Why Canadian Investors Are Avoiding Long-Term GICs Right Now

The Bank of Canada started cutting rates in June 2024, and the one-year GIC rate has since dropped from above 5% to roughly 2.62%. Yet Canadian households still held roughly $497-billion in GICs through 2022 to 2024, and that number hasn’t budged much since the cuts began. Here’s what you actually need to know.

Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through them, Britwealth may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We only include products and services that are relevant to the topic.

This article is general information only and does not constitute professional advice. For your specific situation, consult a qualified professional.

75%
Of the past 40 years, bonds beat one-year GIC returns
RPIA

2.62%
Current one-year GIC rate (down from 5%+)
BMO ETFs

$497B
Flowed into GICs from 2022 through 2024
Globe and Mail

8%
Peak inflation — GIC returns didn’t keep pace
Globe and Mail

GICs were the safe harbour during the 2022 storm. Stocks and bonds both took double-digit losses, and a 5–6% risk-free return looked like a gift. But the tide has turned. Bond markets are recovering, fixed-income ETFs are seeing record inflows, and the tax treatment of GIC interest is starting to sting more as rates fall. Investors who locked into longer terms are now watching their money earn less than inflation while being fully taxed on the nominal gain. The question isn’t whether GICs still have a place — it’s whether locking in for multiple years still makes sense when the rate environment has shifted so sharply.

Bonds beat GICs in most years
Over 40 years, bond returns exceeded one-year GIC returns in 29 of them — nearly 75% of the time. The exceptions were mostly during rising-rate periods.

Tax treatment favours bonds
GIC interest is fully taxed as income at your marginal rate. Corporate bond returns can include capital gains, which get more favourable tax treatment.

Liquidity matters more now
Non-redeemable GICs lock your money in. Actively managed bond funds let you redeem within days, which matters when rates are shifting and opportunities appear.

Inflation ate the real return
With inflation peaking at 8%, even a 5% GIC was losing purchasing power. After tax, the real return was often negative.

GIC (Guaranteed Investment Certificate)
A deposit product that guarantees your principal and a fixed interest rate for a set term. Interest is fully taxable as income. Non-redeemable GICs cannot be cashed early without penalty.

What I’d flag first: the tax difference alone can flip the math. For an Ontario investor in the top bracket, the after-tax return on a one-year GIC at 5% might be roughly equivalent to a bond yielding less, once you factor in capital gains treatment. That gap widens as GIC rates fall and bond prices rise.

What changes when rates drop

When the Bank of Canada cuts rates, bond prices typically rise. That’s basic bond math — existing bonds with higher coupon rates become more valuable. GICs don’t do that. Your locked-in rate stays the same, and if you want to get out early, you pay a penalty. The RPIA analysis of bond versus GIC returns shows that in years following rate-hiking cycles — 1995, 2000, and 2014 — the US Aggregate Bond Index produced more than twice the return of one-year GICs. That pattern is repeating now.

The real cost of locking in
A non-redeemable GIC locks your money for the full term. If rates rise or an emergency hits, you’re stuck. Bond funds let you sell within days. That flexibility has real value when the economic outlook is uncertain.

There’s also a demographic factor at play. A significant number of Canadian households are holding cash in GICs specifically because they face mortgage resets and need the money available for refinancing. That’s not an investment strategy — it’s a holding pattern. The BMO analysis on persistent GIC holdings identifies mortgage resets as the primary reason GIC assets haven’t shifted despite lower yields. Once those mortgages are refinanced, that money may move elsewhere.

Where the standard advice falls short

Rolling over into lower rates

The most common mistake I see is treating GICs as a set-and-forget vehicle. When a GIC matures, the bank typically offers to renew at the current rate — which is now 2.62% for one year. Rolling over locks you into declining yields. Meanwhile, bond funds that were yielding 4–5% in coupon payments have also seen price appreciation as rates fell. The Globe and Mail report on Canadians moving away from GICs notes that fixed-income ETFs are seeing record inflows, and bond funds are almost single-handedly sustaining the mutual fund business. That’s where the money is going.

Ignoring the tax bite in non-registered accounts

GIC interest is fully taxable at your marginal rate. In a non-registered account, that’s punitive. A corporate bond strategy, by contrast, can generate returns that include capital gains — and only 50% of capital gains are taxable. The JCIC breakdown of GIC tax implications makes this clear: after-tax real returns from GICs often barely exceed inflation, because the yield falls alongside inflation and the tax bill eats the rest. For anyone in a higher bracket, the gap between the headline rate and the after-tax real return is substantial.

Treating safety as the only metric

GICs guarantee principal. That’s true. But principal protection isn’t the same as purchasing power protection. With inflation at 8% and a GIC at 5%, you lost 3% in real terms before tax. After tax, the loss was larger. Bonds carry more price volatility, but over a full cycle they’ve delivered better real returns. The trade-off isn’t safety versus risk — it’s guaranteed nominal loss versus potential real gain.

→ Scroll right to see all columns

Source: RPIA market analysis
Year 1-Year GIC Return Bond Index Return
1995 ~5.5% ~18.5%
2000 ~4.0% ~11.6%
2014 ~1.5% ~5.9%

What to do with maturing GICs now

Compare the after-tax return, not the headline rate

Take your marginal tax rate and calculate what the GIC actually pays after tax. Then compare that to the after-tax return on a short-term bond ETF or a corporate bond ladder. For a top-bracket Ontario investor, the difference can be 1–2% annually. That’s not trivial. A tax professional on JustAnswer can run the specific numbers for your situation, because the GIC-equivalent yield varies depending on whether you have net capital gains over $250,000 or hold investments in a corporate account.

Build a bond ladder instead of a GIC ladder

A bond ladder works the same way as a GIC ladder — you buy bonds or bond ETFs with staggered maturities — but you get daily liquidity and better tax treatment. If rates drop further, your existing bonds appreciate. If rates rise, you reinvest maturing bonds at the new rate. The flexibility alone is worth something in this environment.

Keep short-term cash in high-interest savings or money market funds

For money you need within one to two years, a GIC still makes sense — but only a short-term one. Anything beyond two years introduces reinvestment risk and liquidity constraints that the current rate environment doesn’t reward. A high-interest savings account or a money market ETF gives you a competitive rate without the lock-in.

Frequently asked questions

Are GICs ever a good idea in a falling rate environment? ▾
Yes, for money you need within one to two years. The principal guarantee matters for short-term goals like a house purchase or upcoming tuition. Beyond that, the tax and liquidity disadvantages outweigh the safety.
What happens to my GIC if I need the money early? ▾
Non-redeemable GICs charge a penalty — often the loss of several months’ interest. Some institutions allow early redemption in cases of hardship, but it’s not guaranteed. Cashable GICs exist but pay lower rates.
How does GIC interest get taxed in a TFSA? ▾
GIC interest inside a TFSA is tax-free, which solves the tax problem. But the rate is still low compared to bonds, and the liquidity issue remains. A TFSA is better used for growth assets over the long term.
Should I break my existing GIC to move to bonds? ▾
Only if the penalty is small and the expected bond return significantly exceeds what you’d lose. Run the numbers including the penalty and the tax difference. In most cases, it’s better to wait until maturity.
Are corporate bonds as safe as GICs? ▾
No. GICs are insured by CDIC up to $100,000 per institution. Corporate bonds carry credit risk. A high-quality bond ETF reduces that risk through diversification, but it’s not the same as a government guarantee.

The rate environment has shifted — your strategy should too

GICs served a purpose when rates were high and markets were falling. That period is over. The money that flowed into GICs from 2022 through 2024 is now sitting in products that are losing purchasing power after tax and inflation. The bond market is recovering, fixed-income ETFs are drawing record inflows, and the tax treatment of capital gains gives bonds a structural advantage that GICs can’t match. The question isn’t whether GICs are bad — it’s whether locking in for multiple years still makes sense when the direction of rates is clearly down and the alternatives are more liquid and more tax-efficient.

Remember: this article is general information only. For advice on your specific situation, speak to a qualified professional.

If this was useful, you might also want to read Essential Tips for Tiny Home Insurance in Canada.

Sources and Further Reading

Understanding Hybrid Vehicle Insurance Changes in Canada — A look at how shifting vehicle trends affect insurance costs, relevant for anyone adjusting their broader financial picture.

Vintage Home Insurance Tips for Property Insurance in Canada — Covers property coverage considerations that pair well with a review of fixed-income holdings.

RPIA (2024). The Tide Has Turned: Bonds vs. GICs in a Falling Rate Environment. 🔗

BMO ETFs (2024). Macro Notes: There is Still a Lot of Money in GICs…But Why? 🔗

JCIC (2024). Are GICs a Good Investment in Falling Interest Rates? 🔗

The Globe and Mail (2024). Canadians Are Finally Over GICs. 🔗

Share this

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Email

Sam Willy

I’m Sam Willy, one of the bright minds behind BritWealth.com, where I share insights, stories, and fun ideas about a wide range of topics—finance included, but not limited to it! My journey into the world of writing began with a simple hobby: sharing the things that fascinated me. From quirky facts to deeper dives into personal development, I’ve always been curious about the world around me and love passing that knowledge on.
Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted

Disclaimer

The content published on BritWealth.com is provided for general informational and educational purposes only and should not be considered financial, legal, insurance, tax, investment, or professional advice. You should always carry out your own research or seek independent professional guidance before making financial or business decisions.

Some content on this website may contain affiliate links. This means BritWealth.com may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase, at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, BritWealth earns from qualifying purchases.

While we make reasonable efforts to keep information accurate and up to date, BritWealth.com makes no representations or warranties, express or implied, regarding the completeness, accuracy, reliability, suitability, or availability of any content on this website.

Any reliance you place on information found on this site is strictly at your own risk. BritWealth.com will not be liable for any loss, damage, or consequences arising from the use of this website or reliance on its content.

By using this website, you acknowledge and agree to this disclaimer and our terms of use.

Table of Contents

Share This

On Trend

Readers'
Top Picks

Diversification Strategies: Beyond Traditional Assets for Higher Returns

Canadian investors are increasingly looking beyond traditional assets like stocks and bonds to enhance portfolio returns and mitigate risks in a volatile economic climate. Diversification, therefore, is evolving; it’s not merely about spreading investments across different sectors within the stock market but about exploring alternative asset classes that offer unique risk-return profiles and low correlations with traditional investments. This article dives into the realm of alternative diversification strategies available to Canadian investors, providing practical insights and actionable guidance to navigate this exciting yet potentially complex landscape. Understanding the Canadian Investment Landscape Before delving into alternative assets, it’s crucial to

Read More »

Investing in Mentorship: Paying it Forward and Accelerating Your CA Career.

Mentorship is a powerful catalyst for career growth, particularly in the demanding field of Chartered Accountancy (CA) in Canada. Both as a mentee and a mentor, engaging in mentorship can significantly accelerate your career trajectory, expand your professional network, and provide invaluable insights into the Canadian finance landscape. This article explores the multifaceted benefits of investing in mentorship, both from the perspective of receiving guidance and providing it, focusing on the unique context of the Canadian CA profession. The Power of Mentorship for Aspiring Canadian CAs The path to becoming a Chartered Professional Accountant (CPA, formerly CA) in Canada

Read More »

Alternative Investments Demystified: Exploring Opportunities Beyond Stocks and Bonds

Alternative investments offer Canadian investors avenues for diversification and potentially higher returns compared to traditional stocks and bonds. These investments encompass a broad range of assets, including private equity, real estate, hedge funds, infrastructure, commodities, and collectibles. Understanding the nuances of each category, including their risks and potential rewards, is crucial for making informed investment decisions within the Canadian financial landscape. Defining Alternative Investments in the Canadian Context Alternative investments deviate from the conventional assets traded on public exchanges. They often involve less liquidity, more complex structures, and higher minimum investment thresholds, making them generally less accessible to the

Read More »

Canada’s Next Big Boom: Investing in Untapped Potential

Canada is often viewed as a stable, reliable, and predictable investment environment, but beneath the surface of established markets lies a wealth of untapped potential. Forget the saturated markets; the next big boom in Canada is about identifying emerging sectors, regions, and innovative approaches that offer significant growth opportunities. This article will guide you through these promising areas, providing actionable tips and insights for navigating the Canadian investment landscape. Understanding Canada’s Economic Landscape To effectively target investments, a solid understanding of Canada’s economic foundation is crucial. Canada’s economy is heavily influenced by its natural resource endowment, its trade relationship

Read More »

Is Canada’s Healthcare Free? Uncover Hidden Costs

Canada’s healthcare system is often lauded as “free,” but that’s a simplification. While core medical services are indeed publicly funded, meaning you don’t pay directly out-of-pocket when you see a doctor or visit a hospital for covered services, it’s not entirely without cost. Canadians pay through taxes, and significant expenses exist outside the scope of universal healthcare coverage. Understanding these hidden costs is crucial for financial planning and accessing comprehensive healthcare in Canada. The Core of Canadian Healthcare: What’s Covered? The foundation of Canadian healthcare is the Canada Health Act, which outlines the principles of universality, accessibility, comprehensiveness, portability,

Read More »

CA’s Booming Industries: Where Should You Invest Your Money Now?

Canada’s economy is a mosaic of thriving sectors, presenting numerous opportunities for investors. From the resurgent energy sector to the innovative tech scene and the ever-reliable real estate market, understanding where to allocate your capital is crucial for maximizing returns and mitigating risks. This article delves into some of Canada’s most promising industries, providing insights and actionable strategies to help you make informed investment decisions. We’ll examine the key drivers behind each sector’s growth, potential challenges, and practical examples to guide your investment journey. Remember, this information is for educational purposes only and not financial advice. Energy Sector: Riding

Read More »
CANADA
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x