Canada’s real estate market is caught between competing policy forces. Interest rate hikes that pushed borrowing costs to multi-decade highs have triggered a wave of developer insolvencies—on track to hit 240 in 2024, 57% higher than 2023 and above global financial crisis levels according to the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy. At the same time, provincial and municipal governments have layered on foreign buyer taxes, vacancy levies, rent controls, and short-term rental restrictions that are reshaping who can buy, what can be built, and how properties can be used. Here’s what you actually need to know.
This article is general information only and does not constitute professional advice. For your specific situation, consult a qualified professional.
Those numbers tell a story of a market under structural pressure, not just a cyclical downturn. Policy decisions at every level of government are driving the change—some intentional, some collateral. And the effects are showing up differently in Vancouver, Toronto, Calgary, and Montreal, which makes a one-size-fits-all strategy risky for anyone investing in real estate right now.
Why Policy Changes Hit Harder Than Market Cycles
Real estate has always been local, but the current divergence across Canadian markets goes beyond the usual neighbourhood differences. It reflects distinct policy regimes colliding with local economic conditions.
Take the RBC Economics assessment from fall 2026: Vancouver home resales fell nearly 8% month-over-month in September, with the composite MLS Home Price Index down 5.5% from a year ago. The city has been in a four-year slump. Toronto’s tentative five-month recovery went off course in September, with resales dropping 5.2% month-over-month and the condo index falling 6.7% from a year earlier. Meanwhile Calgary has held relatively steady, with single-detached resales up 4.4% from a year ago.
The difference isn’t just about oil prices or immigration patterns. Vancouver and Toronto both carry foreign buyer taxes and vacancy levies. Calgary doesn’t. Montreal sits somewhere in the middle—inventory is up 20% from a year ago, driven by the strongest influx of sellers in six years, but prices have largely flatlined rather than fallen sharply.
Higher borrowing costs are the obvious culprit, but they don’t operate in a vacuum. Developers who bought land during the low-rate era are now carrying construction loans at prime plus 5.8% or more, while municipal approval delays and provincial rent controls limit their ability to adjust revenue. The result: a growing number of projects entering receivership, from small Brampton townhouse sites to the high-profile $1.6-billion The One condo tower in Toronto.
Key Terms and Takeaways for the New Policy Landscape
The Policy Toolkit Reshaping Canadian Real Estate
Understanding how each policy actually works—and where it applies—is the difference between making a calculated investment and walking into a trap. Here’s what’s currently in force across Canada’s major markets.
Foreign Buyer Taxes
British Columbia and Ontario have both introduced taxes on residential property purchases by foreign buyers—defined as individuals who are not Canadian citizens or permanent residents. These are provincial taxes applied at the time of purchase, and they’ve cooled demand in Vancouver and Toronto by effectively adding a significant upfront cost for international capital. The exact rate varies by province and has been adjusted over time, but the policy direction is clear: foreign capital is being actively discouraged in those markets.
Vacancy and Surtax Levies
Vancouver and Toronto have both levied property surtaxes on homes deemed to be vacant—properties that are not occupied by an owner or long-term tenant for a specified period each year. Other municipalities are considering similar measures. The stated goal is to increase housing supply by pushing empty units into the rental market or forcing sales. For investors, this means holding a property vacant as a speculative play now carries an annual tax cost that can eat deeply into any expected capital gain.
Rent Controls
Several provinces and municipalities have controls on how much rent can be increased annually, which constrains an investor’s ability to raise rents to match market rates or cover rising costs. The specific rules vary by province—some tie increases to inflation, others set fixed caps—but the effect is the same: rental income growth is limited by regulation, not by market demand. This matters most for investors who bought at high prices expecting rents to rise quickly enough to cover mortgage payments.
Short-Term Rental Restrictions
Many Canadian municipalities now restrict or completely ban short-term rentals in certain housing types. Condo corporations may also adopt their own restrictions on the proportion of units in a building that can be rented out at all. For investors who bought units specifically for Airbnb-style income, these restrictions can fundamentally break the business model. Always check both municipal bylaws and condo corporation rules before purchasing a property with short-term rental plans.
Interest Rate Policy
The Bank of Canada raised its benchmark rate from 0.25% to 5% over 2022 and 2023, then began cutting in the summer of 2024. The impact on real estate has been brutal for leveraged investors. The prime lending rate at major banks jumped from 2.45% to 7.2% during the hiking cycle, meaning a developer who borrowed at prime plus 5.8% in 2021 saw their interest rate go from roughly 8.25% to 13% or higher. That’s the kind of math that turns a profitable project into a default. The rate cuts since summer 2024 have provided some relief, but borrowing remains expensive compared to the 2020-2021 era, and the RBC Economics outlook warns that the road ahead is likely to be bumpy and uneven across markets.
Construction and Development Policy
Municipal approval processes, development charges, and zoning rules all affect how quickly—and at what cost—new housing can be built. The research shows that residential construction costs across Canada’s major cities are now 81% higher than in 2017, and 107% higher in the Toronto region specifically, per Statistics Canada data. Part of that is material and labour inflation, but part is also the cost of carrying land through lengthy approval processes. Some municipalities are experimenting with streamlined approvals and density bonuses, but the impact has been limited so far.
→ Scroll right to see all columns
| Market | Resales (Sept MoM) | Price Trend (YoY) | Key Policy Factor |
|---|---|---|---|
| Vancouver | −8% | −5.5% (MLS HPI) | Foreign buyer tax, vacancy levy, 4-year slump |
| Toronto | −5.2% | −6.7% (condo index) | Foreign buyer tax, vacancy levy, abundant condo supply |
| Calgary | Stable | −1% (single-detached) | No foreign buyer tax, balanced supply-demand |
| Montreal | Calm | Flat (condo), +0.4% (single-family) | Supply up 20% YoY, displacement from new completions |
Mistakes Investors Make With Policy Changes
The policy environment has shifted faster than many investors have adjusted. Here are the most common errors the research highlights.
Assuming Rent Can Always Rise to Market
Rent controls in several provinces cap annual increases below market rates in hot areas. An investor who buys at a high price expecting to raise rent by 10% a year may find themselves limited to 2-3%, turning a projected positive cash flow into a negative one. The research notes that in the Toronto region, the asking price for preconstruction condos nearly doubled from 2017 through 2024 to roughly $1,345 per square foot—meaning a 550-square-foot unit costs about $740,000. At that price, the rent often doesn’t cover the mortgage and expenses, and rent controls prevent closing the gap.
Ignoring Condo Corporation Rental Restrictions
Condo corporations can adopt restrictions on the proportion of units in a building that can be rented out, or ban short-term rentals entirely. An investor who buys without reviewing the condo’s rental bylaws may find they cannot rent the unit at all, or that they’re on a waitlist while other owners fill the rental quota. This is a policy layer that operates at the building level, not the municipal level, and it’s easy to miss.
Underestimating Transaction Costs in a Policy-Driven Market
Transaction costs for sellers are typically upward of 5% of the price—including agent commissions, legal fees, inspections, and other third-party expenses. In a market where policy changes can shift prices quickly, those costs become a larger percentage of any potential gain. The research notes that real estate is illiquid compared to other assets, and the combination of high transaction costs and policy uncertainty makes it harder to exit a position quickly if conditions change.
Overlooking the Leverage Risk in a Rising-Rate Environment
Leverage works both ways. The research quotes Sabine Ghali, managing director of Buttonwood Property Management in Toronto: “As the property appreciates, the return on initial investment for your down payment can be much higher due to the leveraged amount.” But when rates rise, the loan principal stays the same while carrying costs increase. Investors who bought with only the minimum 20% down payment on investment properties are most exposed. The research flags this as a “potentially perilous time for investors with only a 20-per-cent down payment to get into the market.”
Ignoring Local Market Divergence
Real estate markets are notoriously local, and policy differences amplify that. Calgary has held relatively steady through the rate cycle, with stable prices and balanced supply and demand. Vancouver has been in a four-year slump. Toronto’s recovery attempt collapsed after five months. Montreal is seeing supply surge. An investor who treats “the Canadian market” as a single entity will make bad decisions. The research is explicit: “different dynamics will be at play in Sudbury and suburban Montreal.”
Frequently Asked Questions
Do foreign buyer taxes apply to all of Canada? ▾
How do vacancy taxes work in practice? ▾
Can a condo corporation ban rentals entirely? ▾
Are rent controls the same across Canada? ▾
What happens to a preconstruction condo buyer if the developer goes insolvent? ▾
Are there lower-cost ways to invest in Canadian real estate without buying a property? ▾
What the Policy Direction Means for Your Next Move
The policy environment isn’t going to simplify. Foreign buyer taxes, vacancy levies, rent controls, and short-term rental restrictions are becoming permanent features of Canada’s major urban markets, not temporary experiments. Interest rate policy will continue to shift, but the era of ultra-low rates that fuelled the 2010s boom is unlikely to return soon.
For investors, the practical takeaway is that local knowledge matters more than ever. A strategy that works in Calgary—where supply and demand are balanced and policy intervention is lighter—may fail in Vancouver or Toronto, where multiple policy layers constrain both income and exit options. The research suggests that investors who own their home outright and don’t need to borrow heavily may find opportunities in the current downturn, while those relying on minimum down payments face real risk.
If this was useful, you might also want to read Are Canadian Home Prices Being Driven by Speculation or Real Demand?
Remember: this article is general information only. For advice on your specific situation, speak to a qualified professional.
Sources and Further Reading
The Canadian Neighbourhoods Where Renters Outnumber Owners — Explores the demographic shift behind declining homeownership and where it’s most concentrated.
Statistics Canada (2022). Canadian Housing Survey 2021: Homeownership rates and renter household growth. 🔗
Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy (2024). Real estate, rental and leasing insolvency data, January–May 2024, as reported by The Globe and Mail. 🔗
RBC Economics (2026). More Turbulence Hits Canada’s Housing Markets to Kick Off Fall, by Robert Hogue. 🔗
The Globe and Mail (2024). Real estate investment property guide: what you need to know. 🔗
The Conversation (2024). From NIMBY to YIMBY: how localized real estate investment trusts can help address Canada’s housing crisis. 🔗
Statistics Canada (2024). Residential building construction price index, 2017–2024, as reported by The Globe and Mail. 🔗



