You sign a lease for a retail space assuming the anchor tenant’s presence is baked into the deal. Then the anchor closes, your foot traffic vanishes, and you discover your rent doesn’t automatically drop — because the co-tenancy clause in your lease doesn’t work the way you thought. The 2020 Ontario Court of Appeal decision in Old Navy (Canada) Inc. v. The Eglinton Town Centre Inc. made this painfully clear: a named key store had filed for bankruptcy, yet the court ruled against Old Navy because the centre stayed over 90% leased and shopper traffic hadn’t declined. Here’s what you actually need to know.
Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through them, Britwealth may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We only include products and services that are relevant to the topic.
This article is general information only and does not constitute professional advice. For your specific situation, consult a qualified professional.
Co-tenancy clauses show up most often in retail and mixed-use centres where smaller tenants rely on the draw of a big-name anchor. The clause ties your rent — or your obligation to stay open — to whether that anchor, or a minimum percentage of the centre, remains operating. But as the Old Navy case demonstrates, the clause’s text, the actual commercial impact, and whether the landlord offered a substitute all feed into how a court reads it. That makes due diligence on these clauses a practical necessity, not a legal footnote.
If you’re new to commercial leasing, start with the essential guide to leasing commercial properties in Canada before digging into the fine print of co-tenancy.
Why a Triggered Clause Doesn’t Guarantee Relief
The gap between what tenants think a co-tenancy clause does and what it actually delivers can cost real money. In the Old Navy case, Danier Leather — a named key store in Old Navy’s lease — filed for bankruptcy in February 2016. Old Navy asserted its co-tenancy clause, arguing it should pay only 50% of Minimum Rent for the first three months and 25% thereafter. The Ontario Superior Court disagreed. The centre remained over 90% leased, foot traffic hadn’t dropped, and Old Navy couldn’t show it had suffered any sales loss. The Court of Appeal upheld the decision in 2020.
The Old Navy file also carried a detail worth remembering: the landlord’s termination right had been agreed in the letter of intent but was left out of the executed lease. The court only restored it through rectification. You can’t underwrite a deal on the assumption a court will repair the lease for you — the document you read in diligence is the document you own.
What a Co-Tenancy Clause Actually Does
The logic behind these clauses is straightforward: smaller tenants sign up for the traffic the anchor generates, not for the parking lot. They bargain for a condition — pay full rent as long as the draw is still there. Per an ICSC-published paper by Cory Sherman and John Shrives of Sherman Brown, co-tenancy provisions rest on the idea that a centre’s ability to attract customers is tied either to specific large retailers or to the proportion of the centre that’s open for business. The structural consequence is that anchor income and CRU income are contractually welded together — the cheap tenant becomes load-bearing for the expensive ones.
How the Trigger and Remedy Are Actually Drafted
The ICSC paper breaks operating requirements into structures used alone or in combination: a specific named tenant or key store must be open and operating; tenants occupying anchor premises or premises above a stated square footage must be open; or an occupancy threshold based on number of tenants or percentage of the centre’s rentable area must be met. A named-store trigger is countable and straightforward to price. A percentage trigger is calculable, which means it’s easier to fight about.
The remedy menu matters just as much as the trigger. Common options include:
- Abated rent — either a pre-set rate that applies once co-tenancy fails, or the current rent reduced by a stated percentage
- Percentage rent — the tenant pays a share of gross revenue during the failure instead of base rent
- Right to go dark — the tenant can close for the duration of the failure
- Right to terminate — if the failure runs past a specified length of time, the tenant can walk away
The sample provision appended to the ICSC paper gives a concrete sense of scale: the operating requirement is two key stores plus CRU stores comprising 25% or more of the project’s GLA. If unmet for 120 consecutive days, the tenant may either close for business or, instead of Minimum Rent, Percentage Rent and Additional Rent, pay an amount equal to 50% of that total each month while still covering all utilities.
→ Scroll right to see all columns
| Trigger Type | How It Works | Diligence Difficulty |
|---|---|---|
| Named store | Lists specific tenants; one closes = trigger | Low — countable and verifiable |
| Percentage of GLA | Requires X% of centre square footage to be open | Medium — denominator and “open” definition negotiable |
| Combination | Named stores + percentage threshold | Medium-high — both conditions must be tracked |
| Operating vs. leased | “Open and operating” vs. merely “leased” | High — one-word difference with major consequences |
Landlord-side protections are the other half of the equation. Two provisions decide how much risk the landlord actually carries. A replacement store right lets the landlord cure a co-tenancy failure by substituting a comparable tenant — the ICSC paper suggests objective criteria like a replacement that occupies at least 90% of the vacating store’s former space and is a national retailer with at least 15 stores under the same trade name. A sunset clause caps how long the tenant can sit on abated rent; in the sample, if the operating requirement is still unmet during the 12-month period following the initial failure period, either party may terminate on not less than 6 months’ written notice. A lease with a named-store trigger, no replacement right, and no sunset is the worst version of this instrument you can inherit.
For more on how lease obligations transfer when circumstances change, read our guide on understanding lease obligation transfers when renting commercial spaces.
Common Gaps in Co-Tenancy Due Diligence
Treating the rent roll as the full picture
Every buyer verifies the rent roll. Far fewer read the leases behind it. Co-tenancy clauses are routinely omitted from lease abstracts and rent roll summaries. The only way to find them is to demand complete executed leases and all amendments as a condition of due diligence, with enough time to actually read them after delivery. If the leases don’t arrive, that’s reason to extend the condition or walk — not reason to assume the risk isn’t there.
Assuming anchor closure means automatic relief
The Old Navy case is the clearest warning here. A named key store went bankrupt, but the court still found for the landlord because the centre remained substantially leased and traffic hadn’t dropped. The outcome turned on the specific drafting, the actual commercial impact, and whether a substitute was offered. Litigation is not a diligence strategy.
Missing the operating-versus-leased distinction
An anchor that stops operating without physically leaving can still satisfy its own lease covenant to pay rent while simultaneously breaking the co-tenancy requirement for every other tenant. When reading a trigger, confirm whether it says “operating” or merely “leased.” That one-word difference can carry a seven-figure tail.
Ignoring Quebec registration requirements
For Quebec commercial leases, any lease with a term of 3+ years must be registered in the land registry under CCQ Art. 2936, or a building purchaser can terminate the lease with no compensation. This applies to co-tenancy clauses embedded in those leases — if the lease isn’t registered, the clause’s protection could vanish on a sale. Registration takes 1–2 weeks and costs a few hundred dollars, but it’s non-optional for any lease with significant remaining term.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does every tenant in a centre have a co-tenancy clause? ▾
If an anchor closes, do tenants automatically get to cut rent? ▾
How do I find co-tenancy clauses if the seller only gives me a rent roll? ▾
Is a centre with co-tenancy clauses a bad buy? ▾
Can I renegotiate a co-tenancy clause after buying the centre? ▾
What should I do during the due diligence period? ▾
What the Conditional Period Is Really Buying You
Co-tenancy clauses convert a risk you can’t control — an anchor’s business decisions — into a direct hit to your income. But that hit isn’t automatic, and it isn’t uniform. The same clause that looks like protection in a rent roll can turn into a litigation headache when tested. The work happens before you close: demand the leases, read every co-tenancy provision, build the trigger matrix, and stress-test the NOI on the downside. A clause with a named-store trigger, no replacement right, and no sunset is a liability, not an asset. A clause with objective cure provisions and a hard sunset is a manageable risk you can price.
If this was useful, you might also want to read Guide to Leasing a Regional Mall Space in Canada.
Sources and Further Reading
Understanding Lease Security Deposit Rules for Commercial Spaces in Canada — What you need to know about deposit requirements, interest rules, and return timelines across provinces.
Tips for Renting a Highway-Facing Retail Lease in Canada — Practical considerations for visibility, access, and lease terms on high-traffic retail strips.
ICSC, Sherman & Shrives, Sherman Brown. “The (Almost) Perfect Co-Tenancy Clause.” 🔗
WeirFoulds LLP (2020). Co-tenancy clause thresholds in the Canadian market. 🔗
Ontario Court of Appeal. Old Navy (Canada) Inc. v. The Eglinton Town Centre Inc., 2020 ONCA 679. 🔗
SiLaw (2026). Commercial Lease Negotiation for SME Canada 2026. 🔗
Commercial Tenancies Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. L.7. 🔗
Civil Code of Québec, Arts. 1851–1891, 2936. LégisQuébec, current to 2026. 🔗