The Truth About Canadian Bank Loyalty Not Paying Off

Staying with the same bank for your mortgage could cost you roughly $1,860 a year — that’s what Ratehub’s latest comparison found when they lined up the average Big Five five-year fixed rate (4.49%) against the lowest available market rate (4.04%). On a national average home price of $672,784, the difference works out to $155 a month, or $9,300 over a typical five-year term. Here’s what you actually need to know.

Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through them, Britwealth may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We only include products and services that are relevant to the topic.

This article is general information only and does not constitute professional advice. For your specific situation, consult a qualified professional.

$1,860
Potential annual savings by switching mortgage lenders
Ratehub

69%
of Canadians with primary lender for 10+ years
FICO

75%
of consumer banking held by the Big Five
Industry Data

1.15M
mortgage renewals anticipated in 2026
CMHC

Canada’s banking landscape is unusually concentrated. Fewer than 80 commercial banks operate on Canadian soil, and the Big Five — RBC, TD, Scotiabank, BMO, and CIBC — control roughly three-quarters of all consumer business. That concentration creates a market where inertia is the default. Most people never leave. And that’s exactly what the banks are counting on.

If you’re one of the 69% of Canadians who have been with the same primary lender for more than a decade, the question isn’t whether you’re being overcharged — it’s by how much. The gap between loyalty and shopping around is real, and it’s getting wider as the 2026 renewal wave approaches.

Loyalty Has a Price Tag
The average renewal rate from a Big Five lender sits about 45 basis points above the best available market rate. That gap adds up to $1,860 a year on a standard mortgage.

Most Canadians Don’t Switch
Nearly 7 in 10 Canadians stay with their current lender at renewal, even when better rates are available. Behavioural inertia, not loyalty, is the main driver.

2026 Changes the Math
With 1.15 million mortgages set to renew and 60% of all outstanding mortgages up for renewal by the end of 2026, the next window to act is narrow.

Loyalty Points Aren’t Savings
Canadians sit on an estimated $13 to $15 billion in unredeemed loyalty points. Points are nice. Cash in hand from a lower rate is better.

Loyalty Tax
The practice of offering renewal rates significantly above market rates to existing customers who don’t shop around. Lenders can offer renewal rates 1% above the best available rate, and many do.

What the Numbers Actually Say

The figures are hard to ignore. A 45-basis-point spread on a $624,277 mortgage — the amount after a 10% down payment on the national average home price — means monthly payments of $3,452 at the Big Five average rate versus $3,297 at the best available rate. That’s $155 a month that stays in your pocket if you switch. Over five years, you’re looking at $9,300 in potential savings.

I’d call that a meaningful chunk of any household budget. And it’s not just the mortgage. Chequing account fees of $16 a month add up to $960 over the same five-year term. If that money were sitting in a TFSA earning 6%, it would grow to roughly $1,118 — tax-free. The gap between what you’re paying and what you could be paying exists across every product category, from savings accounts to credit cards.

How Much Loyalty Really Costs

The 2026 renewal wave is shaping up to be one of the largest in Canadian history. The Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation reports that 1.15 million mortgage holders will renew in 2026, and about 60% of all outstanding mortgages are set to renew by the end of that year. For those with five-year fixed contracts, payment increases of 15% to 20% are expected. For variable-rate mortgages with fixed payments, the median payment could reach $2,190 by the end of 2027 — a 54% increase from February 2022 levels.

$9,300 Over Five Years
That’s the real-world difference between accepting your lender’s renewal offer and switching to the best available rate. On a standard mortgage, the gap works out to $155 a month — every month, for five years.

What makes this especially painful is that many borrowers who stuck with their lender through the variable-rate spikes of 2022–2023 now face amortization compression — their balances stayed roughly the same while their timelines shortened, forcing higher payments. Some are still paying down the same principal they started with. The banks that collected those higher payments are now offering renewal rates that look suspiciously like a reward for loyalty. In reality, it’s a penalty for not leaving.

What I notice is that the people who switch are almost never the ones who regret it. The ones who stay — and pay the tax — rarely realise what they’re missing until they add it up.

Where Loyalty Costs the Most

Renewing Without Shopping Around

Your current lender must send a renewal statement at least 21 days before your term ends. They usually mail an offer about 30 days before maturity. That offer is rarely the best rate available. Lenders can offer renewal rates 1% above market, a gap that constitutes the so-called Loyalty Tax. The three paths at renewal are straightforward: refinance to restructure debt, switch to another lender, or stay if the offer is competitive. Most people choose option three without ever looking at option two.

Ignoring the Fees That Add Up

That $16 monthly chequing account fee might not feel like much, but over a 25-year mortgage term it grows into thousands of dollars — money that could have been earning compound returns in a TFSA. Many Big Five chequing accounts charge similar fees, and switching to a no-fee account or a digital bank eliminates that cost entirely. It’s not just the mortgage that’s costing you; it’s the whole relationship.

Treating Points as Real Savings

Canadians belong to an average of 15 loyalty programs, and 28% redeem points once a year or less. The $13 to $15 billion sitting unredeemed across the country represents spending power that’s effectively frozen. Scene+ members who redeem within 30 days of earning get 1,000 points equal to $10 — a modest return compared to the hundreds you’d save by switching mortgage lenders. Points are a perk, not a reason to stay.

→ Scroll right to see all columns

Source: Ratehub mortgage comparison
Scenario Interest Rate Monthly Payment Annual Cost 5-Year Cost
Staying with Big Five lender 4.49% $3,452 $41,424 $207,120
Switching to best market rate 4.04% $3,297 $39,564 $197,820
Difference 0.45% $155 $1,860 $9,300

A Practical Guide to Shopping Around

Start Before the Renewal Letter Arrives

You don’t need to wait for your lender’s offer. Switching lenders can secure rate holds up to 120 days before your term ends, giving you a 90-day window that your current lender won’t offer. That buffer matters — in late November 2025, five-year Canadian bond yields jumped from 2.70% to just over 3% in less than two weeks. Having a rate locked in before that kind of movement protects you from market volatility.

Work With a Mortgage Broker

Brokers have access to more than 20 lenders, including monoline lenders and credit unions that often undercut the Big Five. A broker can run the numbers, compare terms, and handle the paperwork for switching lenders. The process is the same as a new mortgage application: income verification, credit check, property appraisal. The difference is that you’re not starting from scratch — you already have a track record of payments.

Know What You’re Signing

Switching lenders usually means a new mortgage contract with new terms. Read the fine print on prepayment penalties, portability options, and renewal clauses. Some lenders offer cash-back incentives or reduced legal fees for switchers — those can offset the appraisal and discharge costs your current lender may charge. If your situation is complex — self-employment income, a recent credit event, or a property that’s lost value since purchase — a qualified legal or mortgage professional can help you avoid costly mistakes.

Factor in the Full Picture

Don’t compare rates in isolation. A lower rate with high switching costs might not save you money in the short term. Calculate the break-even point: how many months will it take for the monthly savings to cover the switching costs? If you’re planning to move within two years, a shorter-term product with a lower rate might make more sense than a five-year fixed. The broader picture of your debt and savings matters just as much as the rate.

Frequently Asked Questions About Switching

Will switching lenders hurt my credit score? ▾
A hard credit check for a mortgage application may cause a temporary dip of a few points, but multiple checks for the same type of product within a short window (typically 14–45 days) count as a single inquiry. The long-term savings far outweigh the short-term impact.
What if my home value has dropped since I bought it? ▾
In areas like the Greater Toronto Area, where values have dropped roughly 25% from the early-2022 peak, you may face a higher loan-to-value ratio. That could mean a higher rate or a requirement for mortgage default insurance. A broker can tell you what’s realistic before you apply.
Can I switch lenders if I’m in a variable-rate mortgage with negative amortization? ▾
It’s possible, but it depends on the new lender’s stress test and your current equity position. If your outstanding balance is higher than the property’s current value, switching becomes difficult. A conversation with a broker is the first step — they’ll tell you if it’s worth pursuing.
How much time do I need to switch lenders before my renewal date? ▾
Start the process 90 to 120 days before your term ends. That gives you time to shop around, lock in a rate, and complete the paperwork. Your current lender’s renewal offer arrives about 30 days before maturity, but by then the best rates may already be gone.
What costs are involved in switching? ▾
Typical costs include an appraisal fee ($300–$500), a discharge fee from your current lender ($200–$400), and possibly legal fees ($500–$1,000). Some new lenders cover these costs as a switching incentive. Always ask before committing.

2026 Will Test Canadian Banking Habits

The scale of the 2026 renewal wave — 1.15 million mortgages, with 60% of all outstanding mortgages expiring by year’s end — means that for the first time in years, a large chunk of Canadian households will be forced to make an active decision about their lender. The ones who treat that decision as a negotiation rather than a formality will be the ones who save thousands.

Naga Parvatharajan, CEO of Ratehub.ca, put it plainly: every single person benefits from shopping around. You only stand to gain by researching the market and making sure you’re getting a competitive rate. The alternative — signing the renewal letter your lender mails you — is the most expensive option on the table.

Remember: this article is general information only. For advice on your specific situation, speak to a qualified professional.

If this was useful, you might also want to read Beyond the Headlines: Understanding the Geopolitical Risks Impacting Your Investments.

Sources and Further Reading

Canada Car Insurance Tips: Association Discounts Explained — A practical look at how loyalty discounts work in other financial products and where they actually save you money.

Building Generational Wealth: Lessons from High-Net-Worth Families — How the habit of shopping around for financial products compounds over decades.

Ratehub (2025). How much is bank loyalty really costing you? 🔗

Shawn Selanders (2025). Bank Loyalty Costs Thousands. 🔗

Tully Mortgages (2025). Mortgage Renewal 2026: The Loyalty Tax. 🔗

The Wise Marketer (2025). Canadians are rethinking loyalty as everyday rewards take priority. 🔗

Share this

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Email

Sam Willy

I’m Sam Willy, one of the bright minds behind BritWealth.com, where I share insights, stories, and fun ideas about a wide range of topics—finance included, but not limited to it! My journey into the world of writing began with a simple hobby: sharing the things that fascinated me. From quirky facts to deeper dives into personal development, I’ve always been curious about the world around me and love passing that knowledge on.
Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted

Disclaimer

The content published on BritWealth.com is provided for general informational and educational purposes only and should not be considered financial, legal, insurance, tax, investment, or professional advice. You should always carry out your own research or seek independent professional guidance before making financial or business decisions.

Some content on this website may contain affiliate links. This means BritWealth.com may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase, at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, BritWealth earns from qualifying purchases.

While we make reasonable efforts to keep information accurate and up to date, BritWealth.com makes no representations or warranties, express or implied, regarding the completeness, accuracy, reliability, suitability, or availability of any content on this website.

Any reliance you place on information found on this site is strictly at your own risk. BritWealth.com will not be liable for any loss, damage, or consequences arising from the use of this website or reliance on its content.

By using this website, you acknowledge and agree to this disclaimer and our terms of use.

Table of Contents

Share This

On Trend

Readers'
Top Picks

Top Tips For Budgeting And Saving Money In Canada

If you’re aiming to get a better grip on your finances in Canada, learning how to budget and save money effectively is key. Canadians, just like folks around the globe, are dealing with rising living costs while juggling various financial responsibilities. Here are some easy-to-follow tips made just for budgeting and saving money in Canada. Know Where Your Money Goes The first thing to do when you want to budget like a pro is to figure out where your money is coming from and where it’s going. Start by writing down all the ways you make money, like your

Read More »

Save Big With No-Contract Phone Plans In Canada

Many Canadians are realizing that ditching traditional phone contracts for no-contract plans can be a game-changer for their wallets. These plans give you mobile service without locking you into long agreements, which means more freedom and often lower prices. Let’s dive into the world of no-contract phone plans in Canada to help you make smart choices that could lead to significant savings. Understanding No-Contract Phone Plans: Freedom and Flexibility No-contract phone plans, also known as prepaid plans, are all about paying for your mobile service upfront without signing a long-term agreement. Think of it like buying gas for your

Read More »
The Real Reason Canadian Insurance Premiums Spike After 25
Finance Insights

The Real Reason Canadian Insurance Premiums Spike After 25

By mid-2025, the average Ontario driver was paying roughly $2,120 for car insurance. Five years earlier, that figure sat closer to $1,600. The gap isn’t just inflation — insurance premiums have been climbing faster than almost any other household expense, and the acceleration has a clear set of causes. Here’s what you actually need to know. Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through them, Britwealth may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We only include products and services that are relevant to the topic. This article is general

Read More »

Tips For Financial Savings In Canada For Structured Independence

Saving money is super important if you want to be financially free in Canada. Lots of Canadians are feeling the pressure of expensive living and are always looking for ways to save more. This article is packed with useful tips made just for Canadians, focusing on different ways to help you make your financial future safe and sound. Understanding the Cost of Living in Canada The cost of living isn’t the same everywhere in Canada; it changes a lot depending on where you are. For example, Statistics Canada says that cities like Vancouver and Toronto are among the most

Read More »

The Millennial Money Paradox: Are We Actually Worse Off?

Canadian millennials face a unique financial challenge. Despite being arguably the most educated and technologically savvy generation, they grapple with unprecedented debt, sky-high housing costs, and stagnant wage growth, fostering a growing sense of financial insecurity. This apparent contradiction – possessing more tools and knowledge yet struggling more than previous generations – is the “Millennial Money Paradox.” The Crushing Weight of Debt One of the most significant contributors to the Millennial Money Paradox is the overwhelming burden of debt. Unlike their parents or grandparents, many Canadian millennials entered adulthood saddled with student loans. A Statistics Canada report indicates that

Read More »

The Ethics of Finance: Guiding Clients with Integrity and Transparency

The ethics of finance in Canada hinge on building trust with clients through unwavering integrity and radical transparency. It’s about more than just following regulations; it’s about prioritizing clients’ well-being and acting in their best interests, even when it means sacrificing short-term personal gains. This article explores the ethical responsibilities of financial professionals in Canada, providing practical guidance on navigating common dilemmas and fostering a culture of ethical excellence. Putting Clients First: The Fiduciary Duty and Beyond While not all financial advisors in Canada are held to a strict fiduciary standard, the principle of acting in the client’s best

Read More »
CANADA
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x