If you rent a property in the UK and a pipe bursts, who pays for the damage to the walls and floors? The answer isn’t always obvious, and getting it wrong can cost thousands. Buildings insurance is the landlord’s responsibility, but contents cover for your belongings is yours. Around one in five renters don’t have contents insurance, according to the Association of British Insurers, leaving them on the hook for replacing everything they own if the worst happens.
Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through them, Britwealth may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We only include products and services that are relevant to the topic.
This article is general information only and does not constitute professional advice. For your specific situation, consult a qualified professional.
Most people assume the landlord’s insurance covers everything inside a rented home. It doesn’t. The split between building and contents cover is where confusion — and financial risk — lives. A landlord’s policy typically covers the structure, fixtures, and fittings, but your sofa, laptop, and clothes are your problem. Understanding where that line falls is the difference between a quick insurance claim and a personal financial hit.
Here’s what you actually need to know.
What This Article Covers: The Four Things That Matter Most
One term you’ll see a lot is buildings insurance. It covers the cost of repairing or rebuilding the physical structure of a property — the walls, roof, floors, doors, windows, pipes, wiring, and permanent fixtures like fitted kitchens and bathrooms. It does not cover your personal possessions or general wear and tear.
What I tend to notice is that tenants often assume the landlord’s policy covers everything inside the four walls. It doesn’t, and that assumption can be expensive. My first move as a tenant would be to check exactly what the landlord’s policy covers — and then buy contents insurance for everything else.
Buildings Insurance: What the Landlord Must Cover and What They Don’t
There’s no law in the UK that forces a landlord to take out buildings insurance. In practice, though, most buy-to-let mortgage lenders require it as a condition of the loan. Without it, a serious event like a fire or flood could leave the landlord paying the full rebuild cost out of pocket.
Buildings insurance typically covers the cost of repairing damage to the structure from fire, flood, storm, escape of water, vandalism, and impact from vehicles or falling trees. It also usually covers the cost of renting temporary accommodation if the property becomes uninhabitable, and homeowner’s liability for injuries to guests on the property.
What it does not cover is just as important. General wear and tear, gates and fences, and damage caused by pests or animal habitation are all excluded. If a tenant’s pet chews through a wall, that’s not a buildings insurance claim — it’s a dispute between landlord and tenant.
If a rented property has no buildings insurance and damage occurs, who pays depends on who caused it. Damage from a tradesperson, a neighbour, or a burglar is the landlord’s responsibility. Deliberate damage by the tenant is the tenant’s responsibility. Accidental damage by the tenant — knocking a hole in a wall, for example — typically falls to the landlord to fix, though the tenant may lose their deposit.
For landlords, the gap between standard buildings insurance and a proper landlord policy can be significant. A specialist policy often includes cover for loss of rent if the property becomes uninhabitable, legal expenses for evicting problem tenants, and liability cover if a tenant is injured on the property. These aren’t optional extras — they’re the difference between being protected and being exposed.
If you’re a landlord reviewing your cover, it’s worth weighing a standard policy against a specialist one. A tenant landlord lawyer can help clarify what your policy should include based on your specific property and tenancy type.
Contents Insurance: What Tenants Need to Cover Themselves
Your landlord’s buildings insurance does not cover your belongings. If a fire destroys the building, the landlord’s policy pays to rebuild the structure. Your sofa, TV, clothes, and laptop are your problem. That’s where contents insurance comes in.
Contents insurance covers your personal possessions against theft, fire, flood, and accidental damage, depending on the policy you choose. It also typically covers your liability if someone is injured in your home and you’re found responsible. For renters, this is the single most important insurance decision you’ll make.
The cost of contents insurance varies widely based on where you live, the value of your belongings, and the level of cover you choose. A basic policy for a one-bedroom flat in a low-risk area might cost under £10 a month. A comprehensive policy for a family home with high-value items could be £30 or more. The average UK contents insurance premium is around £150 a year, according to the ABI.
What I’d do as a tenant is take a room-by-room inventory of everything I own, estimate its replacement value, and then buy a policy that covers at least that amount. Most people underestimate the value of their possessions by thousands of pounds. A quick walk through your flat — phone, laptop, clothes, kitchen appliances, furniture — adds up fast.
Some landlords require tenants to have contents insurance as a condition of the tenancy agreement. Even if yours doesn’t, the maths is simple: replacing a single laptop costs more than a year’s premium. Going without is a gamble that rarely pays off.
Common Mistakes That Cost Renters and Landlords Money
Assuming the landlord’s policy covers your stuff
This is the most common and most expensive mistake. A tenant’s belongings are never covered by the landlord’s buildings insurance. If a pipe bursts and ruins your sofa, laptop, and clothes, the landlord’s policy pays for the damaged floorboards and plasterboard. You pay for everything else. The fix is straightforward: buy contents insurance before you move in, not after something goes wrong.
Not checking what the landlord’s policy actually covers
Some landlords have basic buildings insurance that doesn’t include cover for temporary accommodation or liability. If the property becomes uninhabitable after a fire, the tenant may have nowhere to go and no help with hotel costs. Ask to see the policy summary before you sign the tenancy agreement. If the cover looks thin, consider whether you want to live there at all.
Thinking accidental damage is always covered
Standard buildings insurance often excludes accidental damage caused by the tenant. If you put your foot through the ceiling while in the loft, the landlord’s policy may not pay. The landlord can then claim the cost from your deposit or take you to small claims court. Some contents insurance policies include accidental damage cover for the building — worth checking if you’re prone to DIY disasters.
Forgetting to update your contents insurance
You buy a new laptop, a new phone, a new bike. Your contents insurance still covers the old values. If you need to claim, you’ll be paid based on what you insured, not what you own. Review your policy every year and increase the sum insured if you’ve added valuable items. A quick home inventory checklist can help you track what you own and what it’s worth.
How to Get the Right Cover: A Practical Guide for Both Sides
For tenants: what to look for in a contents policy
Start with the sum insured — the total value of everything you own. Be realistic. Most people own more than they think. Then decide on the level of cover: basic policies cover theft, fire, and flood; mid-range policies add accidental damage; comprehensive policies cover everything including accidental damage to the building itself. Look for policies that include “new for old” replacement, which pays the cost of buying a new item rather than the depreciated value of the old one.
Check whether the policy covers your belongings outside the home — your phone, laptop, and bike when you’re out and about. This is called “personal possessions cover” and is often an add-on. If you commute with expensive gear, it’s worth having.
For landlords: what a specialist policy should include
A standard home buildings policy isn’t designed for rented properties. A specialist landlord policy should include buildings cover, loss of rent cover (pays your rental income if the property is uninhabitable), liability cover (if a tenant or visitor is injured), and legal expenses cover (for evictions or disputes). Some policies also include cover for malicious damage by tenants, which standard policies often exclude.
If you own multiple properties, a portfolio policy can be cheaper than insuring each one separately. Compare quotes from at least three specialist landlord insurers before renewing. The cheapest policy isn’t always the best — check the exclusions carefully.
What happens when a claim goes wrong
If the landlord’s insurer rejects a claim because the policy didn’t cover the cause of damage, the landlord may try to recover the cost from the tenant. This can lead to deposit disputes, small claims court cases, and strained relationships. The best prevention is clarity at the start of the tenancy: a written statement of who is responsible for what, signed by both parties.
If you’re in a dispute over who pays for damage, a small claims lawyer can advise on your options without you needing to go to court immediately.
Upcoming changes to watch
The Financial Conduct Authority is consulting on new rules for insurance product governance, which could affect how landlords and tenants buy cover. The changes, expected in 2025, may require insurers to provide clearer information about what is and isn’t covered at the point of sale. For now, the onus is on you to read the policy documents and ask questions before you buy.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the landlord’s insurance cover my furniture if there’s a fire? ▾
Can a landlord require tenants to have contents insurance? ▾
Who pays if a tenant accidentally damages the building? ▾
Is buildings insurance a legal requirement for landlords? ▾
What’s the difference between buildings insurance and landlord insurance? ▾
Does contents insurance cover my belongings outside the home? ▾
Who Pays When No One Is Covered
The most expensive scenario is the one no one plans for: damage occurs, and neither the landlord nor the tenant has the right insurance. The landlord’s buildings policy might exclude a specific cause, or the tenant never bought contents cover. In that situation, the cost falls on whoever is legally responsible for the damage — and that can mean months of disputes, legal fees, and out-of-pocket payments.
For landlords, the gap between a standard home insurance policy and a proper landlord policy is where the real risk lives. For tenants, the gap between assuming you’re covered and actually being covered is where the real cost lives. Both sides can close those gaps with a few hours of reading and a single phone call to an insurer.
Remember: this article is general information only. For advice on your specific situation, speak to a qualified professional.
If this was useful, you might also want to read Understanding Your Rights in Property Insurance Claims in the UK.
Sources and Further Reading
Understanding the Limitations of Property Insurance Tips in the UK — A closer look at what standard policies exclude and how to avoid surprises.
Top Tips for Customizable Property Insurance Coverage in the UK — How to tailor your policy to fit your specific property and circumstances.
Howden Insurance (2024). Who pays buildings insurance — landlord or tenant? 🔗
Association of British Insurers (2023). UK Insurance and Long-Term Savings Key Facts. 🔗
