A car is stolen or broken into every 42 minutes in Victoria, according to Insurance Council of Australia analysis that found the state recorded a 25 per cent increase in motor theft claims from 2024 to 2025, with the total bill hitting $243 million across more than 12,500 claims. Nationally, motor theft claims rose 2.5 per cent to 29,000 in 2025, with total incurred costs of $485 million. Whether you’re dealing with theft, an accident, or minor damage, the claims process is where your insurance either delivers or falls apart. Here’s what you actually need to know.
Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through them, Britwealth may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We only include products and services that are relevant to the topic.
This article is general information only and does not constitute professional advice. For your specific situation, consult a qualified professional.
Those dispute numbers matter because they tell you something straightforward: insurers get it wrong sometimes, and the system for pushing back exists for a reason. But the process works better when you know the rules going in. The revised General Insurance Code of Practice, submitted to ASIC in October 2026, is set to make key consumer protections contractually enforceable for the first time, which shifts the balance further toward policyholders who understand their rights.
If you’re sorting out cover or comparing options, it’s worth reading up on how to find affordable car insurance in Australia before you need to claim.
What Breaks When You Get the Claims Process Wrong
The most expensive mistake isn’t crashing the car — it’s handling the claim badly afterward. A rejected claim can leave you covering the full repair bill, plus the vehicle’s lost value, plus higher premiums from insurers who now see you as higher risk. And the data suggests it’s not rare.
The Australian Financial Complaints Authority closed more than 32,000 general insurance disputes in 2025, with comprehensive car insurance being the single most complained-about product. Nearly four in ten of those complaints were decided in favour of the person who lodged them. That’s a lot of people who had to fight for what they’d already paid for.
Then there’s the loyalty tax. ASIC’s March 2026 insurance pricing review found that existing customers are charged an average of $312 more per year than new customers for identical policies. If you don’t shop around at renewal — or at least ask your current insurer to match a new-customer quote — you’re overpaying by hundreds of dollars annually. That’s money you could put toward a lower excess or better cover.
What Actually Matters When Making a Claim
A common trap: assuming your policy covers everything the same way. Modified cars in Australia need specific cover, and standard policies often exclude aftermarket parts unless you’ve declared them.
Common Claim Mistakes That Cost You
Admitting Fault at the Scene
You’re not the one who decides who caused the accident. Insurers assess fault based on evidence, witness statements, and police reports. Apologising or accepting blame at the scene can be used against you later, even if the other driver was primarily at fault. Exchange details, take photos, and leave the fault determination to the professionals.
Claiming for Damage Below Your Excess
If the repair bill is $800 and your excess is $1,000, you’re paying the full repair cost yourself anyway — plus you lose any no-claim discount you’d built up. Moneysmart notes that insurers calculate your no-claim bonus based on your claims history, and ratings typically start at six and reduce by one each claim-free year. A single small claim can reset years of discount accumulation. Run the numbers before you lodge.
Choosing a Repairer Without Insurer Approval
If you take your car to a local mechanic without getting the insurer’s go-ahead, and the insurer disagrees with the cost or scope of work, they can settle the claim in cash for what they consider reasonable. You’d then have to cover the difference out of pocket. Always get written approval for repairs before work starts.
Not Disclosing Information Accurately
Non-disclosure or incorrect disclosure is one of the most common reasons claims get rejected. Hiding driving offences, existing vehicle damage, or modifications can void your cover entirely. If you’re unsure whether something matters, declare it anyway — the insurer will tell you if it affects your policy.
→ Scroll right to see all columns
| Situation | What to Do | What NOT to Do |
|---|---|---|
| Minor collision, no injuries | Exchange details, take photos, move vehicles to safety | Admit fault or agree to settle without documentation |
| Damage below your excess | Get a repair quote and compare against your excess + NCD loss | Lodge a claim automatically without checking the maths |
| Insurer rejects your claim | Ask for written reasons, request internal review, escalate to AFCA | Accept the decision as final — you have options |
| Using your own repairer | Inform insurer first, get written cost approval before work begins | Start repairs and hope the insurer agrees to pay later |
How to Lodge a Car Insurance Claim in Australia
The process itself is straightforward if you’ve done the prep work. Here’s the sequence that covers most situations.
-
1Gather EverythingYou’ll need: the other driver’s name, contact number, licence number, and registration. Your own policy number. The location, date, and time of the incident. A description of what happened. Photos of damage and the scene. Police report number if applicable. Witness names and contact details if available.
-
2Contact Your InsurerCall or use the insurer’s app or website to notify them. Ask what’s covered under your policy, what your excess will be, and whether you’re entitled to a hire car or accommodation. This is also the time to ask about repairer options and whether your policy includes after-accident care like towing or transport.
-
3Lodge the Formal ClaimFill out the claim form — usually online, via app, by phone, or by mail. Provide all the information you gathered in step one. You can ask the insurer to start the claim just to get a repair cost estimate, then decide whether to proceed once you know the figures.
If your claim is rejected, insurers are expected to respond within ten days or tell you how long the assessment will take. The first step is to ask for the rejection reasons in writing. Then request an internal review and provide any additional evidence you have. If that doesn’t work, you can escalate to the Australian Financial Complaints Authority — it’s free to use and resolved more than 32,000 disputes in 2025. If AFCA can’t resolve it, you can apply to a tribunal or go to court, but that requires private legal advice and may involve extra costs.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long do I have to lodge a car insurance claim in Australia? ▾
Should I claim if the damage is minor? ▾
What happens if my car insurance claim is rejected? ▾
Can I choose my own repairer after an accident? ▾
How does making a claim affect my premium? ▾
The Shift Toward Stronger Consumer Protections
The general insurance industry is moving toward a more enforceable set of standards. The revised General Insurance Code of Practice, submitted to ASIC in October 2026, makes key consumer protections contractually enforceable for the first time. That means if an insurer doesn’t meet its obligations under the Code — around claims handling, vulnerability support, or response times — you’ll have a direct contractual right to hold them to it, not just a voluntary promise.
The Code also introduces automatic claim acceptance for home and motor claims where no decision has been made within 12 months due to circumstances within the insurer’s control. For anyone who’s waited months for a claims decision, that’s a meaningful change. The Code is awaiting ASIC approval, after which a transition period will apply before it takes effect on new and renewed policies.
If this was useful, you might also want to read how your postcode affects your car insurance premium in Australia.
Sources and Further Reading
Understanding how your address affects car insurance in Australia — Why where you park matters for your premium and cover.
Insurance Council of Australia (June 2026). Victoria still leads Australia’s car crime insurance claims. 🔗
Forbes Advisor Australia (2026). How to make a car insurance claim. 🔗
Mozo (October 2026). Best car insurance in Australia. 🔗
Insurance Council of Australia (October 2026). Insurers submit enhanced Code of Practice to regulator. 🔗
Moneysmart (n.d.). No-claim bonus on car insurance. 🔗