Is Localism the Key to Solving the UK’s Housing Shortage?

In 2023-24, private renters spent 34% of their income on housing, the highest share of any group. That means for every £100 earned, £34 goes straight to rent before anything else — food, bills, or savings. For those on the lowest incomes, that figure jumps to 63%. I’ve been watching this pattern tighten for years, and the numbers keep telling the same story: the system isn’t working for the people who need it most.

34%
Private renters’ income spent on housing (2023-24)
gov.uk

63%
Lowest-income private renters’ housing cost share
gov.uk

1.5m
Concealed households in England (2023-24)
gov.uk

200k
Homes built in England (2023-24) vs 1.5m target
centreforcities.org

The government wants to build 1.5 million homes this Parliament, but barely 200,000 were built last year. That gap isn’t just a statistic — it’s the reason 1.5 million households in England now contain someone who would move out if they could afford to. The debate about localism — giving communities more say over what gets built and where — keeps coming up as a potential fix. But does it actually work? Here’s what you need to know.

Local control doesn’t mean no building
Giving councils and communities more say can speed things up — if the rules are clear and consistent.

Discretion slows everything down
England’s case-by-case planning system is unusually restrictive compared to rules-based zoning abroad.

Cities need density most
The worst shortages are in economically successful cities where demand is highest and supply is most constrained.

Other countries do it differently
France, Germany and Japan all build more homes using zoning systems that give developers certainty.

What localism actually means for housing

When people talk about localism in housing, they usually mean giving councils and communities more power over what gets built in their area. That sounds good in principle — who doesn’t want a say in their neighbourhood? But the way England’s planning system works right now, that local discretion often becomes a bottleneck. Every planning application is decided case by case, which means even projects that meet all the rules can be rejected by councillors. That uncertainty discourages builders from starting in the first place.

Discretionary planning system
A system where each planning application is assessed individually rather than against a fixed set of rules. England is unusual internationally for using this approach.

What I’ve noticed over the years is that the debate tends to get stuck in a false choice: either central government dictates everything, or local communities block everything. The real answer sits somewhere in the middle. Countries like Germany and Japan use rules-based zoning — if your proposal follows the local plan, it gets approved. That gives communities a say in writing the rules, but once the rules exist, developers know where they stand. My first move would be to look at how that balance works in practice, not just in theory.

Why the current system is failing renters and first-time buyers

The housing crisis isn’t spread evenly. The worst shortages are in the most economically successful cities and towns, where jobs draw people in but the planning system disconnects housing supply from local demand. That mismatch hits renters hardest. In 2023-24, 32% of private renters reported difficulty affording their housing costs, compared to just 14% of mortgagors. For social renters, it was 28%.

Consider a young couple in London, both working, earning just enough to rent a one-bedroom flat. They’re part of the 1.5 million concealed households — people living with family or flatmates because they can’t afford a place of their own. Over half of those in concealed households are aged 16 to 24. That’s not a lifestyle choice; it’s a structural failure. The system isn’t just slow — it’s actively preventing homes from being built where they’re needed most.

The affordability gap is widening
Private renters in the lowest income quintile saw their housing cost share rise from 56% in 2019-20 to 63% in 2023-24 — a 7 percentage point jump in just four years. That’s £7 more out of every £100 earned going to rent, with no improvement in housing quality or security.

What I’d say to anyone feeling stuck is this: the problem isn’t that you’re not earning enough. It’s that the system isn’t building enough homes in the places where you need to live. And until that changes, the pressure on rents will keep building.

Where the localism argument goes wrong

The most common mistake I see is assuming that local control automatically means less building. That’s not what the evidence shows. The problem isn’t localism itself — it’s the type of planning system we’ve layered on top of it. England’s discretionary system means every application is a fight, even when it follows the local plan. That uncertainty pushes up costs and delays projects for years.

Mistaking discretion for democracy

Giving councillors the power to reject compliant applications isn’t democratic — it’s unpredictable. Developers can’t plan around a system where approval depends on who shows up to a meeting. That’s why France, Germany and Japan all build more homes than England does, despite having strong local input. Their systems are rules-based: follow the plan, get permission.

Ignoring the density question

Many local objections focus on preserving “character” — which often means blocking any development denser than detached houses. But Britain needs more homes in its cities, not just on greenfield sites. The Centre for Cities data shows that densification needs to happen in urban areas where employment is concentrated. Blocking that just pushes development further out, increasing commuting and carbon emissions.

Treating all communities the same

The housing shortage varies hugely by region. In London, 8% of households contain someone who can’t afford to move out, compared to 4% in the North East. A one-size-fits-all approach to localism ignores these differences. What works for a rural village won’t work for a city centre, and pretending otherwise just delays solutions.

Source: English Housing Survey 2023-24
Housing cost burden by tenure % of income on housing % reporting difficulty affording costs
Private renters 34% 32%
Social renters 26% 28%
Mortgagors 19% 14%

What I’d flag here is that the mistake isn’t made by communities alone. National policymakers have also failed by not providing a clear framework. If you tell local councils to build more homes but give them no tools to manage density or design, you’re setting everyone up for conflict. The fix isn’t less localism — it’s better localism, with rules that everyone understands upfront.

How to make localism work for housing supply

Writing about topics like this takes real time and research. If you buy something through an Amazon link on this page, I may earn a small commission — at no extra cost to you. It’s one of the things that makes it possible to keep BritWealth free to read. I only link to products that are genuinely relevant to the article.

Replace discretion with flexible zoning

The single most effective change would be moving from England’s discretionary system to a flexible zoning system. Under this model, local communities still write the plan — deciding where homes go, how tall buildings can be, and what types of housing are allowed. But once the plan is in place, developers who follow it get automatic approval. That’s how Germany and Japan do it, and they build more homes as a result. The government has already started moving in this direction with changes to the National Planning Policy Framework, but it needs to go further.

Target densification in cities

Britain doesn’t just need more homes — it needs them in the right places. That means building up, not just out. Centre for Cities research shows that densification needs to happen in urban areas where jobs are concentrated. If you’re a local councillor, that might mean approving four-storey apartment blocks near train stations instead of only detached houses. If you’re a resident, it might mean accepting that your neighbourhood will change — and that change can bring better services and shorter commutes.

Use land value capture to fund infrastructure

One reason communities resist development is that they bear the costs — more traffic, pressure on schools — while developers take the profits. Land value capture changes that by taxing some of the increase in land value that comes from planning permission, then using that money for local infrastructure. It’s not a new idea, but it’s rarely used effectively in England. Done right, it could turn opponents into supporters by making sure new homes come with new schools, parks, and transport links.

Learn from successful experiments

Croydon’s Suburban Design Guide, a rules-based planning experiment from 2019 to 2022, showed that clear design standards can speed up approvals while maintaining quality. The approach gave developers certainty about what would be accepted, and the result was faster decisions without worse outcomes. That kind of pilot could be expanded nationally. If you’re involved in local planning, pushing for similar design guides in your area is a practical step you can take right now.

  • 1
    Understand your local plan
    Check your council’s local plan online. It sets out where development is allowed and what types of housing are prioritised. Knowing this helps you engage meaningfully in consultations.

  • 2
    Support rules-based reform
    Write to your MP or councillor asking for a move toward flexible zoning. Point to the Croydon experiment or international examples as evidence that it works.

  • 3
    Attend planning committee meetings
    These are public. Hearing how decisions are made — and where they get stuck — gives you a clearer picture of what needs to change locally.

What I’d do if I were advising a local council is start with the data. Look at where demand is highest, where infrastructure already exists, and where density can increase without harming quality of life. Then write a local plan that reflects those priorities — and stick to it. Certainty is what unlocks investment, not more meetings.

Frequently asked questions about localism and housing

Does localism mean fewer homes get built? ▾
Not necessarily. The issue isn’t local control itself — it’s the discretionary system that lets councils reject compliant applications. Rules-based zoning with local input can actually speed things up.
How many homes does England actually need? ▾
The government target is 1.5 million homes this Parliament, but only 200,000 were built in 2023-24. Centre for Cities estimates a backlog of 4.3 million missing homes.
What’s the difference between discretionary and rules-based planning? ▾
Discretionary means every application is decided case by case. Rules-based means if your proposal follows the local plan, it gets approved automatically. Most other countries use the latter.
Can local communities still object under a zoning system? ▾
Yes — objections happen when the local plan is being written, not after. That’s when communities have the most influence over what gets built and where.
Why don’t developers just build on brownfield land? ▾
Brownfield sites are often more expensive to develop because of contamination and infrastructure costs. Without clear rules and faster approvals, many sites stay vacant.

The housing shortage isn’t going to fix itself. But the evidence is clear: localism can work if it’s built on rules, not discretion. The countries that build more homes don’t ignore local voices — they give communities a say in writing the plan, then stick to it. That’s the shift England needs.

If this was useful, you might also want to read why UK first-time buyers are struggling and what can be done.

Sources and Further Reading

Is co-living the answer to the UK’s affordable housing crisis? — Explores an alternative model that could ease pressure on traditional housing supply.

English Housing Survey 2023-24: Experiences of the housing crisis. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government, 2024.

Centre for Cities: Housing research and data. Centre for Cities, 2024.

Share this

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Email

Sam Willy

I’m Sam Willy, one of the bright minds behind BritWealth.com, where I share insights, stories, and fun ideas about a wide range of topics—finance included, but not limited to it! My journey into the world of writing began with a simple hobby: sharing the things that fascinated me. From quirky facts to deeper dives into personal development, I’ve always been curious about the world around me and love passing that knowledge on.
Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted

Disclaimer

The content published on BritWealth.com is provided for general informational and educational purposes only and should not be considered financial, legal, insurance, tax, investment, or professional advice. You should always carry out your own research or seek independent professional guidance before making financial or business decisions.

Some content on this website may contain affiliate links. This means BritWealth.com may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase, at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, BritWealth earns from qualifying purchases.

While we make reasonable efforts to keep information accurate and up to date, BritWealth.com makes no representations or warranties, express or implied, regarding the completeness, accuracy, reliability, suitability, or availability of any content on this website.

Any reliance you place on information found on this site is strictly at your own risk. BritWealth.com will not be liable for any loss, damage, or consequences arising from the use of this website or reliance on its content.

By using this website, you acknowledge and agree to this disclaimer and our terms of use.

Table of Contents

Share This

On Trend

Readers'
Top Picks

Decoding UK Property Jargon: A BritWealth Guide.

Buying or selling a home in the UK means wading through a language that can feel deliberately confusing. Terms like “exchange,” “conveyancing,” and “leasehold” get thrown around as if everyone already knows what they mean. Most people don’t — and that lack of clarity can cost time, money, and stress. A single misunderstanding about a lease term or a property form can delay a sale by weeks or leave you with unexpected bills. Here’s what you actually need to know. Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through them, Britwealth may earn

Read More »

Are UK Property Prices About to Plummet? A Realistic Outlook

If you’ve been watching the UK property headlines over the past year, you’ve probably seen a confusing mix of predictions — some warning of a crash, others pointing to steady growth. The reality, as I’ve seen covering this market for a while, is more nuanced than either extreme. House prices across the country rose by just 1.8% in the year to November 2025, leaving the average home valued at £272,998 according to Nationwide. That’s below the rate of inflation, which means in real terms, prices are actually falling. So the question isn’t really whether prices will plummet — it’s

Read More »

Is the UK Property Ladder Broken? A BritWealth Investigation.

The gap between a starter home and a family home in the UK has just hit a record high. In March 2026, the average asking price for a typical first-time buyer property (0–2 bedrooms) stood at £226,955, while a mid-market second-stepper home (3–4 bedrooms) cost £345,857. That is a cash difference of £118,902 — a 52% premium, the widest percentage gap since Rightmove began tracking in 2001. For anyone trying to move up the ladder, that figure isn’t abstract. It means the next rung is now more than half as expensive again as the first one. 52% Record premium

Read More »

Is green property investment the next big thing in the UK

The net zero economy in the UK is now worth over £100 billion a year. That figure isn’t just a headline for policymakers. It tells you that money is flowing into energy efficiency, renewable infrastructure, and sustainable construction at a scale we haven’t seen before. For anyone who owns property or is thinking about buying, that shift changes the rules. £105bn Gross value added by the net zero economy theguardian.com 1.1m Total jobs in net zero and supply chains theguardian.com 58% Office occupiers affected by ESG in rent decisions ft.com 70% UK commercial property rated EPC C or below

Read More »

The Hidden Costs of Homeownership: Are You Really Ready?

Becoming a homeowner in the UK is often touted as a major life milestone, the pinnacle of financial security. But beyond the deposit and mortgage repayments lie a series of often-overlooked costs that can significantly impact your financial well-being. These hidden expenses can range from routine maintenance and repair bills to unexpected legal fees and fluctuating service charges. Understanding these potential financial burdens is crucial to ensure you’re truly ready to take the plunge into homeownership. Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT): More Than Just a Percentage Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT) is a tax you pay when you buy

Read More »

How to rent out UK commercial properties successfully

Commercial property in the UK is seeing a curious split. Prime rental growth has been running higher than normal, not because tenant demand is booming, but because very little new space is being built. According to Savills research, undersupply is the main driver, and unless a wave of new developments or tenant exits changes the picture, that pressure on rents will continue. That sounds like good news for landlords, but the reality is more complicated. Different sectors are moving at different speeds, and the rules around leases and service charges are shifting. Here’s what you actually need to know.

Read More »
UNITED KINGDOM
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x