Airbnb gets blamed for a lot when it comes to housing. Rising rents, disappearing rental stock, neighbourhoods hollowed out by tourist lets—the platform has become shorthand for everything wrong with the property market. But the actual evidence, from multiple countries and academic studies, suggests the story is more complicated than the headlines suggest. Here’s what you actually need to know.
Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through them, Britwealth may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We only include products and services that are relevant to the topic.
This article is general information only and does not constitute professional advice. For your specific situation, consult a qualified professional.
The gap between the political rhetoric and the data is wide. On one side, you have campaign groups and local authorities pointing to short-term lets as a primary cause of housing unaffordability. On the other, a growing body of research suggests the impact is modest—and that the real drivers of the housing crisis lie elsewhere. That doesn’t mean short-term letting has zero effect. It means the debate needs to be grounded in what the numbers actually show, not what feels true.
This matters because the policy response is accelerating. The UK is already seeing landlords exit the buy-to-let market under regulatory pressure, and further restrictions on short-term lets could reshape who can rent property and on what terms. Getting the diagnosis right matters for anyone who owns, rents, or invests in housing.
What’s Actually at Stake in the Short-Term Letting Debate
The risk of getting this wrong isn’t abstract. If policymakers treat short-term lets as the main cause of housing unaffordability, they’ll reach for regulations that reduce tourism income, cut host earnings, and make travel more expensive—without meaningfully improving housing supply or affordability.
An Oxford Economics report commissioned by Airbnb found that short-term rentals generated €149 billion in economic benefits across European Union countries in 2023 and supported 2.1 million jobs. More than half of all short-term rental stays occurred outside major cities, and rural destinations saw their short-term rental nights double since 2020. Domestic travellers made up 67% of stays. This isn’t just a tourism play for city-breakers—it’s a significant economic engine for areas that don’t have a hotel infrastructure to fall back on.
Then there’s the Amsterdam case. After the city imposed strict limits on short-term lets, it saw a 50% reduction in STR stays. But tourist numbers didn’t drop—they shifted to hotels, which increased by 12%. The result was higher hotel prices and an estimated €269 million loss in host earnings for local residents, with no measurable improvement in housing affordability for Amsterdam renters.
The trade-off is real. Cracking down on short-term lets can reduce income for ordinary households, push up hotel costs for visitors, and redirect tourist spending away from residential neighbourhoods—all without fixing the underlying supply problem.
What the Evidence Says About Airbnb and Housing Supply
The Size of the Problem
Start with the basic question: how many homes are actually being pulled out of the long-term market? The numbers vary by city, but they’re consistently small relative to total housing stock.
In Belgium, ING economists calculated that Airbnb removes around 3,000 homes from the regular housing supply in Brussels alone, and nearly 2,000 more in Antwerp and Ghent combined. That sounds like a lot until you see it in context—it represents roughly 0.8% of the country’s rental housing stock. Even accounting for other platforms like Booking.com and Expedia, the share remains below 1%.
Across major European cities—Lisbon, Barcelona, Madrid, Paris, Berlin, and Amsterdam—the Oxford Economics report found that short-term rentals represent less than 0.5% of total housing stock. And even if every one of those listings were returned to the residential market, local housing prices would fall by less than 0.7%. That’s not nothing, but it’s not a solution to a housing crisis either.
In the US, where the data is more granular, a 2021 study published in Marketing Science found that a 1% increase in Airbnb listings in a zip code is associated with a 0.018% increase in rents and a 0.026% increase in home prices. Those effects are statistically measurable but economically tiny—especially compared to the double-digit price growth most cities have experienced over the same period.
What Happens When Cities Ban Short-Term Lets
A handful of cities have tried the nuclear option: banning short-term rentals entirely or imposing restrictions so tight they amount to a ban. The results are instructive.
→ Scroll right to see all columns
| City | Regulation Type | Outcome on Rents/Prices |
|---|---|---|
| Irvine, CA | Complete ban on STRs (2018) | 3% decrease in rents |
| Santa Monica, CA | Licensing + ban on whole-home lets | No significant reduction in prices |
| Paris, France | Strict regulation of secondary home rentals | Rents rose 21%, prices rose 15% in 6 years |
| Amsterdam, NL | Strict limits on STR stays | 50% drop in STRs, but hotel stays rose 12% |
The Irvine ban, one of the strictest in the US, did produce a measurable result: a 2024 report in Real Estate Economics linked it to a 3% decrease in rents. But Irvine is an unusual case—a planned city with a median home price over $1.5 million and among the highest pandemic-era price appreciation in the country. The ban didn’t make housing affordable; it nudged rents slightly lower in a market that remains among the most expensive in the US.
Santa Monica’s experience is perhaps more telling. Despite a significant reduction in whole-home short-term listings after its Home Sharing Ordinance, research found no significant reduction in home prices or rents. Not all units that left the STR market transitioned into long-term rentals—some sat empty, some were sold as second homes, and some were converted to other uses. Short- and long-term leases are not perfect substitutes.
Paris tells a similar story. Despite six years of increasingly stringent regulation on secondary home rentals, rents rose 21% and property prices rose 15% over the same period. The regulations didn’t stop the market from tightening—because the forces driving Paris housing costs have little to do with Airbnb.
Three Misconceptions That Keep Coming Up
Misconception 1: Every STR is a home lost to the permanent market
This is the most common framing, and it’s misleading. Not all short-term lets would become long-term rentals if regulation forced them off platforms. Some are second homes that would sit empty. Some are rooms within owner-occupied homes. Some are properties that were never intended for the long-term rental market—holiday cottages, rural retreats, city pieds-à-terre. The idea that every Airbnb listing represents a family home being withheld from a desperate renter doesn’t match the data. In the US, AirDNA estimates 89% of STR listings are whole-home listings, but even those span a wide range of property types, many of which would never enter the long-term rental pool.
Misconception 2: Banning STRs would fix housing affordability
If the total impact of returning every STR to the residential market is a price reduction of less than 0.7%, then banning them is not a housing policy—it’s a symbolic gesture. The real drivers of unaffordability are structural: restrictive land-use regulations, low construction activity, rising material and financing costs, and a persistent mismatch between the types of homes being built and the types people need. A 2021 estimate from the National Association of Home Builders found that cumulative government regulations account for 23.8% of the final selling price of a single-family home in the US. In Belgium, ING notes that building permits remain at historically low levels despite rising demand, and apartment permits are declining 8% year-on-year even as demand for smaller units grows. These are the bottlenecks that matter.
Misconception 3: STRs only benefit wealthy investors and tourists
The data paints a different picture. Nearly four out of ten short-term rental bookings in 2023 were made by travellers with children. Two-thirds of stays were domestic—meaning local residents using the platform to visit other parts of their own country. Rural destinations, which often lack hotel capacity, saw STR nights double since 2020. The Oxford Economics report estimates that platforms like Airbnb reduced the average cost of overnight stays—including hotels—by €7 across key European cities in 2023. For families who can’t afford a hotel in central London or Paris, short-term lets open up travel options that would otherwise be out of reach.
What This Means for the UK Housing Debate
The UK is not the US or continental Europe, but the structural dynamics are similar. Planning reform, construction capacity, and the cost of building materials matter far more to housing affordability than whether a few thousand properties are listed on Airbnb. That doesn’t mean short-term lets should go unregulated—there are legitimate concerns about noise, community cohesion, and the concentration of tourist lets in certain neighbourhoods. But the evidence suggests that treating STRs as the primary cause of the housing crisis is a misdiagnosis, and misdiagnosis leads to bad policy.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Airbnb actually increase rents? ▾
Would banning short-term lets solve the housing crisis? ▾
How many homes does Airbnb actually remove from the market? ▾
Do short-term rentals benefit local economies? ▾
What happened in cities that banned short-term rentals? ▾
The Real Housing Challenge Isn’t Going Away
The housing crisis predates Airbnb by decades. Blaming short-term lets for rising rents and unaffordable home prices is politically convenient—it identifies a visible target and offers the promise of a simple fix. But the evidence from across Europe and the US suggests that even the most aggressive restrictions on STRs produce, at best, marginal improvements in affordability, and at worst, unintended consequences like higher hotel prices, lost host income, and reduced tourism spending in rural areas.
The harder work—reforming planning systems, increasing construction capacity, aligning housing supply with demographic demand, and stabilising construction costs—is where the real gains lie. Short-term letting regulation has a place in that picture, particularly around licensing, data transparency, and neighbourhood-level concentration. But it’s a small piece of a much larger puzzle. Treating it as the main event is a distraction from the structural reforms that would actually make housing more affordable.
Remember: this article is general information only. For advice on your specific situation, speak to a qualified professional.
If this was useful, you might also want to read The Boomerang Generation: Impact on the UK Housing Demand.
Sources and Further Reading
Why UK Landlords Are Switching to Corporate Lets — Examines the regulatory pressures driving small landlords out of the UK market and what it means for rental supply.
ING (2025). Airbnb: only part of Belgium’s housing affordability problem. 🔗
Reason Foundation (2025). Blaming Short-Term Rentals Won’t Solve the Housing Crisis. 🔗
Oxford Economics (2024). Harnessing the Short-Term Rental Advantage in Europe. Commissioned by Airbnb. 🔗
Marketing Science (2021). The Impact of Airbnb on Rents and Home Prices. 🔗
Real Estate Economics (2024). The Effect of Short-Term Rental Bans on Rents: Evidence from Irvine. 🔗
National Association of Home Builders (2021). Government Regulation in the Price of a New Home. 🔗