Real estate purchase agreements aren’t all the same. While most buyers use a standard mortgage to finance a home, a smaller but significant number enter lease-purchase agreements — contracts that combine a rental lease with an option to buy the property later. In 2021, an estimated 2.1% of homebuyers had signed this type of agreement, according to Pew Charitable Trusts research. Here’s what you actually need to know.
This article is general information only and does not constitute professional advice. For your specific situation, consult a qualified professional.
Lease-purchase agreements are often marketed as a pathway to homeownership for people who can’t qualify for a mortgage right now. But the data tells a more complicated story. These contracts sit in a legal gray area between renting and owning, and buyers can end up with the costs of homeownership — property taxes, repairs, above-market rent — without the protections that come with a mortgage or a standard lease.
Where Lease-Purchase Agreements Fall Short
The central risk is straightforward: you can pay thousands above market rent, cover major repairs, and still never own the home. Pew’s analysis of survey data found that only 64% of people who had used a lease-purchase agreement in the past owned a home in 2021, compared with 80% of those who had used a mortgage. That gap of 16 percentage points represents a lot of people who paid into a system that didn’t deliver ownership.
Part of the problem is structural. Lease-purchase buyers often take on homeowner-level costs during the rental period — 40% reported being responsible for paying property taxes, and 14% had to cover major repairs — without building equity or having foreclosure protections. If they fall behind, they can end up in landlord-tenant court facing eviction, and the down payment or option fee they put up at the start can be forfeited entirely.
And the legal framework is thin. Just five states — Maine, Maryland, North Carolina, Texas, and Virginia — have laws that specifically govern lease-purchase agreements. Everywhere else, these contracts fall under general landlord-tenant law, which doesn’t recognize that the buyer has any ownership stake, even if they’ve made a down payment or spent years covering costs the landlord would normally bear.
How Lease-Purchase Agreements Work
In theory, the arrangement gives a renter time to improve their credit score and save for a down payment while living in the home they hope to buy. In practice, the terms of the option contract matter enormously. A contract that doesn’t set a fixed purchase price — and about two-thirds of survey respondents reported exactly that — leaves the buyer exposed to price increases later. Legal aid attorneys in Pew’s research described cases where sellers raised the price each year, effectively pricing the buyer out of a purchase they’d been working toward for years.
Common Pitfalls That Derail Buyers
Several features common in lease-purchase agreements make it harder, not easier, to become a homeowner. Here are the ones that show up most often in the research.
Balloon Payments
Some contracts include a large one-time payment near the end of the term. In Pew’s 2022 survey, 20% of respondents said their agreement had a balloon payment listed or disclosed. These payments can make it nearly impossible to exercise the option, especially if the buyer hasn’t been able to save enough on top of above-market rent.
No Fixed Purchase Price
Roughly two-thirds of survey respondents reported their contract didn’t set a purchase price. Without that figure locked in, the seller can increase the price over time. One legal aid attorney in Indiana described cases where the seller raised the price each year as the buyer made repairs, saying “now the property is worth more, so now you’re going to have to pay me more to buy it.”
Nonrefundable Option Fees
The upfront payment that secures the option to buy is often nonrefundable. If you can’t exercise the option — for any reason — you lose that money. Unlike a mortgage down payment, which builds equity from day one, an option fee buys you the chance to buy later, with no guarantee.
Legal Gray Area in Disputes
When something goes wrong, most states treat lease-purchase buyers as renters, not homeowners. That means disputes end up in landlord-tenant court, where the focus is eviction, not foreclosure. Buyers rarely get credit for the down payment or option fee they’ve made. Florida is a partial exception — its courts have interpreted state law to treat lease-purchase agreements as mortgages in some cases, meaning buyers go through foreclosure rather than eviction and are more likely to recover their investment.
→ Scroll right to see all columns
| State | Landlord-Tenant Law Applies? | Must Disclose Terms? | Must Record Option? | Extra Time to Catch Up? | Can Recoup Upfront Payments? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Maine | Not clarified | Yes | Yes | Sometimes | Yes |
| Maryland | Yes | No | No | No | No |
| North Carolina | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | No |
| Texas | Yes | Yes | Sometimes | Yes | Sometimes |
| Virginia | Yes | No | No | Yes | Yes |
Even in the five states that regulate lease-purchase agreements, the protections are inconsistent. Maine gives buyers the strongest package — required disclosure, public recording, and the right to recoup upfront payments. Maryland clarifies that landlord-tenant law applies but offers none of the other protections. Texas requires recording only for agreements longer than three years and allows sellers to withhold option fees in some circumstances.
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the difference between a lease-purchase and a standard lease? ▾
Can I lose money in a lease-purchase agreement? ▾
What happens if the seller raises the price? ▾
Are lease-purchase agreements regulated in Canada? ▾
What should I look for in a lease-purchase contract? ▾
What to Watch For Before You Sign
Lease-purchase agreements can work — but the odds are not as good as the marketing suggests. The data from Pew’s research shows that conversion rates vary wildly, from 22% to 71% across different companies, and that many buyers end up paying above-market rent and covering homeowner costs without ever owning the home.
If you’re considering a lease-purchase agreement, the strongest protections come from having a fixed purchase price in the contract, no balloon payment, and clear terms on what happens to your option fee if you can’t exercise the option. A real estate lawyer who reviews the specific contract is worth the cost — the alternative can be losing thousands of dollars and still not owning a home.
For most buyers, a standard mortgage remains the safest and most cost-effective way to finance a home. If a mortgage isn’t available now, it’s worth exploring whether improving your credit score or saving for a larger down payment could get you there, rather than entering a lease-purchase agreement with terms that may not deliver ownership.
Remember: this article is general information only. For advice on your specific situation, speak to a qualified professional.
Sources and Further Reading
Understanding House Loan Term Options for Buying in Canada — Compare mortgage term lengths and how they affect your monthly payments and total interest.
Land Purchase Checklist: Tips for Buying a House in Canada — A step-by-step guide to the home-buying process, from offer to closing.
Pew Charitable Trusts (2025). When Mortgages Are Unavailable, Potential Homebuyers Turn to Lease-Purchase Agreements. 🔗
Pew Charitable Trusts (2022). Millions of Americans Have Used Risky Financing Arrangements to Buy Homes. 🔗
Pew Charitable Trusts (2021). Home Financing Incidence Survey. 🔗
National Consumer Law Center. State Laws Governing Lease-Purchase Agreements. Referenced in Pew Charitable Trusts (2025).