later, even if you meant it as politeness, not an admission.
Authorising repairs before the insurer approves
It’s tempting to get the damage sorted quickly, especially if you need the car for work. But Tower’s wording — and most insurers’ — explicitly requires you to get permission before arranging repairs or spending money on the claim. If you go ahead without approval, the insurer can decline the claim or pay less than you expected. Emergency steps to prevent further loss (like tarping a broken window) are fine, but a panel beater needs a green light first.
Assuming your policy covers everything in the car
Personal possessions left in the vehicle — a laptop, sunglasses, a bag — are generally not covered by your car insurance. ICNZ states this clearly: those items fall under your contents policy, not your motor policy. If they’re stolen or damaged in a crash, your car insurer won’t pay for them. Check your contents policy separately.
Not keeping a paper trail
Phone calls are easy, but they leave no record. Every time you speak to your insurer, note the date, the name of the person you spoke to, and what was agreed. Keep copies of emails, photos you’ve submitted, and any letters you receive. If a dispute arises later, that record is your best evidence. Without it, you’re relying on memory — and the insurer has its own notes.
The claims process from start to finish
Here’s how the sequence actually works, based on the Fair Insurance Code standards and the practical steps outlined by ICNZ, NZTA, and insurers like Tower and AA Insurance.
At the scene: safety, legal duties, and evidence
Stop immediately. Check for injuries. If anyone is hurt or there’s immediate danger, call 111. Under the Land Transport Act 1998, you must report a crash involving injury or death to a Police officer as soon as reasonably practicable and no later than 24 hours. If you’re incapable due to injury, the clock pauses.
For a non-injury crash, you’re required to provide your name, address, and plate number to the owner or driver of any damaged property as soon as possible and no later than 48 hours. If the other driver can’t be found, report it to Police within 60 hours.
Take photos of the damage, the vehicle positions, the road layout, and any relevant conditions — but only if it’s safe to do so. Write down the date, time, location, and a brief factual sequence while it’s fresh. Ask witnesses for their contact details and note what they saw. Don’t put yourself at risk to get information from an uncooperative person.
Notifying your insurer
Contact your insurer as soon as possible. Have your policy number ready if you have it, along with photos, the other driver’s details, and any Police reference number. Tower’s wording asks you to tell it as soon as you become aware of circumstances that may lead to a claim. ICNZ recommends having your policy number, photos, and any Police report number to hand when you call.
Answer questions truthfully. If your Warrant of Fitness had expired or the car has modifications you haven’t declared, disclose it rather than hoping it won’t come up. Non-disclosure can get your claim declined and your policy cancelled.
If the car is damaged, immobile, or insecure, take reasonable steps to prevent further loss — but follow the insurer’s instructions. Don’t authorise repairs or dispose of the vehicle without checking the process first.
Lodgement and the 5 + 10 day benchmarks
Once you’ve lodged the claim, the insurer’s obligations under the Fair Insurance Code kick in. It must acknowledge your claim within 5 business days. Then, once it has all the information it needs to decide, it must determine whether to accept the claim within 10 business days.
That “all information needed” phrase is key. If the insurer needs an assessor to inspect the car, or a police report, or third-party details, the 10-day period doesn’t start until those arrive. For a straightforward claim with clear photos and a named at-fault driver, it might be fast. For a complex liability dispute, it could take longer.
Tower reports that over 87% of online car claims were approved instantly, based on its monthly average for online claims sent to one of its trusted repair partners between April 2025 and March 2026. But that’s a specific metric for a specific channel — not a forecast for every claim.
Assessment, repair, and settlement
If the claim is accepted, the insurer will arrange an assessment. For car claims, this often means directing you to an approved repairer. Under Tower’s wording, if you use a Tower Repair Partner, the insurer backs those repairs for as long as you own the car. If you choose a repairer outside its network, Tower may pay a cash amount based on its own assessment rather than arranging the repair directly.
The insurer may use new, recycled, or reconditioned parts. It doesn’t pay for importing parts from overseas or for inability to match existing paint. After a partial-loss repair, your sum insured is restored to its pre-loss value.
If the car is a total loss, the insurer pays the agreed value or market value shown on your certificate, whichever applies. Any lender you’ve told the insurer about gets paid first. Unpaid instalments for the year are due before settlement. The car, any unused registration, road user charges, and WoF become the insurer’s property, and the policy ends automatically.
Excess: when you pay and when you don’t
The excess is your contribution to the claim. Your certificate of insurance shows the amount. Extra excesses can apply for inexperienced drivers, some international licence holders, or where underwriting has added one.
Under Tower’s comprehensive wording, you pay no excess if: another driver was more than 50% at fault and you’ve named them; keys or locks are lost, stolen, or copied (that benefit only); the car was stolen from a locked garage or secure parking building. Windscreen or glass claims — your excess applies unless you chose the optional windscreen excess buyout. If one event damages your car and another Tower-insured vehicle, boat, house, or contents, you pay only one excess — the highest of them.
But these are Tower-specific rules. Your insurer may have different terms. Check your policy wording rather than assuming.
If the other driver was at fault
A not-at-fault claim still starts with your insurer if you want your own car fixed under a policy that covers it. Under Tower’s comprehensive wording, you pay no excess if you identify the at-fault party with their name, phone number, and registration, and Tower is satisfied they were more than 50% at fault. After accepting the claim, you must cooperate with any action the insurer takes to recover money from the other party.
If the other driver is uninsured, your level of cover matters. Under Tower’s third-party, fire and theft, and third-party-only wordings, the insurer may pay for repairs to your car — up to the least of the repair cost, market value, or $4,000 — if you identify the at-fault driver, the insurer is satisfied they were more than 50% at fault, and their vehicle was uninsured. Car insurance isn’t compulsory in New Zealand, which is why uninsured drivers exist.
If your claim is declined or you disagree
Ask the insurer for its reasons in writing. Compare its decision with your policy wording and the evidence you supplied. If you still disagree, make a formal complaint to the insurer. Label it clearly as a “formal complaint,” set out the relevant dates and claim number, attach key correspondence, explain your concern, and state the remedy you’re seeking.
Under the Fair Insurance Code, the insurer must acknowledge your complaint within 5 business days and respond within 10 business days. If it can’t resolve the complaint within two months, it must advise you of your right to use its independent external dispute resolution scheme.
All New Zealand financial service providers must have a formal complaints process and belong to an approved external dispute resolution scheme. The relevant schemes include IFSO, FSCL, FDRS, and BOS. Check which scheme your insurer belongs to — don’t assume. The service is free to consumers, but the process, jurisdiction, and limits depend on the specific scheme and your complaint.
What to have ready before you lodge
ICNZ and Tower both publish lists of what speeds up a claim. Having these ready before you call can make the difference between a same-day approval and a week of back-and-forth.
- Your policy number
- Date, time, and location of the incident
- Description of what happened
- Photos of the damage (uploading these can help validate a claim twice as fast, per Tower)
- Name, phone number, email, and registration of any other driver involved
- Police file number if Police attended
- Witness names and contact details
- Receipts for any emergency steps you’ve taken (towing, storage)
For a theft claim, you’ll need the Police report number. Tower’s wording also requires you to tell the Police yourself if theft, arson, burglary, or malicious damage appears to have happened.
FAQ
How long do I have to make a car insurance claim in NZ? ▾
Should I repair my car before the insurer approves the claim? ▾
Do I pay an excess if the crash wasn’t my fault? ▾
Do I have to use the insurer’s repairer? ▾
Are things inside my car covered after a crash or theft? ▾
What can I do if my claim is declined? ▾
Will my premium go up after a claim? ▾
What the process actually teaches you
The New Zealand car insurance claims process isn’t a maze designed to trip you up — but it does reward people who treat it like a process rather than a panic. The ones who get through fastest are the ones who know their legal duties before a crash happens, who keep their policy wording somewhere they can find it, who take photos and write things down, and who ask the right questions when the insurer goes quiet.
The Fair Insurance Code gives you real protections — the 5-day acknowledgement, the 10-day decision window, the obligation to explain delays, and the right to escalate to a free dispute resolution scheme. But those protections only work if you know they exist and you’re willing to use them.
Remember: this article is general information only. For advice on your specific situation, speak to a qualified professional.
If this was useful, you might also want to read Car Insurance Claims Denied: Know Your Rights as a NZ Driver.
Sources and Further Reading
Car Insurance and Weather: Are You Covered for Mother Nature’s Fury? — What your policy does and doesn’t cover when storms, floods, or earthquakes damage your vehicle.
Insurance Council of New Zealand. Fair Insurance Code 2016. 🔗
New Zealand Legislation. Land Transport Act 1998, section 22. 🔗
Consumer Protection NZ. Car insurance. 🔗
Insurance Council of New Zealand. Making a claim. 🔗
Insurance Council of New Zealand. How to Make an Insurance Complaint. 🔗
Tower Insurance. Comprehensive Car Insurance Policy Wording 09-24. 🔗
Tower Insurance. Car Insurance. 🔗
New Zealand Government. Complain about your financial services provider. 🔗
Financial Markets Authority. Insurance. 🔗