If your company works in energy, mining, forestry, infrastructure, or any sector where a project touches land in Canada, the constitutional duty to consult Indigenous communities isn’t a box you tick near the end — it’s a requirement that can halt approvals entirely. The Supreme Court has made clear that the Crown must consult and, where appropriate, accommodate Indigenous groups when proposed activities could affect asserted or established Aboriginal or treaty rights. And with both federal and British Columbia legislation now pushing to align Canadian law with the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP), the bar keeps rising. Here’s what you actually need to know.
Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through them, Britwealth may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We only include products and services that are relevant to the topic.
This article is general information only and does not constitute professional advice. For your specific situation, consult a qualified professional.
That’s the scale of the landscape. Three distinct Aboriginal peoples are recognised in the Constitution Act, 1982 — First Nations, Inuit, and Métis — and their rights are constitutionally protected through Section 35. Those rights aren’t abstract. They cover lands, practices, customs, and traditions that were integral to each group’s distinctive culture before European contact. For a business, that means the ground you’re building on may already carry legal obligations you didn’t account for.
What’s at Stake When Consultation Falls Short
The duty to consult is triggered for the vast majority of Crown approvals for resource development. The scope of that duty depends on two things: how strong the claim to an Aboriginal right or title is, and how serious the potential impact on that right would be. A weak claim with minor impacts might only require notice and information-sharing. A strong claim or established right with significant impacts can demand deep consultation — the opportunity to make submissions, participate in decision-making, and receive written reasons for the outcome.
When consultation is inadequate, the consequences are concrete. Approvals and permits can be delayed or called into question. Community and investor relations suffer. Litigation for injunctions or damages becomes a real risk. Project schedules and costs take serious hits. The November 2023 Quebec Superior Court ruling in the White and Montour tobacco case showed one judge finding that UNDRIP guaranteed the right of Indigenous Canadians to sell tobacco — a decision the Quebec government appealed in January 2024, with lawyers expecting the case could reach the Supreme Court of Canada.
British Columbia’s experience is instructive. The province passed the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act (DRIPA) in November 2019 — the first jurisdiction in Canada to adopt UNDRIP standards legislatively. DRIPA mandates the government to bring provincial laws into alignment with the UN Declaration and to develop an action plan in consultation with Indigenous Peoples. One of its four main themes is the right of First Nations to own, use, develop, and control lands and resources within their territories. That has direct implications for any business operating in BC.
Key Concepts That Shape Indigenous Business Relations
Aboriginal title is a distinct concept worth understanding separately. It’s a right to the land itself — the right to occupy it, decide how it’s used, and benefit economically from its use. The Supreme Court has placed three limitations on it: the land must be collectively held, it can’t be alienated except to the Crown, and it can’t be developed in a way that would substantially deprive future generations of the benefits of the land. Once Aboriginal title is proven, the consent of the Indigenous group is required for the Crown or a proponent to proceed with development on those lands. Absent consent, the Crown must justify the incursion by a compelling and substantial governmental objective consistent with its fiduciary duty. So far, Aboriginal title has been established on four occasions, all in British Columbia.
Where Business Approaches Commonly Go Wrong
The most frequent mistake is treating consultation as a procedural checkbox rather than a relationship-building process. The duty to consult is a constitutional duty, not a courtesy. It must be conducted in good faith and be meaningful. There’s no standalone duty on the Crown or a proponent to reach an agreement with an Indigenous group — but good faith consultation can give rise to a duty to accommodate, and inadequate consultation can lead to litigation regardless of whether a deal was ever required.
A second common gap is timing. Many proponents wait until the formal regulatory review process begins before engaging with Indigenous groups. The smarter approach — and one that experienced legal advisors consistently recommend — is to engage from the earliest stages of project planning. Early and effective consultation is one of the most critical factors affecting the viability and ultimate success of a project.
Third, businesses often underestimate the complexity of overlapping claims. In British Columbia especially, there’s a significant degree of overlap between Indigenous groups’ asserted territories. A proponent may need to consult with multiple groups, some with overlapping claims or interests, each with its own consultation policy and process.
Fourth, capacity funding catches many companies off guard. Indigenous groups frequently require capacity funding to participate meaningfully in consultation — including funding for third-party Indigenous knowledge and land-use studies. This isn’t optional padding; it can be necessary to ensure consultation is meaningful, though the specifics are fact-dependent.
→ Scroll right to see all columns
| Right Type | Source | Key Implication for Business |
|---|---|---|
| Aboriginal rights | Practices, customs, traditions integral pre-contact | Harvesting rights (hunting, fishing, gathering) can limit land use |
| Aboriginal title | Pre-existing occupation of land | Consent required for development; collective ownership; can’t be sold except to Crown |
| Treaty rights | Historic and modern agreements with Crown | Terms vary widely; may include land, resources, self-government, economic development provisions |
| Section 35 protection | Constitution Act, 1982 | All above rights constitutionally protected; Crown can infringe only if justified |
Building Relationships That Work
There’s no single template for a successful agreement with an Indigenous group — the scope and content vary widely among projects and communities. But a few patterns are clear from the research.
Impact-benefit agreements (IBAs) have become standard for major projects. These can include employment opportunities, support for education and training initiatives, contracting and business opportunities, and financial benefits such as annual royalty payments or equity interests. Some provinces enter into agreements where tax or other government revenue is shared with interested Aboriginal groups. Certain governments are increasingly expecting these agreements to be in place before they’ll issue an approval.
Equity participation is a growing trend. Major projects increasingly provide a range of economic benefits including equity participation through various financial models. Projects with Indigenous equity participation typically require more sophisticated advice to ensure the project is financeable and uses the most efficient tax structure. But the payoff is real: successful agreements can mitigate risk, provide increased regulatory certainty, strengthen relationships, address concerns, and establish stable frameworks that manage Indigenous-related risks over the life of the project.
For projects on Indigenous lands themselves — and this is increasingly common — the legal regime gets more specific. Federal laws often don’t adequately cover developments on Indigenous lands, and federal and provincial regulators frequently have concerns about the lack of applicable provincial environmental protection regimes, particularly on major projects. The First Nations Commercial and Industrial Development Act is one tool that Indigenous groups, governments, and project proponents can use to voluntarily apply specified provincial laws to projects on Indigenous lands where a regulatory gap exists in the federal regime.
Throughout all of this, experienced legal advice is essential. The regulatory regimes and case law are constantly evolving. Understanding the potential scope of rights and interests — and building successful relationships and agreements from project inception through completion — are key elements of any successful project in Canada today.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the duty to consult apply to my business directly or only to the Crown? ▾
What’s the difference between asserted and established Aboriginal rights? ▾
Do I need to get Free, Prior and Informed Consent from Indigenous groups? ▾
What happens if we can’t reach an agreement with an Indigenous group? ▾
Are there different rules for projects on reserve lands? ▾
The Direction of Travel Is Clear
The legal and practical landscape for Indigenous-business relations in Canada is moving in one direction: toward deeper engagement, higher expectations, and more partnership-based models. The federal UNDRIP Act and BC’s DRIPA aren’t static documents — they require governments to keep aligning law and policy with the UN Declaration over time. The action plans they generate directly affect permitting practice, consultation expectations, and the tenor of engagement for project proponents.
What worked five years ago — minimal engagement, treating consultation as a regulatory hurdle, offering standard compensation — no longer meets the standard. Indigenous groups have more legal tools at their disposal, including the ability to raise UNDRIP in consultations and litigation. The Quebec Superior Court’s 2023 tobacco ruling, the ongoing Tupa’s Joint cannabis case in BC, and the Amikwa case in Ontario all show that courts are taking these arguments seriously.
For businesses, the practical takeaway isn’t complicated: early, good-faith engagement with affected Indigenous communities, informed by experienced legal guidance, is the most reliable path to project viability. The companies that treat this as a core part of project planning — not an afterthought — are the ones that avoid the delays, litigation, and reputational damage that come with getting it wrong.
Remember: this article is general information only. For advice on your specific situation, speak to a qualified professional.
If this was useful, you might also want to read Navigating Excessive Compliance Burdens in Canada.
Sources and Further Reading
The Great Canadian Productivity Paradox: How to Boost Output in 2024 — Explores structural challenges facing Canadian businesses, including regulatory and relationship factors that affect project delivery.
McCarthy Tétrault (2026). Doing Business in Canada: Aboriginal Law. 🔗
Dentons (2026). Doing Business in Canada: Aboriginal Law and Aboriginal Community Relations. 🔗
Government of British Columbia. Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act (DRIPA). 🔗
United Nations (2007). United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. 🔗
Constitution Act, 1982, Section 35. 🔗
Koutouki, K. & Lofts, K. (2019). Cannabis, Reconciliation, and the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. Alberta Law Review, 56(3), 709. 🔗