The federal portion of your student loan has carried a 0% interest rate since April 2023. That changes the old rule about paying off debt before investing — carrying that debt costs you nothing, while money in the market has decades to compound. Here’s what you actually need to know.
Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through them, Britwealth may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We only include products and services that are relevant to the topic.
This article is general information only and does not constitute professional advice. For your specific situation, consult a qualified professional.
Student loans and investments sit on opposite sides of your net-worth statement, but the relationship between them isn’t as simple as “debt bad, investing good.” The federal government made its portion of student loans permanently interest-free in 2023, which means the standard advice to kill all debt before you invest needs a second look. Provincial loans are a different story — some provinces followed Ottawa’s lead, others didn’t. And if you’re in a high tax bracket, borrowing to invest can actually lower your tax bill, provided you follow the Canada Revenue Agency’s rules to the letter.
This guide walks through the trade-offs so you can decide which direction makes sense for your situation. I’ll cover the tax mechanics, the provincial differences that actually matter, and the mistakes that cost people real money.
What Breaks When You Get the Order Wrong
The wrong choice here doesn’t just mean a few hundred dollars in missed gains. It can mean locking yourself out of years of compounding, or carrying expensive debt that eats your returns before you even see them.
Say you have $20,000 in student loans — a mix of federal and provincial — and $20,000 in savings. If your provincial portion carries interest at, say, 6%, and you decide to invest that $20,000 instead of paying down the provincial debt, your investments need to return more than 6% just to break even. That’s doable over a long horizon, but it’s not a sure thing. Meanwhile, the interest on that provincial loan is piling up, and unlike investment loan interest, it’s not tax-deductible.
The opposite scenario is just as common: someone with only federal loans (0% interest) throws every spare dollar at repayment, missing out on years of market growth. A $10,000 investment at 5% grows to roughly $33,863 over 25 years. That same $10,000 used to prepay a 0% loan saves you exactly $0 in interest. The opportunity cost is the entire difference.
The real damage shows up when people mix the two without a plan — using a line of credit meant for investments to cover everyday expenses, or borrowing to invest while carrying credit card debt at 20% interest. The research suggests roughly half of Canadian adults carry credit card debt. That kind of high-interest borrowing needs to be cleared before any leveraged investing makes sense.
What Changes and What Stays the Same
How to Decide: By the Numbers
The decision framework is straightforward once you separate your debts by interest rate and tax treatment. Here’s the order I’d run through.
Step 1: Sort Your Debts by Effective Interest Rate
Federal student loans: 0%. Provincial loans: check your NSLSC account and provincial aid office — anywhere from 0% to a fixed rate. Credit cards: likely 18-22%. Personal loans and car loans: somewhere in between. List them all with their actual rates.
Step 2: Clear High-Interest Consumer Debt First
Nothing else matters until you’ve dealt with debt above about 8-10%. The RBC guide on balancing debt and savings recommends automating both debt payments and savings contributions so you don’t have to decide each month. But the priority order matters: high-interest debt gets paid down before you start leveraged investing.
Step 3: Build Your Emergency Fund
Three to six months of expenses in a liquid account. This isn’t optional. If you’re using leverage and your income dips, you need cash flow that doesn’t require selling investments at a loss or taking on more debt. The BK Financial guide on investment loans stresses that proper risk management includes insurance — life, disability, critical illness — to cover loan payments if something goes wrong.
Step 4: Compare the After-Tax Cost of Borrowing to Invest
If you’re in a high tax bracket and borrowing to buy dividend-paying stocks in a non-registered account, the interest deduction can cut your effective rate significantly. In Quebec, where combined federal-provincial rates can exceed 45%, each dollar of deductible interest is worth more. The CRA’s rules on interest deductibility require that borrowed funds trace directly to income-producing investments and that there’s a reasonable expectation of income. Growth stocks with no dividends don’t qualify.
Here’s the comparison for a typical scenario:
→ Scroll right to see all columns
| Scenario | After-Tax Borrowing Cost | Complexity Level |
|---|---|---|
| No interest deduction (personal use) | Equal to nominal rate | Low |
| Full CRA-approved deduction | Lower than nominal rate | Medium-High (tracking required) |
| Mixed-use loan, partial deduction | Hard to calculate | High (audit exposure) |
Step 5: Stress-Test the Worst Case
Before you borrow to invest, run the numbers on what happens if markets drop 20-30% in the first two years. Can you still make loan payments and cover your living expenses? If the answer isn’t a clear yes, the loan is too large. A written financial plan should show this scenario explicitly.
Mistakes That Cost Real Money
Treating All Student Loans the Same
The federal portion is 0%. The provincial portion might not be. An Alberta borrower with $12,000 in federal loans and $8,000 in provincial loans faces two very different interest rates on the same debt. Paying down the provincial portion first saves actual money. Paying down the federal portion early saves nothing. Check your NSLSC account to see the split.
Borrowing to Invest Before Maxing Out RRSP and TFSA
Interest on loans used to contribute to an RRSP or TFSA is generally not tax-deductible, even if the account later holds income-producing investments. The better sequence for most people: max out RRSP and TFSA room first, then consider borrowing to invest in a non-registered account. The BK Financial guide notes that many clients prioritize RRSP and FHSA first, then look at leveraged investing as an additional engine.
Mixing Personal and Investment Borrowing
Use the same HELOC for a car purchase and an investment, and the CRA will likely deny the interest deduction on the investment portion. The rule is straightforward: borrowed funds must trace directly to income-producing investments. A separate loan or a dedicated HELOC segment keeps the audit trail clean. Mixed-use loans create high audit exposure and make the after-tax cost nearly impossible to calculate.
Ignoring the Repayment Assistance Plan
If you’re struggling with student loan payments, the Repayment Assistance Plan (RAP) can reduce payments to $0 based on income and family size. Enrollment doesn’t harm your credit score. In Ontario, single graduates earning under about $2,100 per month may qualify. The cksaksens.com guide on student loan repayment notes that RAP Stage 1 reduces or eliminates payments while the government covers interest, and Stage 2 may forgive principal after 5 or 10 years. This is a safety net that too many borrowers don’t use.
Taking on Investment Debt Without Insurance
If you’re leveraged and you lose your income, the debt doesn’t disappear. The BK Financial guide recommends life, disability, and critical illness insurance to cover loan payments in unforeseen circumstances. That’s not a sales pitch — it’s a risk management step that determines whether the strategy survives a setback.
When the Math Flips: Scenarios That Change the Answer
The right call depends on more than just interest rates. Here are three situations where the standard guidance shifts.
You’re a high earner behind on retirement savings. If you’re in your early 40s with good income but modest retirement assets, a properly sized investment loan can accelerate accumulation. The BK Financial case study of a Montreal professional couple — both in their early 40s, already using RRSP and TFSA room — used a moderate fixed-rate investment loan with dividend-paying securities. Over five years, projected retirement capital improved significantly despite normal market volatility. The key was clean documentation and stress-testing for rate hikes and market drops.
You have uneven cash flow. A self-employed borrower with fluctuating income should not use a HELOC to invest aggressively. The better path: stabilize cash flow, restructure higher-interest debt, build an emergency fund, then phase in a smaller investment loan. The BK Financial case of a Laval small business owner used separate HELOC segments for personal, business, and investment purposes, preserving interest deductibility and reducing audit risk.
You’re a new graduate with only federal loans. At 0% interest, there’s no financial incentive to prepay. The RBC guide on financial planning suggests scheduling regular contributions to retirement accounts through a Pre-Authorized Contribution plan. Even small amounts grow over time, especially as debt decreases and income grows. The compounding example from RBC — $10,000 at 5% reaching $33,863 over 25 years — shows what you give up by prepaying a 0% loan.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I pay off my student loans before investing? ▾
Is interest on an investment loan tax-deductible in Canada? ▾
What happens to my student loans if I can’t afford payments? ▾
Do student loans affect my credit score? ▾
Can I use a HELOC to invest and deduct the interest? ▾
How much should I borrow to invest? ▾
The Short Version: Know Your Effective Interest Rate
The decision between student loan repayment and investing comes down to one number: your effective interest rate on each dollar of debt. Federal loans cost 0%. Provincial loans cost somewhere between 0% and whatever your province charges. Credit card debt costs 18-22%. Investment loan interest is tax-deductible, which lowers its effective cost.
Pay down the expensive stuff first. Keep the cheap debt while you invest. And if you’re using leverage, stress-test the worst case before you commit. The Quebec tax rules on interest deductibility and the federal CRA framework are both clear — but only if you keep clean records and separate your borrowing.
Remember: this article is general information only. For advice on your specific situation, speak to a qualified professional.
If this was useful, you might also want to read Stop Impulse Buys: The Canadian Guide to Mindful Spending.
Sources and Further Reading
The Power of Automation: Set It and Forget It Savings Strategies for Canadian Residents — How to automate debt payments and investment contributions so you don’t have to decide each month.
Zero-Based Budgeting: Take Control of Your Spending — A budgeting method that helps you allocate every dollar intentionally, useful when balancing debt repayment and investing.
Canada Revenue Agency (2024). Income Tax Folio S3-F6-C1: Interest Deductibility. 🔗
Revenu Québec (2025). Line 231 – Interest on Investment Loans. 🔗
RBC Royal Bank (2026). 2026 Financial Roadmap: Aligning Your Budget, Borrowing and Investments to Your Goals. 🔗
BK Financial Services (2026). Investment Loans in Canada: Strategies, Tax Rules & Quebec Insights. 🔗
cksaksens.com (2026). Canada Student Loan Guide 2026: Interest Rates and Repayment Explained. 🔗

