Since August 17, 2024, homebuyers can no longer rely on the seller to cover their agent’s commission as a matter of course. You now have to negotiate and agree to pay your own agent’s fee before you start looking at properties. Here’s what you actually need to know.
The old model was simple: the seller paid both agents out of the sale proceeds, and you never saw the bill. That’s gone. Now you sign a written agreement with your agent upfront that spells out exactly how much you’ll pay and what you get for it. The change comes from a National Association of Realtors class-action settlement that reshaped how commissions work across the US. Brokers can still offer to cover the buyer’s fee as a concession, but it’s no longer baked into the listing.
What a Buyer Representation Agreement Actually Contains
Before an agent can show you a single house, they need you to sign a buyer representation agreement. This isn’t a formality — it’s a legally binding contract that sets the terms of your working relationship. According to the Consumer Federation of America, these agreements typically include several key elements you need to understand before signing.
The agreement will specify the contract duration — usually a set number of weeks or months. It states the compensation structure: a percentage of the purchase price, a flat fee, or an hourly rate, and who pays it (you, the seller, or both). It also outlines the scope of services, which should cover finding properties, setting up showings, and negotiating offers. Most agreements include an exclusive representation clause, meaning you agree to work only with that agent for the duration of the contract. That part is negotiable, so don’t assume you have to accept it as written.
Look for the cancellation policy. Some contracts include a no-fault termination clause that lets either party walk away, usually within a couple of weeks. There should also be a confidentiality clause covering your personal and financial information, a dual agency disclosure if the agent might represent both sides, and an amendments clause explaining how changes to the agreement are handled — important if you switch payment models for a particular listing.
How Much You Could Be Overpaying
The Consumer Policy Center’s research suggests Americans are leaving serious money on the table. Mark Nadel, the report’s author and a CPC senior fellow, attributes the overpayments to a lack of effective price competition among agents. His analysis found that introducing real price competition could transfer an estimated $30 billion or more annually from brokers back to consumers.
The problem is structural. Most people don’t shop around for agent fees the way they would for a mortgage or home inspection. An April 2025 national survey found that 82% of homeowners worried a low-fee broker wouldn’t provide all the services needed to sell a home successfully. Only 42% said they would probably or definitely consider a broker charging 1% or 1.5% rather than the typical 2.5% to 3%. That reluctance keeps fees higher than they need to be.
Nadel argues that real estate agents aren’t comparable to most salespeople. For a typical salesperson, the price of goods or services is set to recover the employer’s costs plus a profit margin. Doubling sales doubles revenue, which justifies a doubled commission. But a home’s sale price isn’t set to recover the seller’s costs plus a margin — it’s set by the market. So there’s no logical reason an agent’s fee should double just because the home’s price doubled. Most of an agent’s fee compensates their time, and while an experienced expert might deserve a higher hourly rate, basing fees on the sale price doesn’t achieve that.
Three Payment Models You’ll Encounter
The new rules open up options beyond the traditional percentage-based commission. Here’s how the main models compare.
→ Scroll right to see all columns
| Model | How It Works | Best For | Watch Out For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Percentage of purchase price | Agent gets a set % of the final sale price, traditionally 2.5–3% for the buyer’s side | Full-service representation; agent is incentivized to get you the best price | Higher cost on expensive homes; no direct link between fee and actual work done |
| Flat fee | Agent charges a fixed dollar amount regardless of the home’s price | Lower-priced homes where a percentage would be too small; limited or defined scope of services | Agent may have less incentive to go the extra mile; may not cover unpredictable needs |
| Hourly rate | Agent bills by the hour for specific tasks like drafting contracts or negotiating | Savvy buyers who can handle most of the search themselves and only need help with key steps | Total cost is unpredictable; agent may rush to keep hours down |
Mike Hardy, managing partner of the Southwest region for Churchill Mortgage, suggests a tiered system may emerge: a premium all-inclusive service at 2% to 3% for full service, stripped-down models for less, and an attorney-type model offering hourly services for drafting contracts or negotiating prices. Armstead Jones, a strategic real estate advisor at HouseCashin, notes that flat fees are typically used when the selling price is too low and the agent needs fair compensation, or for a limited set of pre-selected services.
Junk Fees You Should Watch For
Beyond the commission itself, there’s a growing trend of transaction fees that can catch you off guard at closing. The Consumer Policy Center estimates buyers and sellers collectively pay nearly $2 billion annually in these fees. Wendy Gilch, a CPC fellow who co-authored the report, called that estimate conservative.
These fees go by names like document storage fees and administrative fees. They’re due at closing as immediate out-of-pocket expenses — not spread over a 30-year mortgage. In 2026, Kelly MacDonald encountered a $425 fee added to her contract by an agent in a Cincinnati suburb. Her mother, who works in commercial real estate, spotted it during contract review. Reddit commenters identified it as a junk fee.
Real estate agent April Green, with 15 years of experience in South Florida, calls these fees “crap” and “greedy.” She’s seen agents add fees of $495 or similar amounts “just because they could.” Gilch says the fees have spread nationwide and appear in most home sales today. Some agents choose to cover them rather than pass them along, but when a client refuses to pay, it usually comes out of the agent’s commission rather than being waived by the brokerage.
Gilch advises homebuyers to look for admin fees in contracts under various names and challenge them. It often works because agents risk losing much larger commissions over smaller fees. Fees are sometimes added without proper disclosure, days or hours before closing. In 2026, Florida homebuyers sued Compass over transaction fees, accusing illegal addition; the case was voluntarily dismissed.
Mistakes That Cost You Money
The most expensive mistake is not negotiating the fee at all. Many buyers assume the terms are fixed and non-negotiable. They’re not. The agreement you sign is a contract between you and your agent, and like any contract, its terms can be discussed and changed before you sign.
Another common error is signing an exclusive representation clause without understanding what it means. You’re locked into working with that agent for the duration of the contract, even if you find a better fit elsewhere. If the contract doesn’t have a no-fault termination clause, you could be stuck. Negotiate for an out before you sign.
Don’t assume the seller will cover your agent’s fee. Under the new rules, the seller can still offer to pay it as a concession, but it’s not guaranteed. Your agreement needs to specify who pays and what happens if the seller’s offer doesn’t cover the full amount. If you skip that detail, you could be on the hook for the difference at closing.
Finally, don’t ignore the junk fees. A $400 fee might seem small next to a $400,000 purchase, but it’s real money you’re handing over for something that may not have been properly disclosed. Challenge it. The worst that happens is they say no, and you’ve lost nothing.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I have to pay my buyer’s agent upfront? ▾
Can the seller still pay my agent’s commission? ▾
What’s a reasonable fee for a buyer’s agent under the new rules? ▾
What are real estate junk fees and can I refuse to pay them? ▾
Is the NAR class-action settlement still accepting claims? ▾
The Bottom Line on Agent Fees
The old commission model was convenient but expensive, and it hid the true cost of buyer representation. The new rules force transparency, which is a good thing if you use it. Negotiate the fee, read the contract, challenge junk fees, and don’t assume the seller will pick up the tab. The agents who provide real value will justify their fee. The ones who rely on the old system to hide their costs will have to adapt.
Remember: this article is general information only. For advice on your specific situation, speak to a qualified professional.
Sources and Further Reading
Home Price Negotiation Tips for Buying a House — Practical strategies for negotiating the best price on your next home purchase.
CNBC Make It (2024). Homebuyers now have to negotiate agent fees upfront. 🔗
Consumer Policy Center (2025). Most home buyers and sellers are routinely charged junk fees. 🔗
Consumer Federation of America (2024). Required Buyer Agency Contracts Report. 🔗
HousingWire (2025). Agent fee overpayment report. 🔗
Inman (2026). Real estate brokerage transaction fees survey. 🔗
NPR (2026). Homebuyer junk fees. 🔗
National Association of Realtors (2024). Final reminder of August 17 practice change implementation. 🔗
Top Class Actions (2026). $120M NAR real estate commission class action settlement. 🔗

