Leadership in a Crisis: Lessons from Top Canadian CEOs

In March 2026, Thomas d’Aquino delivered the 20th Ivey-Thomas d’Aquino Lecture on Leadership at the National Gallery of Canada, launching a series that celebrates the Business Council of Canada’s 50th anniversary. The lecture framed a crisis that is worldwide — geopolitical fracture, democratic retreat, populism, protectionism, declining trust in institutions, and AI disruption. For Canadian business leaders, this isn’t abstract. Prime Minister Mark Carney addressed the World Economic Forum in Davos in January 2026, challenging middle powers and business leaders to respond. The question is what practical lessons emerge from top CEOs who have already navigated severe crises.

Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through them, Britwealth may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We only include products and services that are relevant to the topic.

This article is general information only and does not constitute professional advice. For your specific situation, consult a qualified professional.

62%
Canadian CEOs now prioritising M&A since early 2026
EY-Parthenon CEO Survey

80%
Canadian leaders ramping up AI investment despite regulatory uncertainty
EY-Parthenon CEO Survey

$100M
Netflix’s bet on “House of Cards” when studios pulled licensed content
CNBC

54
Frontal impact crashes linked to GM’s faulty ignition switch crisis
CNBC

These figures point to a pattern. Crisis leadership isn’t about staying calm and repeating platitudes. It’s about making specific, high-stakes decisions under conditions where the usual playbook doesn’t apply. The Canadian CEOs surveyed by EY-Parthenon operate in what they call a NAVI landscape — nonlinear, accelerated, volatile, interconnected. That’s not jargon. It describes an environment where the old rules of quarterly planning and incremental change no longer hold. Here’s what you actually need to know.

What Crisis Leadership Actually Demands

Bet Against the Crowd
Netflix’s Ted Sarandos invested $100 million in original content when competitors pulled back. The bet redefined the company.

Protect People First
Shake Shack’s Danny Meyer created a staff relief fund and a job-placement system during COVID-19, then restructured tipping to cover kitchen workers.

Own the Failure
GM’s Mary Barra inherited a deadly ignition-switch crisis weeks into her CEO tenure. She chose transparency over legal containment.

Think Nationally
D’Aquino argues Canadian business leaders have three duties: strengthen national unity, stabilise the Canada-US relationship, and build domestic resilience.

These four takeaways cut across industries and crisis types. What they share is a willingness to act decisively when the safe option looks like waiting. The central concept here is crisis decision-making under uncertainty — the ability to commit resources, change structures, or admit fault when the outcome is genuinely unknown.

Crisis Decision-Making Under Uncertainty
The process of making high-stakes choices when available information is incomplete, timelines are compressed, and conventional models no longer apply. It requires committing to a course of action before the full picture emerges.

What I tend to notice is that leaders who handle crises well don’t wait for perfect data. They identify the one or two moves that matter most and execute them while others are still forming committees. That’s worth weighing against the instinct to gather more information before acting.

What Changes When You Get Crisis Leadership Wrong

The cost of poor crisis leadership isn’t abstract. GM’s faulty ignition switch crisis, which Mary Barra inherited just weeks after becoming CEO, involved at least 54 frontal impact crashes and over a dozen deaths. The company’s response — or lack of it before Barra took over — had already damaged trust beyond repair for many families. Barra’s approach was to establish transparency, customer support, and a commitment to never let such failures happen again. That didn’t undo the harm, but it stopped the bleeding.

For Canadian business leaders, the stakes are structural. D’Aquino’s lecture framed three duties that go beyond shareholder returns: strengthen national unity and the integrity of the Canadian economic union, re-establish stability in the Canada-United States relationship, and build economic and security resilience at home. These aren’t optional extras. They’re the conditions under which Canadian businesses operate. Ignoring them during a crisis doesn’t just hurt a single company — it weakens the broader environment every business depends on.

The NAVI Reality Check
Canadian CEOs now operate in a nonlinear, accelerated, volatile, interconnected landscape. The EY-Parthenon survey found that geopolitical tensions, macroeconomic volatility, and talent shortages are the top three drivers influencing CEO decisions over the next 12 months. These aren’t temporary disruptions — they’re structural shifts.

The EY-Parthenon CEO Outlook Survey, which polled 1,200 leaders globally including Canada in March-April 2026, found that Canadian CEOs’ M&A appetite climbed from 46% to 62% since the start of 2026. That’s a 16-point jump in a few months. It suggests that many leaders see crisis as an opportunity to reposition, but it also raises the risk of rushed deals. The difference between a smart acquisition and a costly mistake often comes down to whether the leadership team has a clear framework for decision-making under pressure.

Where Leaders Commonly Misstep

Waiting for Certainty Before Acting

The most common error is paralysis. Netflix’s Ted Sarandos didn’t wait to see whether streaming originals would work before greenlighting a $100 million investment in “House of Cards.” He called it an existential decision. Film and TV studios had pulled back on licensed content, and Netflix needed its own library. Waiting would have meant losing the window. What I’d do in that situation is identify the one decision that, if made now, changes the trajectory — and make it before the data is complete.

Treating Crisis as a PR Problem

When Mary Barra took over GM, the instinct might have been to lawyer up and limit liability. Instead, she established transparency and customer support as the operating principles. That didn’t eliminate legal exposure, but it prevented the crisis from becoming a permanent brand liability. Leaders who treat a crisis as a communications exercise rather than an operational failure usually make things worse.

Ignoring the Human Layer

Danny Meyer’s response at Shake Shack during COVID-19 included creating a fund to help laid-off staff cover urgent expenses and establishing a system to help them find jobs at companies like Whole Foods. He also returned to tipping, paying a percentage of sales to all kitchen and non-tip eligible workers. That’s not charity — it’s retention strategy. Leaders who focus only on financial metrics during a crisis often lose the people they’ll need when recovery starts.

Acting Alone

D’Aquino’s lecture emphasised that Canadian business leaders have been inseparable from nation-building since Confederation in 1867. The foundational example was building the Canadian Pacific Railway from Eastern Canada to Vancouver in just over four years, six years ahead of schedule. That didn’t happen because one CEO made smart calls. It happened because business and government coordinated. Leaders who try to navigate a crisis without engaging the broader ecosystem — other businesses, regulators, community organisations — miss the structural leverage that comes from collective action.

How to Lead Through a Crisis: The Practical Mechanics

Identify the Existential Decision

Every crisis has one or two decisions that determine the outcome. For Netflix, it was whether to invest in original content when licensed content was drying up. For GM, it was whether to admit fault or fight every claim. The first step is to name that decision explicitly. Write it down. If you can’t state it in one sentence, you haven’t identified it yet. Once you have, the next step is to assess what information you actually need versus what would be nice to have. Most leaders overestimate the first and underestimate the second.

Build a Decision Framework, Not a Plan

Plans assume the future will look like the past. Frameworks assume it won’t. A decision framework specifies your principles, your risk tolerance, and your escalation triggers. For example, Danny Meyer’s framework during COVID-19 was: protect staff first, then customers, then shareholders. That order of operations guided every specific choice he made. Without a framework, you end up making each decision from scratch, which is slow and inconsistent. A business law consultation can help clarify the legal boundaries of your framework, especially around employment and contractual obligations during a crisis.

Communicate in Real Time, Not After the Fact

Barra’s approach at GM was to establish transparency from day one. That meant telling the public what the company knew, what it didn’t know, and what it was doing to find out. Most leaders default to communicating only when they have complete information. In a crisis, that’s a luxury you don’t have. The rule of thumb is: share what you know when you know it, even if the picture is incomplete. People can handle uncertainty better than they can handle silence.

Prepare for the Next Crisis While Managing the Current One

The EY-Parthenon survey found that Canadian CEOs view mega trends as structural shifts affecting operations well into the future. That means the current crisis isn’t the last one. Leaders who emerge stronger are those who use the present disruption to build systems that will handle the next one. That might mean investing in AI despite regulatory uncertainty — 80% of Canadian leaders are doing exactly that. It might mean restructuring supply chains or building more resilient business models. The key is to treat crisis response and long-term strategy as the same conversation, not two separate ones.

The Emerging Regulatory Landscape

Canadian CEOs are ramping up AI investment despite evolving regulation. That’s a calculated risk. The regulatory framework isn’t settled, but waiting for clarity could mean falling behind competitors who are already deploying the technology. The approach that makes sense here is to invest in AI capabilities while building in flexibility — systems that can adapt to whatever regulations emerge. That might mean using modular AI tools rather than monolithic platforms, or working with legal advisors who specialise in intellectual property and compliance to ensure your AI investments don’t create future liability.

Frequently Asked Questions

What’s the first thing a CEO should do when a crisis hits? ▾
Identify the existential decision — the one or two choices that will determine the outcome. Everything else is secondary. Communicate what you know immediately, even if the picture is incomplete.
How do you balance transparency with legal risk? ▾
Mary Barra’s approach at GM shows that transparency and legal protection aren’t mutually exclusive. Share what you know factually. Avoid speculation. Work with legal counsel to frame disclosures, but don’t let legal caution prevent honest communication.
Should you invest during a crisis or conserve cash? ▾
It depends on whether the investment addresses an existential threat or an opportunity. Netflix invested $100 million in original content when studios pulled licensed content. That wasn’t optional — it was survival. Conserve cash for non-essential spending, but fund the moves that define your future.
How do you keep employees focused during a crisis? ▾
Danny Meyer’s approach at Shake Shack was to address employees’ immediate needs first — relief funds, job placement, fair tipping. Once people feel secure, they can focus on work. Ignoring the human layer creates distraction and turnover at the worst possible time.
What’s the biggest mistake leaders make in a crisis? ▾
Waiting for perfect information before acting. Crises don’t provide complete data. The leaders who succeed are those who make high-stakes decisions with incomplete information, using a clear framework rather than a detailed plan.
How do Canadian CEOs view the current crisis landscape? ▾
The EY-Parthenon survey found that Canadian CEOs see geopolitical tensions, macroeconomic volatility, and talent shortages as the top three drivers over the next 12 months. They describe the environment as NAVI — nonlinear, accelerated, volatile, and interconnected.

Why Crisis Leadership Is a Long-Term Capability, Not a Short-Term Fix

The Canadian Pacific Railway was built in just over four years, six years ahead of schedule. That wasn’t because the leaders of the time were smarter or braver. It was because they understood that a crisis — in that case, the existential need to unite a country — required a different kind of decision-making. They committed resources, coordinated across sectors, and kept moving even when the path wasn’t clear. The same principle applies today. The Canadian CEOs surveyed by EY-Parthenon are operating in a NAVI landscape that isn’t going to revert to something more predictable. The leaders who build crisis decision-making as a permanent capability, rather than a temporary response, will be the ones who shape what comes next.

Remember: this article is general information only. For advice on your specific situation, speak to a qualified professional.

If this was useful, you might also want to read Building a Strong Personal Brand: A Guide for Canadian Professionals.

Sources and Further Reading

Building Resilient Businesses: Lessons from Canada’s Pandemic Response — Practical strategies for creating operational resilience drawn from Canadian businesses that navigated COVID-19.

Beyond the Numbers: Ethical Leadership in the Modern Accounting World — How ethical frameworks support better decision-making under pressure, relevant for leaders across industries.

Policy Magazine (2026). Business Leadership in a Time of Crisis: The 2026 Ivey Thomas d’Aquino Lecture on Leadership. 🔗

CNBC (2025). From Netflix to Uber: How 8 Top Leaders Used Crisis to Reinvent Companies. 🔗

EY (2026). EY-Parthenon CEO Outlook Survey. 🔗

Share this

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Email

Sam Willy

I’m Sam Willy, one of the bright minds behind BritWealth.com, where I share insights, stories, and fun ideas about a wide range of topics—finance included, but not limited to it! My journey into the world of writing began with a simple hobby: sharing the things that fascinated me. From quirky facts to deeper dives into personal development, I’ve always been curious about the world around me and love passing that knowledge on.
Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted

Disclaimer

The content published on BritWealth.com is provided for general informational and educational purposes only and should not be considered financial, legal, insurance, tax, investment, or professional advice. You should always carry out your own research or seek independent professional guidance before making financial or business decisions.

Some content on this website may contain affiliate links. This means BritWealth.com may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase, at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, BritWealth earns from qualifying purchases.

While we make reasonable efforts to keep information accurate and up to date, BritWealth.com makes no representations or warranties, express or implied, regarding the completeness, accuracy, reliability, suitability, or availability of any content on this website.

Any reliance you place on information found on this site is strictly at your own risk. BritWealth.com will not be liable for any loss, damage, or consequences arising from the use of this website or reliance on its content.

By using this website, you acknowledge and agree to this disclaimer and our terms of use.

Table of Contents

Share This

On Trend

Readers'
Top Picks

The Untapped Potential of Rural Markets in Canada: Opportunities and Challenges

Canada’s rural markets are brimming with untapped potential for businesses of all sizes. While often overlooked in favor of urban centers, these communities offer unique advantages, including lower operating costs, less competition, and a strong sense of community loyalty. However, unlocking this potential requires a strategic approach that considers the specific challenges and opportunities present in rural areas. Understanding the Rural Canadian Landscape Defining “rural” in Canada is more complex than simply looking at population density. Statistics Canada classifies areas based on population size and density, with rural areas generally referring to communities outside of Census Metropolitan Areas (CMAs)

Read More »

BritWealth: 5 Financial Habits Holding CA Entrepreneurs Back

Canadian entrepreneurs are known for their innovation and drive, but certain financial habits can significantly hinder their business growth and long-term success. Overlooking key areas like diligent budgeting, strategic debt management, proactive tax planning, robust insurance coverage, and consistent investment in growth opportunities can create unnecessary hurdles. This article will explore these five crucial financial habits and provide actionable strategies to help Canadian entrepreneurs thrive. 1. Neglecting Detailed Budgeting and Forecasting One of the most common pitfalls for Canadian entrepreneurs is failing to create and consistently adhere to a detailed budget. A budget isn’t just a number; it’s a

Read More »

Navigating Uncertainty: Key Strategies for Business Resilience in Canada

Canadian businesses face a complex and ever-changing landscape, navigating uncertainties ranging from economic fluctuations and supply chain disruptions to technological advancements and evolving consumer demands. Building resilience – the ability to withstand and recover quickly from difficulties – is no longer optional but essential for survival and long-term success. This article provides actionable strategies for Canadian businesses, offering a roadmap to proactively prepare for and navigate uncertainty. Understanding the Canadian Business Environment The Canadian business landscape is characterized by a unique set of factors. Its open economy is heavily influenced by global trade, making it susceptible to international economic

Read More »

From Startup to Scale-Up: The Biggest Hurdles for CA Businesses.

Moving a business from the initial startup phase to a successful scale-up presents unique challenges for Canadian entrepreneurs. It’s not just about replicating what worked in the beginning; it requires a strategic shift in mindset, operations, and resource allocation. This article explores the significant hurdles faced by Canadian businesses as they navigate this critical transition and offers practical advice to overcome them. Accessing Capital for Growth in Canada One of the most significant hurdles for Canadian businesses scaling up is securing adequate funding. While seed funding might have been sufficient to get started, scaling often requires substantial capital injections

Read More »

Rethinking Leadership: What it Takes to Thrive in the Canadian Business Landscape

Canadian business leadership is undergoing a significant transformation. The traditional top-down, hierarchical model is increasingly ill-suited for today’s dynamic and complex environment. To thrive, leaders in Canada must adopt a more collaborative, adaptable, and purpose-driven approach that fosters innovation, inclusivity, and resilience. This involves not just understanding the specific challenges and opportunities of the Canadian market, but also cultivating the skills and mindset necessary to navigate them effectively. The Shifting Tides: Why Traditional Leadership is Failing For decades, leadership in Canada, as elsewhere, was largely defined by authority and control. Leaders were expected to have all the answers, make

Read More »

ESG Investing in Canada: Hype or a True Path to Sustainable Growth?

ESG investing—incorporating environmental, social, and governance factors alongside financial metrics—is rapidly gaining traction in Canada. While some view it as a passing fad driven by hype, others believe it represents a fundamental shift towards sustainable economic growth. The crucial question is: Is ESG investing a genuine catalyst for positive change in the Canadian business landscape, or is it simply a marketing tactic? The Rise of ESG in Canada: A Landscape Overview Across the Canadian business spectrum, you’ll find considerable interest and growing adoption of ESG principles. Pension funds, asset managers, and increasingly, individual investors are allocating capital to companies

Read More »
CANADA
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x