Is ‘Help To Buy’ Helping Or Hurting? A UK Home Buying Debate

Government home buying schemes have always split opinion. The old Help to Buy lifted thousands onto the property ladder with a 5% deposit. It also pushed up new-build prices by an estimated 5.5%, according to the government’s own evaluation. Now a new scheme called Your First Home is set to go further — a 2.5% deposit backed by a 20% equity loan. Whether that helps more than it hurts depends on which side of the debate you land. Here’s what you actually need to know.

Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through them, Britwealth may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We only include products and services that are relevant to the topic.

This article is general information only and does not constitute professional advice. For your specific situation, consult a qualified professional.

2.5%
Minimum deposit under Your First Home scheme
GOV.UK

5.5%
Estimated price premium on new-builds under Help to Buy
Govt Evaluation

34%
Of property professionals’ day spent chasing updates
Landmark

£4,000
Annual Lifetime ISA contribution limit
HMRC

The Your First Home scheme was announced by Prime Minister Andy Burnham on 26 September 2026, with full eligibility rules due at the Autumn Budget on 28 October 2026. First-time buyers in England will be able to purchase a new-build property with a 2.5% cash deposit and a government equity loan worth up to 20% of the purchase price. Pre-registration is expected to open by the end of December 2026, with the first customer applications going live in February 2027. That timeline means anyone considering the scheme has months to weigh whether it genuinely improves their position — or simply repeats the problems of the old Help to Buy.

How Your First Home and the Alternatives Actually Work

The mechanics of Your First Home look straightforward on paper. You put down 2.5% of the purchase price as a cash deposit. The government provides an equity loan worth up to 20% of the property value. You take out a mortgage for the remaining 77.5%. The equity loan is interest-free for an initial period — expected to be five years, matching the old Help to Buy structure — after which interest kicks in and the loan becomes repayable. The amount you repay tracks the home’s value at the time of repayment, not the original sum borrowed. That means if your property rises in value, you owe more than you borrowed.

The original Help to Buy Equity Loan scheme closed to new applications in England on 31 October 2022 and ended entirely in March 2023. It required a 5% deposit and offered a 20% equity loan (40% in London), also interest-free for five years. Many homeowners who took that route are now reaching the five-year mark and looking to remortgage or sell to repay the government stake. Your First Home is structurally similar but drops the deposit requirement to 2.5%, which the Ministry of Housing says could save hundreds of pounds per month compared to a standard 95% mortgage.

Several other schemes remain available right now for buyers who don’t want to wait for Your First Home to launch. Here’s how they compare:

→ Scroll right to see all columns

Source: Own Your Home government portal
Scheme Deposit Key Feature Property Type
Your First Home 2.5% 20% equity loan, interest-free 5 years New-build only
First Homes 5% of discounted price 30–50% permanent discount New-build only
Shared Ownership 5–10% of share Buy 10–75%, pay rent on rest New-build & resale
95% Mortgage (Freedom to Buy) 5% Government guarantee to lenders Any legal residence

First Homes offers a minimum 30% discount off the open market price, and that discount stays with the property permanently — passed to the next buyer when you sell. It’s aimed at local first-time buyers and key workers, with household income capped at £80,000 a year (£90,000 in London) and post-discount price capped at £250,000 across England (£420,000 in Greater London). Shared Ownership lets you buy a share of a property — typically between 25% and 75% — and pay rent on the rest. Your deposit is calculated on the share you’re buying, not the full market value, which can make it accessible with far less cash upfront. The Freedom to Buy mortgage guarantee scheme, made permanent in July 2025, encourages lenders to offer 95% loan-to-value mortgages on any property type, not just new builds.

The Case for Help: Lower Barriers, Faster Entry

The strongest argument for schemes like Your First Home is simple: the deposit is the single biggest barrier to homeownership. Many first-time buyers struggle to save while covering rent, household bills, and childcare. A 2.5% deposit on a £230,000 new-build works out at £5,750 — compared to £11,500 for a standard 5% deposit. That difference can cut years off the time needed to save.

The Ministry of Housing’s own modelling suggests the scheme could save buyers hundreds of pounds per month compared to a 95% mortgage, because the equity loan reduces the amount you need to borrow from a lender at a commercial rate. The interest-free period on the equity loan gives you five years of lower monthly costs before any repayment obligation begins. John Doherty, managing director of Just Mortgages, told Today’s Conveyancer that keeping the interest-free period to five years aligns well with typical fixed-rate mortgage terms, giving buyers certainty over early-year costs.

There’s also a wider market argument. Dominic Agace, CEO of Winkworth, said the scheme is needed to help unlock activity at the lower end of the market and get the wider housing market moving. More first-time buyers entering the market creates chain movement — sellers at the bottom can move up, and so on. Without that flow, the entire housing market risks stagnation.

The trade-off worth weighing
A lower deposit gets you in sooner, but the equity loan is repayable and tracks your home’s future value. If prices rise, you owe more than you borrowed. That’s not a problem if you’re trading up — but it can squeeze you at the point of sale or remortgage.

The Case Against: Inflated Prices, Hidden Costs, and Industry Logjams

The most persistent criticism of Help to Buy — and by extension Your First Home — is that it inflates new-build prices. The government’s own evaluation estimated that new-build homes carried a 5.5% premium over comparable existing properties, and that Help to Buy properties carried a further 0.9% premium on top of that. In other words, the scheme may have been capitalised into higher prices rather than purely improving affordability.

Will Bainbridge, founder of Hawthorn Capital, described Your First Home to Money Age as “irresponsible policymaking dressed up as aspiration.” His concern is that subsidising demand without addressing supply simply pushes prices higher, and that the equity loan structure creates a future repayment burden that many buyers don’t fully understand when they sign up.

That lack of understanding is a real problem. Martin Dewar, head of residential conveyancing at T G Baynes Solicitors, said that under Help to Buy, buyers generally understood the deposit and monthly payment but rarely grasped the exit mechanics. Redemption, remortgaging, and selling brought an extra party — the government — into the transaction, which could hold up completions years later. Conveyancers now have to explain these terms clearly at the outset, and firms should request the scheme’s legal documents well before applications open.

Then there’s the wider industry bottleneck. Landmark’s independent market research found that property professionals spend roughly 34% of their working day chasing or being chased for updates. 67% of home movers experienced uncertainty or delays after their offer was accepted. Simon Brown, CEO of Landmark, pointed out that helping people buy has less impact if lengthy transactions and avoidable delays continue putting purchases at risk. A scheme that gets more people into the system without fixing the transaction process could simply shift the bottleneck further along.

Which Route Makes Sense for You

Equity Loan
A government loan that covers a percentage of your home’s purchase price. It’s interest-free for an initial period, then you start paying interest and must repay the loan when you sell, remortgage, or reach the end of the loan term. The repayment amount is based on your home’s current market value, not the original sum borrowed.
Your First Home
Best if you want a new-build, have a very small deposit, and can wait for the scheme to launch in early 2027. The 2.5% deposit is the lowest available, but you’re limited to new-builds from participating developers and subject to income and price caps not yet confirmed.

First Homes
Best if you’re a local first-time buyer or key worker in England and want 100% ownership at a 30–50% discount. The discount is permanent, so you benefit now and the next buyer benefits later. Income cap of £80,000 (£90,000 London) applies.

Shared Ownership
Best if you can’t afford the deposit or mortgage on a full property but can manage a smaller purchase. You buy a share (typically 25–75%), pay rent on the rest, and can staircase to full ownership over time. Works for new-builds and resales.

Lifetime ISA + 95% Mortgage
Best if you have 3+ years to save and want flexibility on property type. Save up to £4,000 a year, get a 25% government bonus (up to £1,000 a year), then use the funds as a 5% deposit on any property up to £450,000. The most common strategy for buyers in 2026.

The choice between these options comes down to your timeline, your income, and the type of property you want. If you’re set on a new-build and can wait until early 2027, Your First Home offers the lowest cash deposit requirement of any current scheme. If you want to buy now, First Homes or a 95% mortgage through the Freedom to Buy scheme are available immediately. If your income is too low to support a full mortgage, Shared Ownership reduces the borrowing needed. And if you’re still saving, a Lifetime ISA gives you a guaranteed 25% return on your contributions up to the annual limit.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Help to Buy coming back in 2026? ▾
Not under the old name, but Your First Home is structurally very similar — a 2.5% deposit with a government equity loan up to 20% on new-builds. Full eligibility rules are due at the Autumn Budget on 28 October 2026.
Can I apply for Your First Home now? ▾
No. Pre-registration is expected to open by the end of December 2026, with first customer applications from February 2027. Nothing to apply for yet.
What happens when the equity loan interest-free period ends? ▾
After five years, you start paying interest on the loan and the amount you repay is based on your home’s current market value. Many buyers remortgage at that point to pay off the government stake.
Does Your First Home work for existing homes or only new builds? ▾
Only new-build homes in England from developers signed up to the scheme. For existing properties, look at the Freedom to Buy mortgage guarantee scheme or Shared Ownership resales.
What’s the difference between First Homes and Shared Ownership? ▾
First Homes gives you 100% ownership at a 30–50% discount. Shared Ownership lets you buy a share (10–75%) and pay rent on the rest. First Homes discount is permanent; Shared Ownership lets you staircase to full ownership.
Should I wait for Your First Home or buy now? ▾
If a current scheme gets you into an affordable home now, there’s little reason to pause for an unfinalised scheme. If you’re not quite ready and have months of flexibility, watch the Budget before committing.

The Real Question Isn’t Whether It Helps — It’s Who It Helps

Your First Home will almost certainly help some people buy a home sooner. A 2.5% deposit is genuinely lower than anything else on the market, and the interest-free period gives breathing room in the early years. But the evidence from Help to Buy suggests that some of that benefit gets absorbed into higher prices, and that the complexity of equity loan repayment catches many buyers off guard further down the line. The scheme also does nothing to fix the transaction delays that put purchases at risk — 67% of movers already experience uncertainty after an offer is accepted, and adding more equity loan transactions into a strained system could make that worse.

The stronger case here is that Your First Home works best as one option among several, not a silver bullet. Combined with a Lifetime ISA for savings, a clear understanding of the equity loan repayment mechanics, and a realistic view of how long the buying process actually takes, it can be a useful tool. Treated as the only route onto the ladder, it risks repeating the same problems the old scheme created. If this was useful, you might also want to read UK Home Buying Regrets: Avoid These Common Pitfalls.

Sources and Further Reading

Essential Tips for Buying a House in the UK — Practical steps for first-time buyers navigating the current market.

Victorian Charm vs Modern Build: The Ultimate UK Home Buying Face-Off — Weighing the trade-offs between period properties and new builds.

Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (2026). New first-time buyer scheme to be confirmed at Budget. 🔗

HM Government. Own Your Home: Government Schemes. 🔗

Landmark (2026). Property professionals spend 34% of day chasing updates. 🔗

Financial Conduct Authority (2026). FCA Handbook and Guidance — Mortgage reforms. 🔗

Bank of England. Mortgage Market Statistics. 🔗

Share this

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Email

Sam Willy

I’m Sam Willy, one of the bright minds behind BritWealth.com, where I share insights, stories, and fun ideas about a wide range of topics—finance included, but not limited to it! My journey into the world of writing began with a simple hobby: sharing the things that fascinated me. From quirky facts to deeper dives into personal development, I’ve always been curious about the world around me and love passing that knowledge on.
Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted

Disclaimer

The content published on BritWealth.com is provided for general informational and educational purposes only and should not be considered financial, legal, insurance, tax, investment, or professional advice. You should always carry out your own research or seek independent professional guidance before making financial or business decisions.

Some content on this website may contain affiliate links. This means BritWealth.com may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase, at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, BritWealth earns from qualifying purchases.

While we make reasonable efforts to keep information accurate and up to date, BritWealth.com makes no representations or warranties, express or implied, regarding the completeness, accuracy, reliability, suitability, or availability of any content on this website.

Any reliance you place on information found on this site is strictly at your own risk. BritWealth.com will not be liable for any loss, damage, or consequences arising from the use of this website or reliance on its content.

By using this website, you acknowledge and agree to this disclaimer and our terms of use.

Table of Contents

Share This

On Trend

Readers'
Top Picks

Understanding Age of Property: Tips for Buying in the UK

Over the past few years, I’ve watched the age of a property become one of the most overlooked factors in a home-buying decision. A report from Historic England shows that well-maintained period properties tend to hold their value better than newer homes, but that doesn’t mean an older house is always the safer bet. The real picture is more nuanced, and getting it wrong can cost you thousands in unexpected repairs or energy bills. 4% Forecast house price rise for 2026 Miller Metcalfe 34 Average age of first-time buyers in England gov.uk 5.5% Annual increase in UK private rents

Read More »

Choosing A Home Near An Airport: Tips For Buying In The UK

If you’re looking at properties near a UK airport, you’ve probably noticed the price difference already. Houses under flight paths tend to be cheaper, and that discount can be tempting. But the trade-off isn’t just about noise — it’s about resale value, health, and how long you’ll actually want to live there. I’ve watched this pattern play out for years, and the same questions keep coming up: how much noise is too much, will the flight path change, and can you ever get your money back out? 24% Potential value added by a well-planned extension nationwide.co.uk 62% Of property

Read More »

UK Property Hotspots 2024: Where Should You Actually Invest?

Predicting UK property hotspots for 2024 requires more than just following market trends; it demands understanding localized regeneration projects, infrastructure investments, and evolving demographic shifts. Forget generalized advice. This guide dives deep into specific areas poised for growth, offering insights into why these locations are attractive, potential pitfalls to consider, and actionable advice to navigate buying in these promising markets. Northwest England: Manchester and Beyond Manchester continues to be a strong contender, but simply buying “in Manchester” is too broad. Look at areas benefiting from its ripple effect. For instance, consider Stockport, which has seen significant investment in its

Read More »
The UK’s Hidden Property Gems: Unveiling Undervalued Areas for Investment
Home Buying Tips

The UK’s Hidden Property Gems: Unveiling Undervalued Areas for Investment

Looking to invest in UK property but tired of the sky-high prices in London and other major cities? You’re in luck! The UK boasts many “hidden gems”—undervalued areas with great potential for growth. We’re diving deep into some of these locations, giving you the inside scoop on where to find affordable properties and promising investment opportunities. This guide provides detailed insights and actionable tips to help you discover the UK’s best-kept secrets in real estate. It’s all about making smart choices, doing your homework, and finding that perfect spot before everyone else does. Manchester: The Northern Powerhouse Manchester is

Read More »

Smart Tips For Buying The Right Exterior Design In The UK

Over 60% of UK households now own at least one smart home device, according to research from 2025. That shift tells you something important: exterior design is no longer just about how a house looks from the street. It is about how the building performs, how it handles weather, and whether the choices you make today will cause problems tomorrow. I have been writing about property and home improvement for years, and the question I hear most often is some version of “where do I even start?” This article walks through what actually matters when planning an exterior design

Read More »

How To Get Prequalified For A Home In The UK

Nearly four out of five UK adults say saving a deposit is one of the biggest barriers to buying a home, according to recent research. That figure has stayed stubbornly high for years, and it’s the first thing people mention when I ask why they haven’t started looking yet. I’ve been covering the UK housing market long enough to see the same pattern repeat: people assume they need a 20% deposit or a perfect credit score before they can even speak to a lender. That assumption keeps a lot of potential buyers stuck in rented homes longer than necessary.

Read More »
UNITED KINGDOM
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x