Rethinking Retirement Savings: Alternatives to Traditional Pensions

Around 15 million people in the UK are currently undersaving for retirement, according to the Pensions Commission’s May 2026 interim report. That’s not a small gap — it’s roughly one in four working-age adults who aren’t putting enough aside to maintain their living standards after work ends. And the problem goes deeper: 45% of working-age adults — about 18 million people — aren’t saving into any pension at all, despite many being in work.

Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through them, Britwealth may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We only include products and services that are relevant to the topic.

This article is general information only and does not constitute professional advice. For your specific situation, consult a qualified professional.

15 million
people undersaving for retirement
UKPol.co.uk

45%
working-age adults not saving into a pension
UKPol.co.uk

4%
self-employed workers saving for retirement
UKPol.co.uk

52%
DC pension contributors with low engagement
Gov.uk

Auto-enrolment has been a genuine success — 89% of eligible employees now save into a workplace pension, up from 55% in 2012. But participation alone doesn’t equal adequacy. Half of savers are contributing at the minimum level, and low and middle earners are most at risk. The Pensions Commission, relaunched in July 2025 on the model of the original Turner Commission, is tasked with fixing this. Its final report is due in early 2027. For anyone under 50 today, the changes it recommends could reshape how retirement savings actually work. Here’s what you actually need to know.

Most people aren’t saving enough — even those who are saving
Auto-enrolment got millions into the habit, but minimum contributions leave most short of a comfortable retirement. The Commission’s focus has shifted from “getting people saving” to “getting enough saved.”

Half of pension pots are cashed out early
3 in 10 private pension pots are accessed at the earliest possible opportunity, and half of all pots taken out are withdrawn in full — often for cars, holidays, or renovations rather than retirement income.

The self-employed are almost entirely left out
Just 4% of wholly self-employed workers save for retirement, and the rate is even lower among younger self-employed people. Auto-enrolment doesn’t cover them, and no replacement has been designed yet.

New pension models are being designed right now
Collective Defined Contribution schemes, guided retirement defaults, and auto-consolidation of small pots are all being developed. The next few years will change what a “normal” pension looks like.

Collective Defined Contribution (CDC)
A hybrid pension model where contributions are defined (like a DC scheme) but the investment and longevity risk is shared across a pool of members rather than falling entirely on the individual. CDC schemes are being explored as a way to provide more predictable retirement income without the full cost of a defined benefit guarantee.

What I tend to notice is that most people still think of a pension as a single thing you either have or don’t. The reality is more fragmented — and the alternatives now being built could change that. If you’re just starting to think about this, the case for starting early has never been clearer.

The Real Retirement Savings Numbers

The headline figures from the Pensions Commission tell a story that’s hard to ignore. 45% of working-age adults — roughly 18 million people — have no pension savings at all. Among those who do work, 2 in 5 still aren’t saving. And for those who are, around half are contributing only the minimum auto-enrolment level, which is widely considered insufficient for a comfortable retirement.

45% of working-age adults have no pension savings at all
That’s 18 million people. Of those in work, 2 in 5 still aren’t saving. The auto-enrolment success story is real, but it has a massive gap in the middle.
Working-age adults not saving into a pension45%

The engagement problem is just as serious. Over half of adults contributing to a Defined Contribution pension have low or very low levels of engagement with their pension. 31% don’t even know their pot is invested. And 68% of non-retirees expect their pension income to fund their retirement — meaning most people are betting on a system they barely understand.

Life expectancy adds another layer of uncertainty. A man reaching State Pension age in 2025 has a 25% chance of dying before 79 and a 25% chance of living beyond 91. A woman at the same point has an average life expectancy of around 89, with a 1-in-10 chance of reaching 98. That means retirement income needs to last for decades, not years. The Pension Schemes Act, which benefits 22 million workers by up to £29,000 by retirement, is designed to help with this — but only if people stay engaged.

→ Scroll right to see all columns

Source: Pensions Commission report
Group Saving rate Key risk
Eligible employees (auto-enrolment) 89% Most at minimum contribution level
Working-age adults overall 55% 45% not saving at all
Self-employed workers 4% Almost entirely outside the system
Low and middle earners Around half at minimum Inadequate contributions for lifestyle

These aren’t abstract figures. A 30-year-old on median earnings saving only the minimum auto-enrolment amount could end up with a retirement pot far below what they’d need for a comfortable retirement — especially if they take career breaks, work part-time, or move between jobs. The gap between what people save and what they’ll need is the central problem the Commission is trying to solve.

Where the Current System Falls Short

Early access is draining pots before retirement

3 in 10 private pension pots are accessed at the earliest possible opportunity, and half of all pots taken out are withdrawn in full. The research shows that nearly half of these withdrawals are for large expenses — cars, holidays, renovations — not for retirement income. This is a mechanical problem: once the money is out, it’s gone, including the tax relief and compound growth it would have earned. The 33% of people who partially encashed their pension felt confident they had enough to last, but only 30% of those who fully encashed said the same.

Low engagement means poor decisions

31% of DC pension contributors don’t know their pot is invested. Over half have low engagement. When it comes time to access the money, 38% of people who decumulated a DC pension in the last four years did so without receiving any financial advice. The government’s guided retirement principles aim to fix this by designing default pension paths that don’t require complex decision-making — but those rules are still being developed.

The self-employed are almost invisible in the system

Only 4% of wholly self-employed workers save for retirement. Among younger self-employed people, the rate is even lower. Auto-enrolment doesn’t cover them because there’s no employer to set up the scheme. The Pensions Commission’s remit includes expanding coverage, but no specific solution has been proposed yet. For anyone self-employed, the gap isn’t just about saving less — it’s about having no structured option at all.

  • Check your current pension contributions — are you at the minimum or have you increased them?
  • Review your National Insurance record for gaps that could affect State Pension entitlement
  • If self-employed, set up a personal pension or SIPP even with small contributions
  • Before accessing any pension pot, check how it affects your future income and benefits
  • Consider speaking with a financial advisor before making withdrawal decisions

Alternative Approaches to Retirement Savings

Collective Defined Contribution (CDC) schemes

CDC schemes are the most significant structural alternative to traditional DC pensions. Instead of each person carrying their own investment and longevity risk, the risk is shared across a pool of members. This provides more predictable income in retirement without the full cost of a defined benefit guarantee. The Pensions Commission is exploring CDC models as part of its review, and the Pension Schemes Act has paved the way for their wider adoption. For most savers, the appeal is straightforward: less uncertainty about how long the money will last.

Guided retirement and default pension paths

The government’s guided retirement principles, published under the Pension Schemes Act 2026, require trustees to provide well-designed default pensions. The idea is that most savers should only need to make one decision — when to access their pension — and whether to stay in the default or choose an alternative. The FCA is introducing rules to make these defaults available through workplace pensions. For someone with low engagement, this removes the need to navigate complex investment choices, sequencing decisions, and withdrawal strategies on their own.

Auto-enrolment expansion and the self-employed gap

The government has ruled out changes to auto-enrolment contribution levels this Parliament, but the Commission’s remit includes expanding coverage to groups currently excluded. The most obvious gap is the self-employed, who make up a growing share of the workforce. The Commission is also looking at how to close the gender and income disparities that leave women and low earners with significantly smaller pots. The final report in 2027 is expected to recommend specific changes to contribution tiers and eligibility thresholds.

What the Pension Schemes Act 2026 means for you

The Act is designed to benefit 22 million workers by up to £29,000 by retirement through lower costs, better returns, and auto-consolidation of small pots. For anyone who has changed jobs multiple times — which is most people under 40 — small pots scattered across old employers will be consolidated automatically. This matters because lost pots are a major source of disengagement. If you can’t find your pension, you can’t manage it. The Act also enables the guided retirement framework, meaning the default you’re placed into at retirement will be designed to provide a sustainable income, not just a lump sum.

For those who want to understand how these changes fit into a broader retirement plan, a financial advisor can help clarify the options based on your specific circumstances.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I lose my pension if I don’t engage with it? ▾
Not directly, but low engagement means you’re likely to stay in a default fund that may not match your retirement goals, and you risk making poor withdrawal decisions. 31% of DC contributors don’t know their pot is invested — that’s lost growth potential.
What happens if I take my pension early and then need more money later? ▾
Once money is withdrawn, it’s gone permanently — including future growth and tax relief. 3 in 10 pots are accessed at the earliest opportunity, and half are fully cashed out. You can’t put it back.
Is the State Pension enough to live on? ▾
The full new State Pension is around £11,500 per year. For most people, that’s below what’s considered a comfortable retirement income. The Commission is reviewing how the State Pension interacts with private savings to prevent low-income retirees from falling through cracks.
What if I’m self-employed and haven’t saved anything? ▾
You’re not alone — 96% of self-employed workers don’t save for retirement. Starting a personal pension or SIPP, even with small regular contributions, is the most straightforward option. The Commission is expected to recommend better solutions by 2027.
How does the Pension Schemes Act affect me? ▾
The Act benefits 22 million workers by up to £29,000 by retirement through lower costs, better returns, and auto-consolidation of small pots. It also introduces guided retirement defaults so you don’t need to make complex decisions alone.

What Comes Next for UK Retirement Savings

The Pensions Commission is running through 2026, with its final report due in early 2027. The government has already ruled out changes to auto-enrolment contribution levels in this Parliament, meaning the next window for structural reform opens in 2028 or later. But the direction of travel is clear: the system is moving from “get people saving” to “get enough saved.” For anyone currently in work, the decisions made in the next two years will determine how much you’re expected to save, how your pension is managed by default, and what happens to the small pots you’ve left behind at old jobs.

Remember: this article is general information only. For advice on your specific situation, speak to a qualified professional.

If this was useful, you might also want to read Retire Rich, Live Lush: Is a £500k Pension Enough in the UK?.

Sources and Further Reading

Retirement Planning for Millennials — A practical guide for younger savers who need to start thinking about adequacy, not just participation.

Retirement Regrets: Avoid These Common Mistakes — Real-world pitfalls that cost savers thousands, including early access and low engagement.

UKPol.co.uk (2026). Britain is undersaving for retirement, warns Pensions Commission. 🔗

Gov.uk (2026). Pension Schemes Act 2026: Guided Retirement Guiding Principles. 🔗

UKEmploymentHub.com (2025). The Pensions Commission Returns: Rethinking Retirement for a New Generation. 🔗

Share this

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Email

Sam Willy

I’m Sam Willy, one of the bright minds behind BritWealth.com, where I share insights, stories, and fun ideas about a wide range of topics—finance included, but not limited to it! My journey into the world of writing began with a simple hobby: sharing the things that fascinated me. From quirky facts to deeper dives into personal development, I’ve always been curious about the world around me and love passing that knowledge on.
Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted

Disclaimer

The content published on BritWealth.com is provided for general informational and educational purposes only and should not be considered financial, legal, insurance, tax, investment, or professional advice. You should always carry out your own research or seek independent professional guidance before making financial or business decisions.

Some content on this website may contain affiliate links. This means BritWealth.com may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase, at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, BritWealth earns from qualifying purchases.

While we make reasonable efforts to keep information accurate and up to date, BritWealth.com makes no representations or warranties, express or implied, regarding the completeness, accuracy, reliability, suitability, or availability of any content on this website.

Any reliance you place on information found on this site is strictly at your own risk. BritWealth.com will not be liable for any loss, damage, or consequences arising from the use of this website or reliance on its content.

By using this website, you acknowledge and agree to this disclaimer and our terms of use.

Table of Contents

Share This

On Trend

Readers'
Top Picks

Future-Proofing Your Pension: Is It Prepared for Inflation?

Inflation is eating away at the real value of savings, and your pension is no exception. You need to actively manage your pension to ensure it retains its purchasing power during retirement. This article explores how inflation impacts your pension in the UK and provides strategies to safeguard its future value. Understanding Inflation’s Impact on Your Pension Inflation is the rate at which the general level of prices for goods and services is rising, and consequently, the purchasing power of currency is falling. A pension of £20,000 a year might seem adequate today, but in 20 years, with inflation

Read More »

Mastering Your Finances: A Simple Guide to Managing Your Money in Retirement.

Retirement in the UK marks a significant life transition, demanding a shift in financial strategy. Moving from earning a regular income to relying on pensions, savings, and investments requires careful planning and management. This guide provides a comprehensive overview of managing your money effectively during retirement in the UK, ensuring financial security and peace of mind. Understanding Your Retirement Income The first step in mastering your finances in retirement is understanding exactly where your income will come from. This involves identifying all potential sources and estimating their likely amounts. A clear picture of your income streams is crucial for

Read More »

Leaving a Legacy: How to Pass on Your Values and Wealth to Future Generations

Retirement in the UK offers a unique opportunity to reflect on your life’s achievements and plan how to leave a lasting legacy for future generations. This involves more than just distributing assets; it’s about passing on your values, wisdom, and experiences so your influence continues to shape the lives of your loved ones long after you’re gone. This comprehensive guide explores the practical steps involved in creating a meaningful legacy plan, encompassing financial strategies, estate planning, and the invaluable task of sharing your story. Understanding Legacy Planning in the UK Landscape Legacy planning in the UK extends beyond traditional

Read More »
The Real Reason UK Pension Advice Is So Expensive
Retirement

The Real Reason UK Pension Advice Is So Expensive

Only 9% of UK adults receive financial advice about their pensions and investments. For the other 91%, cost is usually the reason. A standard pension review runs between £500 and £1,500. Retirement planning can cost £1,000 to £3,000. For someone with a £300,000 pension pot, a 0.75% annual advice fee works out at £2,250 every year. That is real money — and it explains why most people handle retirement planning alone. Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through them, Britwealth may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We

Read More »

Retirement Friendships: Building a Support Network in Later Life in Britain

Retirement in the UK presents a significant life transition, often accompanied by shifts in social circles and a need for new connections. Building a robust support network of friends becomes crucial for maintaining well-being, combating loneliness, and enriching the retirement experience. This article explores the importance of retirement friendships in Britain, offering practical advice and insights to help individuals cultivate meaningful relationships during this phase of life. The Importance of Friendship in Retirement Retirement often sees a reduction in social interaction previously provided by the workplace. This can lead to feelings of isolation and loneliness, which have been shown

Read More »

Financial Freedom Without a Fortune: Retirement on a Budget in the UK.

Financial freedom in retirement doesn’t always require a vast fortune. In the UK, many individuals successfully retire comfortably on a budget by carefully planning, making informed financial decisions, and adapting their lifestyles. This article explores practical strategies and actionable tips for achieving a fulfilling retirement without needing to be wealthy. Understanding Your Retirement Needs in the UK Before embarking on your retirement planning journey, it’s crucial to understand your projected financial needs. This involves calculating your estimated expenses and anticipated income. Consider various factors, such as housing costs, healthcare, food, transportation, leisure activities, and any outstanding debts. Also, factor

Read More »
UNITED KINGDOM
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x