Half of Gen Z workers in Canada aren’t interested in management promotions, according to a Robert Half survey. At the same time, 59 per cent of current supervisors have either quit or plan to leave their roles, an Express Employment Professionals study found. The leadership pipeline is narrowing from both ends — younger workers don’t want traditional authority positions, and the people filling them now are walking away. Here’s what you actually need to know.
This article is general information only and does not constitute professional advice. For your specific situation, consult a qualified professional.
These numbers point to something bigger than a hiring problem. They reflect a fundamental shift in what people expect from work and from the people who lead them. Nearly 90 per cent of Gen Z want work aligned with their values and contributing positively to society, according to a 2025 Deloitte survey. Taking a management role in a company that doesn’t share those values feels like endorsing an institution they don’t support. The older generation that held those roles is retiring, and the gap is set to widen unless businesses rethink how they train, support, and define leadership.
The Leadership Gap — What Breaks When Trust Erodes
SHRM research found companies with strong ethical foundations see 40 per cent lower turnover rates and are twice as likely to outperform competitors. For Canadian businesses already facing a tightening labor supply — population growth slowed to 0.5 per cent in the year to July 2026, the slowest since the Second World War — losing talent because of a trust deficit is a risk the economy can’t afford.
The diversity gap in leadership is another measure of the same problem. Women now hold 29 per cent of TSX board seats, up from 11 per cent a decade ago, according to the Canadian Securities Administrators’ tenth annual review. But progress in executive officer positions has been markedly slower. From the fifth year to the tenth year of reporting, the percentage of issuers with a woman CEO grew just 1 per cent. For Indigenous peoples, visible minorities, and people with disabilities, representation on boards sits below 5 per cent across all categories. The slow pace isn’t unique to Canada — Deloitte’s Women in the Boardroom, eighth edition describes it as a global phenomenon — but it signals a leadership culture that hasn’t fully opened its top ranks.
What Ethical Leadership Actually Looks Like Now
These four elements aren’t theoretical. Companies that adopt them see measurable results. The Ethics & Compliance Initiative found employees are 68 per cent more likely to report misconduct when they see a strong ethical commitment from leadership, and organizations with robust ethics programs are 42 per cent less likely to experience misconduct.
Where Most Efforts Fall Short
The gap between stated values and actual practice is where trust goes to die. Many organizations have mission statements about inclusion and integrity, but their structures and incentives tell a different story.
Ignoring what younger workers actually want
Traditional management models assume people want to climb a hierarchy. Gen Z has made it clear they don’t. The Robert Half survey showing 50 per cent uninterested in managerial promotions is a signal that the reward structure needs to change, not that younger workers lack ambition. They prefer career growth through lateral moves and skill-building opportunities that don’t involve managing others. Businesses that keep offering the same promotion track without rethinking what leadership means will find the pipeline getting drier.
Diversity targets without teeth
The CSA data shows a clear correlation between targets and outcomes. The table below tells the story.
→ Scroll right to see all columns
| Measure | With Measure | Without Measure | Gap |
|---|---|---|---|
| Target for women on boards | 35% women | 22% women | +13 pp |
| Written policy on women on boards | 33% women | 20% women | +13 pp |
| Term limits adopted | 25% of issuers | — | — |
Yet only 44 per cent of issuers had adopted such targets, and only a quarter had adopted term limits. The gap between what works and what’s actually being done is wide.
Treating ethics as a compliance checkbox
A code of conduct sitting in a handbook that nobody reads does nothing. People need to know how values play out in real situations — what fairness means when explaining a disclosure or how to handle a vulnerable customer. Without that clarity, values stay abstract and get applied inconsistently. Credibility comes from reinforcement when leaders recognize good decisions and address lapses, showing standards are real, not optional.
Building a Leadership Pipeline That Works
Closing the leadership gap requires changes to structure, policy, and daily practice. Here’s what the research points to.
Flatten the hierarchy
Gen Z particularly values teamwork, shared decision-making, and flatter hierarchies. Companies can include younger employees in key meetings, offer opportunities to co-create projects, and focus on mentorship and growth rather than top-down management. Some Canadian companies have adopted matrix-style structures with multiple reporting lines, which flatten hierarchies while maintaining clear responsibilities and accountability. Success depends on clearly defining roles, setting expectations, and identifying decision-makers.
Update policies for flexibility and well-being
Businesses can update policy handbooks to include comprehensive health benefits, wellness programs to prevent burnout, and flexible working hours or hybrid approaches. Canadian Equality Consulting operates remotely with flexible hours and optional Fridays, allowing teams to set their own schedules — a shift that led to improved performance and well-being. A flat organizational structure promotes independence and accountability, with team members trusted to manage their time while remaining fully responsible for their work and client commitments.
Create real feedback loops
Annual or semi-annual reviews don’t cut it anymore. Organizations can adopt informal, consistent approaches: direct access to senior leaders, monthly coaching check-ins, and real-time feedback channels. This helps identify and address root causes when burnout is rising in middle management. The SHRM research showing 40 per cent lower turnover in companies with strong ethical foundations suggests that when people feel heard and supported, they stay.
Adopt targets and term limits
The evidence from the CSA’s decade of data is clear: targets work. Issuers with targets for women on boards had 13 percentage points more women in those seats. Written policies added another 13 points. Term limits, though only adopted by a quarter of issuers, help create turnover that opens seats for diverse candidates. Companies serious about ethical leadership should set measurable goals for representation at all levels and tie them to accountability mechanisms.
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the difference between ethical leadership and compliance? ▾
Why don’t Gen Z workers want management roles? ▾
How many Canadian companies have diversity targets for their boards? ▾
What’s the business case for ethical leadership? ▾
How can a company apply consistent ethical standards across different markets? ▾
The Opportunity in This Moment
The leadership gap in Canadian business is real, and it’s widening. But it’s also a chance to build something better than the old model. Gen Z isn’t rejecting leadership — they’re rejecting a version of it that demanded long hours, rigid hierarchy, and personal sacrifice for uncertain rewards. The workers who do want to lead want to do it differently: collaboratively, transparently, and in organizations whose values match their own.
The data from the CSA’s decade of disclosure shows that targets and policies work when they’re actually adopted. The SHRM research shows that strong ethical foundations improve retention and performance. The Ethics & Compliance Initiative shows that leadership commitment drives better outcomes. The pieces are there. The question is whether Canadian businesses will put them together before the pipeline runs dry.
Remember: this article is general information only. For advice on your specific situation, speak to a qualified professional.
If this was useful, you might also want to read Unlocking Employee Potential: Fostering a Culture of Continuous Growth in Canada.
Sources and Further Reading
Canadian Businesses, Are You Ready for the Next Global Disruption? — Explores how Canadian businesses can build resilience in an uncertain global environment, relevant to the crisis leadership context discussed above.
Marcie Hawranik (2025). Gen Z and the leadership pipeline. Canadian Business. 🔗
BLG (2025). Unfinished Business: A Decade of Data on Women in Canadian Corporate Leadership. 🔗
Canadian Securities Administrators (2024). CSA Multilateral Staff Notice 58-317 Review of Disclosure Regarding Women on Boards and in Executive Officer Positions. 🔗
Ethics & Compliance Initiative (2024). Engaging Ethical Standards That Can Be Lived. Communicate Magazine. 🔗
SHRM (2025). Global Worker Project. 🔗
Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada (2023). Diversity of Boards of Directors and Senior Management of Federal Distributing Corporations. 🔗
Canadian Chamber of Commerce (2022). Championing Women in Business in Canada. 🔗
