The rules for both short-term and long-term letting in the UK have shifted more in the past eighteen months than in the previous decade. The Renters’ Rights Act 2025 scrapped Section 21 no-fault evictions in England from May 2026, while the Furnished Holiday Lettings tax regime was abolished from April 2025 — two changes that have pushed landlords in opposite directions at the same time. Here’s what you actually need to know.
Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through them, Britwealth may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We only include products and services that are relevant to the topic.
This article is general information only and does not constitute professional advice. For your specific situation, consult a qualified professional.
Both letting models have genuine strengths, and both have clear capacity to fail. The difference between a property that works well as a short-let and one that should stay in the long-term market comes down to four things: location, occupancy, cost structure, and how much hands-on work you actually want. The regulatory direction of travel matters too — what made sense five years ago may not hold for the next five.
If you’re weighing up which route fits a property you own or are thinking about buying, the lease terms and regulatory obligations that come with each model are where the real differences start.
What’s at Stake When You Pick the Wrong Model
The wrong choice here costs more than just lost income — it can lock you into a management burden you didn’t expect or leave a property sitting empty during months you counted on. The stakes break down into three areas.
Income that doesn’t show up. A short-let charging £120 a night looks dramatically more profitable than a long-term rental at roughly £40–£50 a night once you divide the monthly rent by days in the month. That comparison only holds if the short-let is booked every night of the year. Even popular locations rarely hit 100% occupancy across a full year once seasonality, gaps between bookings, and owner-blocked dates are accounted for. The Assist a Landlord guide illustrates the point with a two-bedroom flat in a mid-sized UK city: long-term at £1,100 a month (£13,200 a year) versus short-term at £90 a night with 55% occupancy generating roughly £18,100 in gross bookings — but after cleaning, platform fees around 15%, higher utility bills, and increased wear, the net often lands between £12,000 and £14,000, similar to or only modestly ahead of the long-term figure with far more time invested.
Regulatory exposure you didn’t plan for. Long-term letting in England now carries more security for tenants and less flexibility for landlords. Section 21 no-fault evictions are gone. Existing tenancies convert to assured periodic tenancies with no fixed end date. Rent increases are limited to once a year via a formal Section 13 notice. On the short-let side, Scotland already operates a licensing scheme, Greater London caps whole-property short-lets at 90 nights per year without planning permission, and the UK government has confirmed plans for a mandatory national register for short-term lets that Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy stated in Parliament on 3 September 2026 will be “up and running” by March 2027.
Time commitment you underestimated. A long-term let, once the tenant is in place, is genuinely low-touch — a few hours a year for most landlords. A self-managed short-let is a recurring operational job: guest messages, pricing adjustments, cleaner coordination, handling issues on a schedule that doesn’t respect weekends. Management companies can close that gap, but they take 15–25% of booking revenue.
The Financial Reality — Side by Side
Let me put the two models side by side on costs, because the gross income comparison is where most people get misled. The table below shows how each cost item lands differently depending on which model you choose.
→ Scroll right to see all columns
| Cost Item | Long-Term Let | Short-Term Let |
|---|---|---|
| Cleaning | Tenant’s responsibility, rare | After every stay, landlord pays |
| Utilities | Usually tenant-paid | Usually landlord-paid |
| Management fees | Standard letting agent fee if used | 15–25% of booking revenue typical |
| Furnishing standard | Basic to mid-range; tenant may bring own | Hotel-standard expected; higher turnover of items |
| Void risk | Occasional between tenancies | Frequent seasonal gaps |
| Income pattern | Fixed monthly, predictable | Fluctuates with demand, seasonal |
The cost stack for a short-let eats into the higher gross income faster than most first-time hosts expect. Cleaning between every stay, platform commission, utility bills that the landlord now covers, and furniture that wears out in a fraction of the time — all of these reduce the headline figure. A CalcHub analysis puts it plainly: at 90% occupancy (unusually high for most areas), a property at £110 a night grosses £36,080 before costs — well above the long-term alternative. At 55% occupancy (more typical outside peak tourist areas), gross drops to £22,110, and once the higher cost base is subtracted, net income can end up close to or even below the long-term tenancy’s simpler net figure.
The exact break-even occupancy rate depends entirely on your specific nightly rate, cost base, and location. There’s no universal formula. But the principle holds across every example in the research: occupancy is the variable that decides whether the short-let premium is real or illusory.
The Regulatory Picture — Both Sides Are Changing
The legal side of this decision has changed more in two years than in the twenty before them. You need to know where each model currently stands and where it’s heading.
Long-term letting in England post-Renters’ Rights Act
The Renters’ Rights Act 2025 received Royal Assent on 27 October 2025, with the main tenancy reforms coming into force on 1 May 2026. These apply to England only — Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland run separate rented-sector regimes. The key changes:
- Section 21 no-fault evictions are abolished. Ending a tenancy now requires a valid legal ground.
- Existing tenancies convert to assured periodic tenancies with no fixed end date.
- Rent increases are limited to once a year via a formal Section 13 notice (Form 4A, at least two months’ notice).
- Adverts must list a fixed asking rent; bidding wars above that figure are banned.
Long-term letting is now a longer, less flexible commitment than it used to be. That’s pushed some landlords toward short-term lets, but the short-let side has its own regulatory momentum.
Short-term letting — licensing, caps, and the incoming register
Scotland already operates a short-term let licensing scheme — hosts must register with their local authority. In Greater London, whole-property short-lets are capped at 90 nights per calendar year without planning permission, though MPs have argued that enforcing this limit is effectively impossible under current systems due to difficulty obtaining accurate data.
For England, the government has confirmed plans for a mandatory national register for short-term lets. Under the proposed scheme, hosts will be required to register their property’s address and receive a unique reference number that must be displayed on every platform where the property is advertised. Hosts will need to confirm compliance with existing legal requirements including fire safety measures and gas and electrical safety certification. The register is expected by March 2027.
Propertymark, the professional body for estate agents, has called for the government to strike a balance, noting that its research found increasing the supply of private and social housing is the main solution to pressures linked to short-term lets, and that members support proportionate regulation creating greater parity with the private rented sector.
On the mortgage side, not every buy-to-let product permits short-term letting. Standard buy-to-let mortgages are typically written with long-term tenancies in mind, and using a property for short-lets without checking the terms can breach the mortgage agreement. The same applies to insurance — standard landlord policies often don’t cover short-term guest stays.
What Actually Matters — Four Takeaways
If you take nothing else from the detail above, these four points matter most when deciding which model fits a property.
Common Mistakes When Choosing or Switching
The research on landlords who switch models or choose poorly keeps surfacing the same patterns. Most are avoidable with proper planning, but they show up often enough to treat as standard risks rather than edge cases.
Listing a property before you have vacant possession
Putting a property on Airbnb while a tenant is still in residence can breach their right to quiet enjoyment and create legal exposure. The 53 Degrees Property transition guide flags this as the single most common transition mistake. It’s fine to prepare photographs, copy, and platform listings in draft — but do not publish until the keys are back.
Skipping the mortgage conversation
Standard buy-to-let mortgages don’t automatically permit short-term letting. Speaking to your lender about consent to let, a holiday let product, or a remortgage should happen before you serve notice on a tenant, not after. Mortgage conditions can change the economics of conversion entirely, and operating in breach of terms carries real risk.
Underestimating the refurbishment window
The handover period between tenancies is the only chance to refurbish efficiently — deep clean, redecorate, upgrade weak rooms, replace tired furniture, fit smart tech, and get all compliance in place in one block. A typical refurbishment window for a two-bedroom UK property converting from a long-term tenancy to a short-let is three to five weeks. Locking in trades early matters because the biggest delays usually come from electricians (for EICR remedials) and furniture lead times.
Buying domestic-grade furniture
Short-let guests expect hotel-standard furnishings. Domestic-grade sofas, mattresses, and kitchenware typically fail within twelve months under the turnover of a busy short-let. The upfront cost of commercial-grade items is higher, but the replacement cycle is longer and the guest reviews better.
Launching with rushed photography or a single platform
Listings that go live with weak photography or missing key information typically take months to recover from poor first impressions. Professional photography, optimised copy, multi-platform listing, and dynamic pricing should all be in place before the first booking. A single-platform launch limits reach and leaves income vulnerable to that platform’s policy changes.
Trying to do everything personally
Self-managing a short-let is a real operational job. Many landlords use a specialist manager for the first six to twelve months to maximise ramp-up and avoid first-time-host mistakes, then reassess. The Landlord Today feature notes that professionally-managed short-lets can command stronger rates and occupancy, and that economies of scale make it easier to grow margins as a portfolio expands.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which model earns more money overall? ▾
Can I switch from long-term to short-term letting? ▾
What are the new rules for long-term lets in England? ▾
Do I need a licence for short-term letting? ▾
Is the tax treatment different between the two models? ▾
The Honest Answer Depends on Your Property and Your Time
The honest answer to which model is “right” is that it depends on three things you can assess before committing: whether your property sits in an area with consistent short-term demand, whether the numbers at realistic occupancy levels genuinely beat the long-term alternative after costs, and whether you have the time or budget for the management load a short-let requires.
Short-term letting suits properties in strong tourist or business-travel locations, landlords willing to manage frequent turnover, and those comfortable with income volatility across seasons. Long-term letting suits landlords who want predictable, lower-management income and properties in areas without strong short-term demand or where local licensing makes short-term letting impractical.
Both models can be genuinely profitable. Both have capacity to fail. The work behind the numbers — understanding your local market, budgeting properly for the costs each model brings, and putting a management approach in place that can deliver the expected return — is what decides the outcome. Landlords who set a strategy once and leave it alone tend to see returns drift. Review pricing, costs, and management arrangements regularly, and treat the decision as ongoing rather than settled once.
Remember: this article is general information only. For advice on your specific situation, speak to a qualified professional.
If this was useful, you might also want to read Negotiate Rent Like a Pro: UK Apartment Leasing Tips.
Sources and Further Reading
Tips to Navigate the Lease Deposit Refund Process Smoothly — Practical guidance on deposit protection rules that apply to long-term tenancies.
The Value of Lease Rental History When Renting an Apartment — Why rental history matters for tenants and landlords in the long-term market.
GOV.UK / HMRC. Abolition of the furnished holiday lettings tax regime (policy paper). 🔗
legislation.gov.uk. Renters’ Rights Act 2025 (2025 c. 26). 🔗
GOV.UK / MHCLG. Guide to the Renters’ Rights Act. 🔗
Scottish Government. Short-term lets licensing scheme. 🔗
Hansard. Oral Answers to Questions — Culture, Media and Sport (3 September 2026). 🔗
Propertymark. National short-term lets register promised by March 2027. 🔗