Canadian investors paid an average of 1.98% annually on equity mutual funds last year — nearly four times the global average of 0.50%. That gap alone explains a lot about why more people are moving away from stock picking and toward low-cost index funds. Here’s what you actually need to know.
Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through them, Britwealth may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We only include products and services that are relevant to the topic.
This article is general information only and does not constitute professional advice. For your specific situation, consult a qualified professional.
Those numbers frame a choice that’s becoming harder to ignore. The typical actively managed mutual fund in Canada costs nearly ten times what an all-in-one ETF charges. On a portfolio of $100,000, the fee gap alone can eat up more than $200,000 in potential growth over three decades. That kind of math is pushing a lot of Canadian investors to reconsider whether picking individual stocks or paying for active management makes sense anymore. The millennial money mindset in particular has shifted hard toward passive, low-cost strategies, and the data backs that move.
What Index Investing Actually Delivers
The idea is straightforward: instead of trying to beat the market by picking winners, you own the whole market and keep costs minimal. Over long periods, that approach has beaten the majority of active fund managers after fees — not every year, but consistently enough that the evidence is hard to argue with. The term you’ll see on every fund fact sheet is the management expense ratio, or MER.
The MER is invisible — you never write a cheque for it — but it compounds relentlessly. Choosing between a 1.98% fund and a 0.20% fund is basically choosing whether to give away a large chunk of your retirement or keep it. For most people, that trade-off settles the index-versus-active question pretty quickly.
The Compound Effect of Paying Too Much
A $100,000 investment over 30 years at a 7% gross return tells the story. With a 0.20% MER, that portfolio grows to roughly $780,000. With a 1.80% MER — typical for an active Canadian mutual fund — it hits about $566,000. The difference of $214,000 is money that left your account in fees, not because the fund performed worse on its investments.
The fee advantage is the headline, but it’s not the only reason the balance is tipping. Index funds also remove the behavioural risk that comes with stock picking — the temptation to chase a hot stock, panic-sell during a dip, or tinker with a portfolio every time the news cycle shifts. A lot of investors who think they’re making active choices are really just introducing more randomness into their returns. What I tend to notice is that the people who stick with a simple index portfolio over a full market cycle almost always come out ahead of those who try to time their way through it.
At the same time, the argument for index funds isn’t as clean as it used to be. Market concentration has risen sharply. The top 10 companies in the S&P 500 now account for roughly 40% of the index’s value — double the historical average and higher than the dot-com peak in 2000. The S&P/TSX Composite has its own concentration problem, weighted heavily toward financials and energy. So holding an index fund means accepting that concentration risk. That’s worth knowing, not a reason to abandon the approach, but a reason to think about what else belongs in your portfolio.
Where the Index Approach Has Blind Spots
Index investing wins on cost and simplicity, but it’s not a set-and-forget solution. The research points to a few places where the strategy can trip up investors who don’t look under the hood.
Assuming All Index Funds Charge the Same
Not all index funds are created equal. TD e-Series index mutual funds carry MERs around 0.30% to 0.50%, while all-in-one ETFs from BMO, iShares, and Vanguard range from 0.15% to 0.25%. The difference sounds small — 0.15% vs 0.50% — but on a $250,000 portfolio over 30 years, that gap adds up to well over $100,000 in extra fees. Checking the MER before buying is the single most important step, and yet a lot of investors skip it because the fund name sounds familiar.
Ignoring Tax Location Across Accounts
Canadian investors often hold the same fund in an RRSP, TFSA, and non-registered account without thinking about which fund belongs where. In a non-registered account, US-listed ETFs trigger withholding taxes on dividends that you can’t fully recover, while Canadian-listed versions of the same index are more efficient. If you hold dividend-heavy ETFs in a TFSA, you’re also losing the tax advantage those dividends could provide in a non-registered account. A multi-ETF DIY approach lets you optimise for tax — an all-in-one ETF forces you to accept some inefficiency for the convenience.
Overlooking the Retirement Income Gap
Index funds are built for accumulation. They don’t automatically solve the drawdown problem in retirement. BlackRock has noted that rising market concentration, geopolitical volatility, and longer retirements mean a traditional index-heavy portfolio may not fund 20-plus years of withdrawals without adjustments. A 65-year-old Canadian man can expect to live another 19.6 years; a woman the same age, 22.2 years. That’s a long time for a portfolio weighted entirely toward equities to sustain steady income. Adding a bond allocation — either through an all-in-one fund like XBAL or VBAL, or through a separate bond ETF — addresses this, but it requires knowing when and how to shift.
→ Scroll right to see all columns
| Fund Type | Typical MER | Minimum Investment | Tax Efficiency |
|---|---|---|---|
| All-in-One ETF (e.g., XEQT, VEQT) | 0.15% – 0.25% | ~$25 – $35 (one share) | High |
| Index Mutual Fund (e.g., TD e-Series) | 0.30% – 0.50% | $100 – $500 | Moderate |
| Active Mutual Fund | 1.50% – 2.50% | $500 – $5,000 | Low |
The table makes the trade-offs visible. The all-in-one ETF wins on cost and tax efficiency and lets you start with very little. The index mutual fund is better suited for people who want automated monthly contributions from a bank account without thinking about trade execution. The active fund, despite its high cost, still holds appeal for investors who want a manager making decisions in volatile markets — though the fee burden is hard to justify against the long-term data.
If you’re working through estate planning or setting up a trust that holds index investments, it’s worth getting the legal structure right from the start. Talking through the options with someone who understands both the investment mechanics and the legal side can save you from costly restructuring later.
Building Your Portfolio: All-in-One or DIY
The main decision for most Canadian investors comes down to one question: do you want a single fund that handles everything, or are you willing to manage a few funds yourself for slightly lower costs and more tax control?
The All-in-One Route
Funds like XEQT (100% equities, 0.20% MER) and XGRO (80% equities / 20% bonds, 0.20% MER) give you global diversification and automatic rebalancing in one ticker. You buy one fund, you’re done. Vanguard’s equivalents — VEQT at 0.24% and VGRO at 0.25% — work the same way. BMO has pushed fees even lower, with ZEQT and ZGRO both at 0.15%. For someone who wants simplicity and is still building the habit of regular investing, this approach removes almost all behavioural risk. You can’t tinker with a single fund.
The DIY Multi-ETF Approach
If your portfolio is large enough that the MER difference between 0.15% and 0.24% actually moves the needle — say, $250,000 or more — holding separate Canadian, US, international, and bond ETFs gives you finer control over asset location. You can keep Canadian equities in a non-registered account for the dividend tax credit, US equities in an RRSP to avoid withholding tax, and bonds in a TFSA or RRSP where interest income is sheltered. The trade-off is that you need to rebalance yourself, usually once a year, and you need enough discipline to do it without emotion. For most people, the all-in-one route makes more sense. Worth weighing against the marginal cost savings if your portfolio is in that range.
Where to Start
Open a brokerage account with Questrade, Wealthsimple, or any of the major bank brokerages. Buy the all-in-one ETF that matches your time horizon — XEQT or VEQT if you’re 10+ years from needing the money, XGRO or VGRO if you’re closer to retirement and want some bond cushion. Set up automatic contributions and reinvest dividends. That’s the whole process. The hardest part is not opening the app and checking the balance every day.
The shift toward index funds isn’t just a Canadian trend — it’s happening globally as fee awareness spreads and the data accumulates. But Canadian investors have a particularly strong incentive, given how high mutual fund fees have been relative to the rest of the world. The great wealth transfer between generations is accelerating this, as younger investors bring a cost-first mindset to portfolios that their parents’ generation accepted at face value.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is index investing really better than picking individual stocks? ▾
What’s the catch with all-in-one ETFs? ▾
How do I choose between XEQT and VEQT? ▾
Can I lose money with index funds? ▾
Do I need to rebalance an all-in-one ETF? ▾
Are dividend ETFs worth the extra yield? ▾
Where the Low-Cost Shift Is Heading Next
The move toward index funds in Canada isn’t a fad. It’s driven by fee data that’s increasingly hard to ignore and by product innovation that makes low-cost investing easier than ever. BMO cutting all-in-one ETF fees to 0.15% and the rise of zero-commission brokerages have removed the last practical barriers. The bigger question going forward is whether index investors will need to supplement their portfolios with other assets — private markets, direct real estate, or income annuities — to address the concentration and retirement-income gaps that pure index strategies leave open. For now, moving from stock picking or high-fee mutual funds to a simple all-in-one ETF is the change that will have the biggest impact on most investors’ outcomes.
Remember: this article is general information only. For advice on your specific situation, speak to a qualified professional.
If this was useful, you might also want to read Tips for Successful Income Suite Development in Canada.
Sources and Further Reading
Essential Tips for Choosing Personal Insurance in Canada — A practical look at protecting your financial plan alongside your investment portfolio.
The Millennial Money Mindset — How younger Canadian investors are reshaping the way money is managed and invested.
LifeMoney.ca (2026). Index Funds vs ETFs vs Mutual Funds in Canada. 🔗
WealthNorth.ca (2026). ETFs and Index Funds — A Canadian Guide. 🔗
Money.ca (2025). Why Index Funds Alone Won’t Fund Your Retirement. 🔗
AOL Finance (2026). Why Picking Individual Stocks May Be the Way to Go Right Now. 🔗
BuildWealthCanada.ca (2026). The Canadian Guide to Index Investing. 🔗
